HISTORY

Why Brazil remained whole, while Spanish America broke apart

Portuguese and Spanish Americas followed different paths. Illustration: National Archives

When Brazil declared its independence in 1822, it emerged as a territorial giant, with lands stretching from the Amazon down to the Río de la Plata. Spanish America, by contrast, splintered into a constellation of new republics. The roots of that divergence lie not only in geography and economics, but also in the institutional choices of the two Iberian empires that shaped the Americas for more than three centuries.

In the late 15th century, Portugal and Spain divided the non-European world between them through the Treaty of Tordesillas. It was this agreement that placed the future Brazilian coastline under Portuguese rule when navigator Pedro Álvares Cabral arrived in 1500. Over the next 300 years, the two colonial systems developed in ways that would define how independence unfolded across the region…

🔒 This was a free preview; the rest is behind our paywall

Don’t miss out! Upgrade to unlock full access. The process takes only seconds with Apple Pay or Stripe. Become a member.

Why you should subscribe

We’re here for readers who want to truly understand Brazil and Latin America — a region too often ignored or misrepresented by the international media.

Since 2017, our reporting has been powered by paid subscribers. They’re the reason we can keep a full-time team of journalists across Brazil and Argentina, delivering sharp, independent coverage every day.

If you value our work, subscribing is the best way to keep it going — and growing.

Reply

or to participate