Transcript 0:00 [gentle music] Hello and welcome to Explaining Brazil. 0:11 My name is Gustavo Ribeiro, editor-in-chief of The Brazilian Report, and this is The Brazilian Report's weekly podcast. 0:18 Uh, we are now in the last stretch of the campaign before the October 4th first-round elections in Brazil. 0:26 As always, I'm joined by James Green, a historian at Brown University, and chairman of the board at the Washington Brazil office and the Brazil Office Alliance. James, always glad to have you. Great to see you today. 0:40 What an exciting- So we-... week this is gonna be. [chuckles] Oh, yes. It's going to be brutal for us working, uh, observing the election and, uh, everything that surrounds it. 0:49 But, uh, before we start, I'd just like to make a, a small reminder to our listeners and viewers that this is, uh, an independent podcast, and we are funded on subscript- uh, The Brazilian Report is funded on subscriptions. 1:04 So if you're already a subscriber, you can go to buymeacoffee.com/brazilianreport and make a pledge, a donation for a cup of coffee for, uh, our staff. 1:14 You can also flash the QR code on the upper right side of your screen if you're watching this on YouTube, right next to James's head. Uh, and, uh, you can, uh, help us, uh, fund this operation. 1:30 Now, without further ado, because we have a lot to discuss, this is, we're in the final days before Brazilians finally cast a vote. 1:38 We have been talking about the election and everything around it since the start of the year, James. Uh, what do you make of, uh, the, the environment? You're now in Brazil. Uh, 1:52 h- how do you see the environment around the election in this home stretch? 1:58 So I think, first of all, we can say that there has not been as much interest and enthusiasm about the election as in other years, uh, in terms of campaigning, people talking about it, getting out the vote, convincing friends for whom to vote, et cetera. 2:12 And, uh, yesterday in São Paulo, there was a, a big rally for the Workers' Party at, uh, on Paulista Avenue. I went there. Uh, I missed the candidates because I got there a little late. 2:22 And you saw a lot of people campaigning with their banners and passing out the little stickers and flyers, but not the energy that I've seen in other years. 2:30 The other thing I've observed, and this is reinforced by every conversation I've had with my famous Uber drivers, is that, uh, the country's very polarized. 2:38 Uh, people are very, uh, uh, tired of dealing with the tensions in Brazilian society that they c- uh, attribute to corruption and all politicians being corrupt. 2:51 And I think also there's a, a, a sentiment, at least among the supporters of, uh, of Flávio Bolsonaro, that Lula is likely to win, which is a very interesting, uh, observation to make. 3:01 I've, I've heard too many people to, to s- have said that to make it not be something significant in some way. 3:07 So whether this means le- some people won't vote, they'll, they'll vote blank, or, or they won't bother to mobilize, I'm not sure, but there's certainly this atmosphere as well. 3:16 A cautious, uh, prediction that Lula will win the election, and by Flávio's supporters, a big, uh, prediction that he will win the, that Lula will win the elections. 3:26 One, one thing that I, I find quite, uh, interesting to, to talk about now, and we are recording this on September 28th, a Monday, so the last Monday before the election, is, uh, and we have been discussing this over the, the past few weeks, how momentum is swinging rapidly and, uh, violently, violently. 3:49 Uh, one week, uh, everyone thinks, "Okay, of course Lula is going to win," the next week, "Of course Lula is going to lose." 3:56 And, uh, now it seems that the pendulum has swung back in favor of Lula and, uh, against Flávio Bolsonaro because of a religious controversy. 4:06 And, uh, one that is interesting, and I think it carries a dark irony, is that it is, uh, a controversy based in unsubstantiated rumors as far as we know. 4:18 And of course, we know that, uh, over the almost a decade, we have seen, uh, Bolsonarism feeding off disinformation and blending rumors with the truth in order to get a political edge, and now they find themselves on the other side of the table. 4:34 Uh, last Thursday, uh, a global news commentator, uh, talked about a reaction within Catholic circles of, uh, people that are scared that if Flávio wins, uh, the evangelical caucus will mobilize to enact legislation that will strip the patron saint title of Our Lady of Aparecida, uh, saint, uh, that is, uh, revered in Brazil. 5:04 And, uh, that w- this, this rumor did not, uh, came from the ether. Uh, actually evangelicals, they are against the adoration of saints. They believe that we should only adore God and Jesus Christ. 5:20 Uh, we have seen evangelic- televangelists picking and destroying images of Our Lady of Aparecida. 5:29 And, um, and we have seen, 20 years ago, uh, attempts at legislation that would, uh, strip, uh, the saint of its patron saint title. 5:42 Uh, now this is a very, very, uh, delicate subject for Catholics, even those that are not that devout. 5:51 Uh, so just long story short, for people who are not familiar with, there's a legend that, uh, in 1717, um, fishermen found, uh, an image of a Black saint, uh, without the head- Uh, wh- while they were casting their nets trying to, to fish, uh, a- and it was... 6:14 Uh, they did not have success in catching fish. Later they found the head that magically glued itself to the body of the image, and after that they, uh, they, they were, uh, bestowed with abundance. 6:29 And then, uh, little by little that, uh, the cult to this image, Our Lady of Aparecida, Aparecida is a city in countryside São Paulo, became a real thing. It is Brazil's biggest pilgrimage site to this day. 6:45 Uh, it, it was, uh... It became Brazil's patron saint in 1930, and, uh, in the '80s, October the 2nd, its feast, became a national holiday. 6:57 So, uh, this reports, these rumors that Flavio would, uh, strip the saint of its title, for Catholics it touches on their core beliefs. For atheists, it touches on a holiday. [laughs] So everyone has reason for beef. 7:16 [laughs] So there's a- I think there's a little bit more to this story we need to include, that recently Flavio announced that he wanted Brazil to be dedicated to, to Jesus Christ, which is a code, uh, for evangelical Christians or Protestants, that we don't have patron saints, we don't have a patron saint of the country, but we do, uh, believe in Jesus alone. 7:35 And this was seen by some people as perhaps the reason why the church was responding to, um, to this with this all- alleged rumor that the, this legislation that had been passed in the, uh, had been, uh, pres- presented in the past might actually be re-presented and passed, uh, under a new, a new government of Flavio Bolsonaro. 7:56 So the response was tremendous, and people wrote many, many postings. 8:02 And then suddenly on Friday, the, uh, member of the Supreme Court overseeing the elections, uh, André Mendoza, declared that, uh, all the postings that talked about this issue had to be taken down. 8:17 Um, and then Monday morning, uh, one of the other members of the Supreme Court, uh, reversed that ruling and said, "No, they cannot be taken down. They should be allowed to come up again." 8:25 So, um, what's happened here is something that was a very small issue has become a national, uh, debate, and everyone's talking about it, and making jokes about it, and posting about it. 8:35 And so it really is how she's shifted the attention away from other questions, at least today, tomorrow, maybe for the next few days. 8:43 No, and I think that this might be really something important, because I think that voters are somewhat jaded when it comes to corruption scandals, because they have, 8:55 uh, come, uh, so often that for many voters it's like, "Well, they're all crooks, so why bother, uh, going into, uh, the nuts and bolts of this particular scandal?" 9:07 And when we're talking about this kind of issue, it touches people's core beliefs. Uh, even if Catholicism is in decline in Brazil, uh, still half of the population declares itself as Catholics. 9:20 You have a good portion of that, almost a quarter of the country at least, is devout and goes regularly to mass. 9:27 Uh, and it's funny because over the past, I don't know, three, four electoral cycles, uh, talking about religion and politics became synonym, uh, of talking about the evangelical vote, because the rapid rise of evangelicals in the country, uh, uh, just consumed everyone's attention around that issue. 9:47 And we never talk about the Catholic vote, and, uh, b- one, because, uh, Catholics are not a monolith, and because, uh, when we're talking about half of the population, it is extremely varied. 10:00 Uh, and also because the Catholic Church does not manifest, uh, the same way that evangelicals do. 10:08 You're not going to have many, uh, influencer priests that are directing how people should vote or ranting on social media. 10:17 It's pretty much, uh, talking in, uh, uh, in, in official documents and, uh, uh, through the rank- within the ranks of the church and, uh, on dioceses. It, it's a very different style of communication. 10:35 The, the timings are very different. But it, it does not mean that, uh, it doesn't have an influence on society. 10:44 A- and for me, what, w- what, what shows that this is a, a powerful issue is how violently, violently, uh, the Flavio Bolsonaro campaign has reacted. It has tried to put a gag order on thousands of social media accounts. 11:00 Uh, Flavio Bolsonaro, uh, even took, uh, to fight the bishops of the Catholic Church, saying that the National Confederation of Brazilian Bishops, uh, started to spread this fake news. 11:13 Uh, so it's, uh, it's something that, uh, really caught my eye. Yeah, I think keep in mind also there, about a third of the population is, uh, are Protestant or evangelical. 11:23 W- in- the word evangelical is used as synonymous with Protestant. Um, and we have a notion in English evangelical Christians are more conservative Christians, but it's a gener- general term in Brazil. 11:34 But nevertheless, of this, uh, one-third of the population, a large percent of them are more conservative Christians, uh, along the lines of evo- evangelical Christians or Pentecostal Chri- Christians. 11:45 And I think what's interesting about this is that in the past, Lula has always done better among Catholic, uh, voters than Protestant voters. 11:53 This time now he's really increasing his support, uh, and the possibility of mobilization of Catholic voters in the elections, and especially women, who are more religious than men. 12:03 And, uh, and this is also feeding into another question, which I think we need to talk about, which is the question of Lula prohibiting the bets, the betting system here, which has consumed- Billions of dollars of people who are betting on online betting of all kinds. 12:17 And Lula just decreed this last week, the, the prohibition of, of online betting, uh, which I, you know, is seen by many people as a, as a way to a- address problems of family poverty. 12:29 Because many families face the situation of someone in the family, whether it's the main breadwinner or another person, getting in debt by going online and betting and betting and betting and losing. 12:39 Uh, and so this is seen as a measure that might actually attract evangelical Christians who are very much against, uh, public betting or betting in any, any way, shape, or form. 12:48 So these are two measures that I think, uh, are two e- elements that could have a very interesting and unexpected result, uh, uh, effect on the, on the results this Sunday. 12:59 No, and, uh, you were talking about, uh, uh, women of faith, and to your point, especially evangelical women might be sensi- uh, sensitive to the ban on online gambling because they see their husbands and their children falling ill to, uh, gambling addiction. 13:18 It ha- It is something that, uh, according to many polls, uh, is more prevalent among males. 13:24 So, uh, uh, uh, because so many households are led by women, they see their household crumble because of this kind of addiction. 13:34 So it is considered some, uh, side door for Lula to get into that cohort when the election comes. Uh- And I think about 65% of the population is, uh, in favor of, uh, of banning o- online betting. Yeah. So Even more. 13:49 75, uh, according to some polls. Maybe 75, is it? Is it that much? Yeah. So it's a really popular question, and the counterargument of course, is, "Oh, this will push betting underground. 13:57 This will encourage, uh, criminal voting." 13:59 But, um, I think criminal elements are already involved in the online, online betting as it is right now, so I'm not sure that there's gonna be a d- a decline in their influence in this regard. 14:08 If in fact one sector does go, uh, uh, clandestine and, and is illegal, the government proposal is very strict at kind of eliminating it from the, from the internet and, and h- putting huge fines on platforms that continue to provide that. 14:22 Uh, now this is a, a provision which, uh, is decreed, but if it's not ratified by Congress it, it becomes ineffective, I think after 180 days. And so this is somewhat of a temporary measure- 120. 120 it is. Thank you. 14:34 And it's, uh, so this is somewhat of a temporary measure, but it sends a clear signal, along with other things that Lula has been doing at the last minute, uh, in order to kind of pump up his support. 14:43 And again, we'll see in six days whether that's effective. No, to your point, uh, this is a provisional decree, so it's not yet set in stone. 14:53 The Congress must approve this, and Congress is, uh, an arena where the betting, uh, lobbying is ex- extremely strong. 15:04 Uh, we have a major effort by major gambling companies to, uh, court lawmakers and, uh, we have seen many reports of top leadership within Congress that, uh, uh, travel to many lavish places on the dime of, uh, gambling magnates. 15:25 Um, now, uh, to you- you talked about the fact that, uh, many people are talking about the possible nasty side effects of it. 15:33 Now, uh, one, yes, uh, there, there will be, uh, a lot of illegal gambling sites that are going to emerge, but not... 15:41 It's not because someone can do something illegally that you shouldn't prohibit, and, uh, and it is a game of whack-a-mole. 15:48 The, just, uh, over the past few days, the go- according to the government-owned data, uh, they struck down 1,500 of, uh, those illegal gambling sites. 15:59 And, uh, the, the, the thing that I, I, I think this discourse that we're seeing many people, uh, put forward is that because betting is legal, they are able to advertise wherever they want, and it has become ubiquitous. 16:15 Uh, most football teams in Brazil are sponsored by gambling, uh, platforms. Uh, every broadcast has tons of betting ads all the time that you could bet on games while they're being played. And, uh, 16:31 a- and also one thing that is problematic with this narrative that m- part of the press is putting forward is that the press also has a, a horse on this race. 16:41 Because you have, for instance, the Grupo, Grupo Globo, the biggest media corporation in Brazil, is, uh, co-owns one betting house, uh, uh, BetMGM. 16:53 Uh, many, uh, media outlets get money from these platforms, uh, in advertisement. So, uh, it, it, it is a less than impartial, uh, 17:08 view, uh, the one by, uh, legacy media in Brazil. And, uh, and I agree with you. Uh, I think that, uh, we have seen multiple... Uh, it's not only the debt problem. 17:19 Uh, retailers have been asking for this kind of ban for more than a year, saying that many surveys, many studies show that people are buying less groceries, they are buying less consumer goods because their money's being drained to online betting, because we have a population that does not have tons of, uh, financial education, and, uh, many people see betting as a form of investment. 17:45 Exactly, and so we have a situation in which the population in general is feeling the economy is not going as well as it should be going, and not necessarily understanding the reasons for that, one of which is the war in Iran and the high costs of, of, of, of, uh, combustibles that have an effect on Brazil. 18:01 A second is the ways in which the US tariffs have, uh, have been imple- implemented and imposed on Brazil that are now at 37%, they were 1.50%. 18:10 And, and I think other i- issues about the international economy which are affecting Brazil. So I, I think a lot of people that I've talked to at least don't see these connections. 18:19 They don't understand that billions of pe- billions of- Of high ice and debt that people have is going to affect, as you said, consumer, uh, uh confidence and the ability for people to actually to purchase necessary goods which could fuel the economy. 18:34 Um, and the race remains extremely tight, although all the polls in recent days are showing that Lula is three to five points ahead at this moment in the first round. 18:43 And some are even predicting that he's close to a, a, a victory in the first round, which I think is not very likely at this point. But we have six days and anything can happen in these six days. 18:55 Yeah, and we were talking about v- voters' mood swings. And, uh, the, the last polls; and the thing is, the last, the latest polls, they do not fully account for the effects of the Our Lady of Aparecida gate. 19:10 Um, but, uh, they already show, uh, they already suggest, according to some statisticians, that Flávio is plateauing, that he might have reached his ceiling. 19:21 Uh, while Lula is slightly, very slightly trending up, so it is, uh, a trend that favors the incumbent. But like you said, we're going to have to see. 19:33 And, uh, so we mentioned the, the religious, uh, scandal, the betting ban. 19:38 I would like to add a third element for this cocktail that I think is also connected, is that at the same event that Lula issued the provisional decree banning gambling, uh, online gambling, he also launched the third iteration of, uh, his debt relief program. 19:55 The first one came in 2023, then this year a second one, and now a third one that essentially, uh, brings the government into the debt market. 20:06 So, uh, public banks will, uh, operate, uh, debt portfolios and, uh, essentially buy people's debt, uh, and negotiate them, uh, at 90%, 95% discounts with banks. 20:20 For banks, this is good because it's money they already counted as, as permanently lost. Uh, for citizens it's good because it cleans their name. 20:30 You, you give people a possibility of, uh, removing their names from bad payers lists, uh, and also gives them some breathing, financial breathing room. Uh, it targets the poor. 20:43 Uh, there's a cap at 10,000 reais, which is more or less $2,000 as the total amount of debt per person. 20:52 So it is very targeted at small debt by low-income people that even though it is small, it just eats up a big part of people's revenue. You know, and it's very interesting, several people have criticized 21:08 Lula, several com- commentators, the f- the fact that many of his, these new proposals are coming at the last minute, as if he's panicked and, and carrying out these, these, uh, uh, endeavors in order to get votes. 21:18 But in a, in a way, um, because there's a certain amount of lack of people remembering the past; and I, and I've really been shocked by the way I've been talking to people on the arguments they are making to me about not being aware of very recent events in Brazilian history among Brazilian 21:34 Uber drivers who are lower middle class, uh, members of the community. Uh, so that I think to a certain extent, many of these, you know, measures which are relative to the last minute could really be determinative. 21:48 They could really make a difference because people will remember them. That'll be the last thing on their minds. 21:52 Whether that's a cost of living adjut- adjustment in the family stipend, the Bolsa Família, or, uh, the measures we've talked about today, or even, uh, Lula's proposal to, uh, provide, uh, the, uh, uh, I'm gonna say abs- uh, I don't, can't think of the name of it in, in English b- besides the generic name of the d- uh, weight loss, uh, injection, uh, uh, treatments. 22:15 And, and offering them through the unified health system, which if actually were to go into effect, would be very important in Brazil because of the huge amount of obesity that exists in the country today. 22:27 Uh, and so these are all measures for- But this is longer term, right? It takes, uh, many studies for the incorporation of, of any drug. 22:35 Uh, it is more the announcement saying, like, "Lula is bringing you, uh, free Ozempic." 22:40 [laughs] And people, and people who are, you know, concerned about this and would like to buy it and can't afford it 'cause it's expensive in Brazil- Yeah... 22:47 uh, unlike other meas- um, um, medications that are, uh, under the, the control of the state, which are much cheaper; it's, uh, for example, uh, anti-AIDS viral are free in this country where they're extremely expensive in other parts of the world. 23:00 So these are measures which I think can have an, a popular appeal and could, could make that 1% difference. 23:05 Because if the, if the final results are very close in a one or two-point margin, any of these shifts in pop- popularity could, could swing the election one way or the other. 23:14 And, and I think this is what we're seeing right now at play as both sides are trying to appeal to that small percentage of voters who haven't made a decision yet, who may or may not vote, uh, and trying to encourage them to vote and vote for their side. 23:29 Now, uh, I, I do believe that, uh, when people say that Lula is doing this for the votes, I, I think that they are right. I mean, the, the, the timing of it is not incidental. 23:41 Uh, you're doing this a week before people go to the polls. Uh, my problem is, uh, with the outrage is that we forget that, uh, every four years the incumbent does that. 23:53 And, uh, uh, in many ways, what Jair Bolsonaro did in 2022 was even worse. Uh, and every president kind of, uh, or governor, e- e- everyone running for re-election pretty much throws everything but the kitchen sink, uh, 24:10 uh, when trying to, to, to get a second term. Uh, what Bolsonaro did, I think was much worse in many ways because Bolsonaro, uh, he created a system for people who were on welfare programs to get, uh- 24:28 Uh, uh, payroll loans. So, uh, they would get a loan up to three times their monthly income, and up to 30% of their income would be discounted every month, uh, at massive interest rates. 24:45 So many economists pointed out that this was a debt trap to people with low financial education. 24:52 And, uh, we at The Brazilian Report even did the story, award, award, an award-winning story showing that the government leaked 24:59 massive databases of, uh, people on welfare so that banking representatives could aggressively market these loans. 25:08 So it is the same sport, but it's not the same league, uh, I think what we are seeing, uh, in terms of spendoring. And, and the, and the actual measures are quite different in terms of their outcomes. 25:18 I think that's an important to keep in mind as well in terms of- Yeah... 25:21 uh, the general trend consistently, and it remains the case that the government of Lula, uh, da Silva really does focus on low-income voters, low-income people in the society, and that has to do with Lula's own empathy with, with his own life story of being very poor when he was young and working very hard starting at age 10 or 12. 25:40 So I think this is an interesting thing, but again, it's really, I see the bubbles that people are living in, the social media bubbles that they're living in, and so it's really, it's gonna be very interesting to see if these things break through these bubbles and convin- uh, convince people, uh, against the, the narrative that they're hearing in a constant way. 25:58 Coming to this, to this, uh, taping today, I was in an Uber and, uh, the driver had a very loud conversation. Uh, he was listening to something and afterwards I said, "Could you please turn this down?" 26:09 Because it was really very, very, uh, tendential and it was making really strong and ira- inaccurate arguments about why, uh, Lula should not be elected and Flávio, uh, should be elected. 26:19 So I think we're hearing pe- people are hearing, uh, this information, they're receiving this information through the, through the internet, through social media, and, uh, the question is, is how effective these measures, whether it's, uh, the question of religion or, or, uh, dealing with debt reduction or other questions will, will actually penetrate and have some influence on the final outcome. 26:40 Now, we're only going to know this once the votes are counted, uh, and this will happen on Sunday. 26:46 So, uh, before we go, James, I would like to, uh, invite our listeners and our viewers, uh, to be with us, uh, when the votes are being counted on, uh, Sunday evening. 27:01 You and I are going to host several, uh, people, several guests to discuss the main themes of the election, uh, the main trends, and of course, the results. 27:12 So, uh, it's going to start at 5:00 PM on Sunday once the polls are closed, and, uh, it's going to last until we know whether we have a victor or whether we're going to have a runoff race that is going to be settled on October 25th. 27:31 And we'll be sending information about how to, uh, find the link for the, the program so you can join us on Sunday for hot English language, uh, coverage of the Brazilian elections and, uh, and a, a wrap-up discussion about what comes next after we see the results and the results are finally in. 27:50 Well, James, see you on Sunday. See you on Sunday.