Transcript 0:00 As the saying goes, the calm comes before the storm. In the case of Brazil Supreme Court, its current crisis came after a period of glory and renown. 0:09 [dramatic music] In September 2025, the Supreme Court made history and became a global reference. 0:17 Breaking with Brazil's long tradition of impunity for military interference in politics, the court analyzed a wealth of evidence and convicted former President Jair Bolsonaro and top-ranking military officers for attempting a coup after the 2022 election. 0:33 That same month, Edson Fachin took office as the Supreme Court's chief justice, and quickly began discussing his desire to create a code of conduct for judges on the top court. 0:44 Apparent conflicts of interest involving justices are common, and preventing them is also a way to strengthen the rule of law. 0:52 In December, however, the court was pulled into the swirling scandal involving Banco Master, a mid-sized lender that was liquidated amid suspicions of fraud involving billions of reais. 1:05 The bank's owner, Daniel Vorcato, has ties to state governors, lawmakers, justices, and high-ranking executive authorities, putting many people under suspicion across the political spectrum. 1:17 My name is Isabela Cruz, a reporter at The Brazilian Report, and this is Explaining Brazil. 1:23 [dramatic music] Late last year, the press revealed that the wife of Justice Alexandre de Moraes had signed a three-year contract with Banco Master worth 129 million reais, or about $25 million, to work as a lawyer for the bank. 1:44 The sheer value of the contract caused eyebrows to raise. 1:48 Soon after, it also became public that Justice Dias Toffoli, the rapporteur of the Master case, had recently traveled to a football match on a private jet with the lawyer of one of the bank's former executives. 2:01 That alone would already be inappropriate, but from there, the problems only piled up. The justification for keeping the case at the Supreme Court was unconvincing. 2:12 Evidence gathered in the investigation was placed under seal. Officials involved in shutting down the bank were put under pressure, and even the federal police saw its investigation work obstructed. 2:24 More recently, the press reported that members of Toffoli's family are linked to Vorcato through a network of large investments made via financial funds. 2:33 At the center of these dealings is a luxury resort in southern Brazil frequented by the justice and his guests. A political time bomb now seems to be ticking right in the middle of an election year. 2:47 At the Supreme Court, Fachin's push for higher ethical standards was suddenly put to the test. 2:53 To understand what is at stake for Brazil's highest court, I'm pleased to welcome Marjorie Marona, a political science professor at both the Federal University of the State of Rio de Janeiro and the Federal University of Minas Gerais, and coordinator of the Observatory of Justice in Brazil and Latin America. 3:14 Marona holds a law degree and a PhD in political science. In 2022, she was a visiting scholar at the University of Toronto. Professor, thanks for joining us. Thank you for having me. 3:29 Signs that Justice Toffoli may have a personal stake in the case abound. The Federal Police and several members of the legal community argue that the justice has issued unusual rulings. 3:44 Other Supreme Court justices have also shown discomfort with the situation. Still, Justice Toffoli has not stepped back and remains the case rapporteur. 3:57 Justice Moraes has likewise provided no explanation regarding the major contract between his wife and Master. What does this reveal about the power currently held by a Supreme Court justice in Brazil? 4:12 Are they acting without sufficient institutional checks, without being required to account for their actions? What explains this kind of culture? 4:24 Well, I'd say that to, to understand the Master case, it's important to start with a broader institutional point that often surprise foreign audience, how much power a single Supreme Court justice holds in Brazil, especially when acting as a rapporteur of a case. 4:44 So formally, Brazil Supreme Court is a collegial court. I mean, uh, decisions are supposed to reflect collective reasoning. 4:53 But in practice, much of the court's real power is exercised individually through the rapporteur. 5:01 So one justice can sometimes decide whether a case is secret or public, uh, or maybe control its timing, authorize or block investigative steps, manage evidence, and issue interim rulings that can remain in force for months or even years without immediate review by the full court. 5:29 So this, this is not really about Justice Toffoli or Justice Moraes as individuals. It reflects a structural feature of the Brazilian Supreme Court. This, 5:43 uh, uh, I'd say there are institutional checks, of course, uh, plenary review, internal rules, I could mention, motions by the parties, but these mechanisms, uh, they are often slow, discretionary, and they are, for sure, politically sensitive. 6:00 Uh- Recusal or impediment, for, for instance, uh, although legally set, is almost nonexistent in practice at the Supreme Court level. The dominant norm is self-regulation. 6:18 So what we see is a court that is extremely powerful but also highly exposed. When accountability depends more on personal restraint than on clear procedures, 6:32 uh, I'd say that legitimacy becomes fragile, especially in, in, in politically charged case like this one. 6:40 But now Chief Justice Fux has been trying to advance discussions around a code of conduct for the Supreme Court, right? 6:49 Justices who resist the idea argue that it would amount to an admission of guilt, exposing the court to attacks from the far right. 6:59 Supporters, conversely, believe it would be a way for the court to take the lead in the debate, shielding itself from further criticism. What's your assessment of this? Yeah. 7:12 This brings us directly to the debate around the code of conduct, which, um, at its core is really, uh, about how the Supreme Court should manage the concentration of power it currently holds, especially the power exercised by individual justices. 7:30 Justices who resist the idea tend to approach it from a defensive standpoint. 7:37 They are operating in a political environment that is deeply polarized and is still marked by the memory of sustained attacks from the far right, particularly during Jair Bolsonaro's presidency. 7:52 From, from that perspective, there is a real concern that adopting a formal code of conduct could be framed externally as an admission that something is wrong, that the, the Court has behaved improperly and now needs to correct itself. 8:08 The fear, uh, is that critics would not read the code as a sign of institutional responsibility, but as a proof that the Court is vulnerable and on the defensive, or worse, that it's responding to political pressure rather than acting autonomously. 8:28 On the other hand, supporters of the code of conduct starts from a very different diagnosis of the problem. 8:37 They argue that the Court's vulnerability does not come from having standards, but from not having them clearly articulated. 8:46 In their view, uh, the absence of, uh, shared explicit rules is precisely what allows controversies to escalate and repeat themselves because every situation has to be handled ad hoc, case by case, often under intense media and political pressure. 9:07 Without clear benchmark, questions about conflicts of interest, transparency, personal relationships, or public behavior are resolved informally or not resolved at all, and that feeds, uh, speculation. 9:23 So from this perspective, a code of conduct would not weaken the Court, but rather express institutional confidence and leadership. 9:32 It would allow the Court to define its own boundaries proactively instead of having those boundaries imposed or debated, uh, externally. 9:41 [gentle music] To hear the full episode, subscribe to Explaining Brazil on Apple Podcasts, Buzzsprout, or Spotify. 9:53 Or better yet, support us directly by subscribing to The Brazilian Report, newsroom behind this show. 10:01 You will find the audio free on our website, along with daily newsletters delivering original reporting and sharp analysis on Brazil and Latin America. Head over to brazilian.report. 10:16 [outro music]