Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hello. Welcome back to Explaining Brazil, the podcast by The Brazilian Report, and in partnership with the Brazil Office Alliance. 0:16 And I'm here joined by James Green, historian at Brown University and president of the board at the Brazil Office Alliance. James, how are you? Thanks for- Great... for being back. Great to see you today. 0:29 So James, uh, let's jump right into our discussion because since we last spoke and, uh, I mean, last episode we talked about Congress and its oaths. So let's go back to the presidential race and, uh, a lot to unpack. 0:42 Uh, we had a conversation between Presidents Lula and Trump. Uh, Brazil trying to establish a positive, uh, rapport with the US, uh, in these weeks leading up to the election. 0:57 And then we had some crazy polls, uh, that were out on Monday, uh, September 31st when we're recording this. So let's, um, let's start with the polling. And I mean, the dust has not even settled. 1:11 We had two polls, uh, that were out, uh, one by Nexus, which is done by phone, the other one is done by, uh, Atlas Intel, which is an online poll, and both showed a 1:27 remarkable and unexpected rise of Augusto Cury. 1:31 He's a psychiatrist, and he made his fame and fortune, uh, by, uh, publishing self-help books and, uh, he's this sort of, uh, self-help guru, one of the best-selling authors that Brazil has produced over the past few decades. 1:47 Um, and I mean, he started as someone nobody really takes seriously. Uh, his entire platform, if we can call that, is more, uh, recycling the, 2:00 the self-help slogans he has, uh, brought up during his, uh, lectures and his, uh, paying, um, uh, speakership engagements. 2:11 Um, but then in one week he goes from 1% to 11%, according to Nexus, and almost 8% according to Atlas. 2:22 Leapfrogging everyone else from the so-called third way, uh, this, uh, plethora of candidates trying to break the duopoly between Lula and Flávio Bolsonaro. How do you read these two polls and... 2:37 Well, I think the first thing we have to understand is that Lula and Flávio did not participate in the first debate, and I think that allowed the non-candidates, the small number of candidates in the polls, to show their face more and to be more visible. 2:51 And so I think this is an element in the situation. 2:54 I think the second thing is this is a moment of people still looking for alternatives and seeing what might be out there that might be interesting, and I think that's another reflection in the possibility of the increase of his poll numbers. 3:05 I just am very skeptical of any possibility of a third candidate doing anything other than causing a mix-up within the polarization between Flávio and, and Lula, which are the two main candidates and who are gonna determine the race. 3:18 And so, um, this could create a situation in which it's impossible for Lula to win in the first round and making it harder for him to win in the second round, where the polls show that the race is much tighter. 3:30 Um, but I don't see any of these candidates, uh, offering an alternative that was any, in any way viable. I think it really does boil down to, um, the historic polarization. 3:40 It used to be between the PSDB and, and the Workers' Party, and now it's between, uh, Bolsonaro's forces and, and, and the Workers Party and the coalitions they've built. 3:51 And I think I w- I, I agree with you that I don't see, uh, Cury, uh, going as far as un- uh, leapfrogging Flávio Bolsonaro and taking a runoff spot. 4:04 But I do think that it's quite interesting what we're seeing because, um, all campaigns have spent the lion's share of their energy, uh, attacking other candidates. 4:16 So Lula spends tons of time of his, uh, TV and radio, uh, ads, uh, deconstructing the image of Flávio Bolsonaro. 4:26 Flávio Bolsonaro does the same with Lula, and then the other candidates try to do a little bit with one another, uh, but mostly, uh, they try to attack, uh, and to various degrees of aggressiveness, Lula and Flávio Bolsonaro. 4:40 And Cury sets himself apart because regardless of the, the substance of his platform, uh, he has been an outlier in trying to convey a more positive image and trying to, um, appeal to, to people's sentiments of, uh, fatigue with the polarization. 5:03 He always says, like, "They sold us a lie that there are only two options, left and right, and we should take the, the path of the middle." 5:11 And, uh, I do think that his meteoric rise kind of shows, um, that the third way problem in Brazil has always been like a matter of supply rather than demand. 5:24 There is a big part of the electorate who would rather not vote for either Lula or Bolsonaro, but end up gravitating towards these two polls because they vote more, uh, as a strategy to prevent the, the one that they hate the most from taking office. 5:41 Uh, and I think that, uh, even if I don't think that, um, Cury is going to surpass Flávio, 5:49 I do believe that, uh, he may be showing a roadmap for candidates that you can, uh, you, you can appeal to voters without sounding extremely vitriolic all the time. Well, I, I agree with you. 6:05 I mean, the tone would be nicer if it were less, uh, polarizing. But the fact of the matter is, both of the main candidates offer a vision o- of the country. Lula's vision is more of the same. 6:16 "We've done a wonderful job over the years, let's keep it up, let's remember our roots in the working class, and let's, you know, continue the programs we want to do." 6:24 And Flávio is saying, "Let's go back to where Bolsonaro father, uh, ru- run the country and all the things that he accomplished," and the discourse of the right. 6:32 And I think, uh, and no other candidates offers any other vision of the country that people can identify with. 6:37 And so, I mean, given the way in which Brazilian humor, uh, undermines many aspects of, of life in the country, I'm imagining very quickly there's going to be a huge campaign, uh, against Curi and the joking about self-help and Brazilian self-help, and t- all the, the jokes that will kind of, I think, deflate his campaign. 6:57 And again, we have to remember that in all of the other recent races, there's been this surge at even moment in the, in the, in this period of candidate that seemed to be really challenging of the polarization, and they deflate at the end of the day. 7:11 I think, uh, the last election, Simone Tebet was the person who most managed to, to, to, to, to show some kind of independence in the, in the first round, and then she quickly endorsed, uh, Lula in the second round. 7:24 And so she e- eliminated, uh, and- But, uh, my pushback to that is that this is the first time that a non-Lulista or Bolsonarista candidate has ever reached this double digits since 2018. 7:39 Because Simone- Remind, remind me what Ciro Gomes, what did Ciro Gomes get in his polling in the first, in the early stages? Uh, in, in 2018, he was in the double digits. 7:48 At one point it seemed that he could eventually, like he got to 15 to 16%, but that was eight years ago. Uh, in, uh... 7:57 Well, well, I, I do think it's notable that for the first time in eight years we have someone not named Lula or Bolsonaro- Absolutely... that are in the double digits. 8:06 Which doesn't mean that I, I, I'm not saying that he could be elected or anything like that, but I do think it kind of scrambles a little bit how, um, uh, th- this campaign may unfold. 8:18 Because, uh, what I always say is the polls are not important because of the numbers, but because of how they affect- Right... 8:26 uh, the parties, the candidates, uh, a- and even the voters, because voters tend to flock to the candidates that are polling the best. 8:34 So I do think that, uh, uh, I mean, we have for months, everyone keeps saying that, uh, there are revelations that could be really detrimental to Flávio Bolsonaro. 8:46 I mean, uh, every week is, "Is this the week that we're going to, to get that?" 8:51 So if we do get something, uh, we do, we, we, we still, uh, are in a campaign where, uh, the federal police is playing an outsized role with certain leaks and, uh, factions of the federal police who are more aligned with Bolsonarism, uh, are doing this drip, drip, uh, uh, thing that, uh, to keep, uh, the, the scandal with the president's son in the media. 9:18 Uh, uh, we are expecting some pushback from the other side of the federal police with, uh, revelations coming against Flávio Bolsonaro. 9:28 And, um, I, I, I do wonder how this, uh, Curi thing could affect the way that people are campaigning. Could this- Well, if, if, if my- Could this campaign starting down? 9:39 Uh, you know, if my informal, uh, unscientific polling, uh, that I did with Uber drivers [laughs] in Rio de Janeiro, São Paulo and Belo Horizonte has any valid, I don't think it does necessarily, but there is something that I detected, which is, uh, people who don't really believe that, that, that, that Flávio is going to win, that Lula is going to win. 9:56 It's inevitable. And that, that depresses, theoretically at least, depresses, uh, right-wing voting because people feel, "Oh, we're not going to win, so why bother?" 10:05 Not, not for the hardcore dedicated Bolsonaristas, but other people who are in the middle are not sure about that. 10:11 Some of them might go to people, uh, like Curi as an alternative or even Zema or Caiado or, or, or another candidate. 10:18 But I think that this, this is, this is a vote of frustration, or this is an interested frustration of the two sides. It doesn't, 10:25 won't result, I think, in any way in a, in a, in a sig- I mean, if there are significant revelations about Flávio that kind of sink his candidacy, some other third party could emerge, uh, to be the, the contestant against Lula. 10:38 But I, I just don't see that as, as, as realistic at this moment. And so, uh, it's an interesting phenomenon to follow. 10:44 Let's see if it, if the polls, uh, repeat themselves in the next couple of weeks, if this is just a, a, a, a flash in the night or if this is something more substantial in terms of its reflections of a disillusionment. 10:57 There is a disillusionment with the two sides. I don't d- dispute that at all. But I think part of that means people either just not voting or just not bothering to mobilize, uh, on the far right in that regard. 11:08 And I think that, um, I, I'm surprised that the, the left is weaker than it, it could be in, in terms of its mobilization and its, its candidacies. But we'll see. I mean, I think it's still very early. 11:19 Um, I think the next, the real month is, is approaching, which is really the month that we're starting to be in as of tomorrow, which is September, and, and how that's gonna- Yeah... 11:28 kind of really show clearly where the tendency's gonna or will be in the, in the, in the final weeks before the, the campaign. And it's, we're getting close, if we think about it. It's, it's October 4th- Yeah... 11:40 which is, uh, five weeks away. No, it, uh, I... One thing that, uh, is also crazy about this Curi, um, rise is also that it serves as 11:53 sort of a vindication for legacy media because before he got exposure on TV, uh, during the televised debate on the 23rd, and then on Saturday he went on Jornal Nacional, Brazil's main, uh, newscast, to be grilled. 12:08 Um, and, uh, I mean, that exposure Helped him. Uh, he has already a lot of name recognition. He had already millions of followers on social media. 12:19 But, uh, that, uh, appearance that we ha- he had in the traditional media outlets really boosted him. Yeah. 12:28 And like you said, because the front-runners chose not to participate in the debate, and they gave them more air time. 12:35 Yeah, but I think, again, it, I mean, as- unless Lula and now Flávio decide not to participate in the debates generally, and I don't think they'll do that because I think that looks really bad that, that they're hiding something or they're running away from a discussion. 12:47 And short of some kind of tragic health problem that Flávio might have, uh, which would make it difficult for him to participate in the debates; I'm being a little facetious here. 12:56 Uh, then I, you know, I think it's just gonna, it's really gonna boil down again to the polarization. 13:00 I don't see any- anything other than that, and I think that's where most electorate are, are thinking is the reality, whether they like it or not. 13:07 And I think that's how people are gonna tend to end up voting or deciding not to vote because they're disillusioned with all the candidates. 13:14 Or voting for a protest candidate in the first round and then maybe sitting out the second round. Uh, it's, it's still, it's still hard to see. 13:21 I think the, I think the close nature of the second round is really indicative of the real situation in the country. 13:29 When you really sort out all the outside no- uh, the noise, I think what you really do have is the same polarization which we've... 13:36 And I, I think it's gonna continue, uh, unless there's a real shakeup in terms of not having strong candidates on the left and on the far right, and then another candidate m- merging, which is kind of conciliatory. 13:48 But that's, that's four years away. 13:50 Uh, and I think, you know, Tarcísio and other people might be wanting to play that role in the future, but I don't think even they will be the kinds of people that will manage to kind of mobilize the popular support to alter- to, to offer a serious third way alternative. 14:04 It's just not in the cards these days, as far as I can tell. So this is interesting, but I don't think it's necessarily, uh, has a long-term impact on the elections. I could be wrong. 14:13 I, I think it could have the impact on the elections in one aspect. 14:18 Uh, because Cudi is, um, if you, if you look at the detail in the, in the data that, uh, Nexus released this morning, um, he's turning a lot of disengaged voters. 14:32 So if, and it's a big if, this, uh, trend continues, even if he gets 10, 12%, so miles behind, uh, Flávio Bolsonaro, uh, if he increa- if his participation and his enhanced profile increases turnout, that is bad news for Lula. 14:53 But so- Because it reduces Lula's cha- already slim chances of clinching the election on the first round. 15:00 And the s- a ru- th- this year, I think the runoff for Lula is extremely hard because he has very few, uh, lanes from which he could pull new voters between the first and the second round. 15:16 Well, that, that could, that speaks to the question of what, uh, Cudi will do, actually. Will he endorse someone in the second round? Will he call people not to vote? 15:23 All these people he mobilizes, will he demobilize them? Will he call them to vote for Bolsonaro? 15:28 Which if he does, immediately des- destroys the argument of a third way, uh, you know, um, no bird flies without two wings, a left wing and a right wing, all these metaphors that are used over the years. 15:38 I, I just, I just think that, you know, it's... 15:42 The impact could be if he, if he, uh, called on his supporters to support one of the two finalists, Flávio, es- I mean, assuming that Flávio doesn't sink and he doesn't occupy that, that space. 15:53 And I think that, you know, that, um [lip smack] I don't know. I don't know what he'll do. What do you think he'll do? 15:57 Do you think he'll endorse Flávio or Lula in the second round or just call on people to, to not vote for anyone? I think he published something on his Instagram that, uh, could be answering your question. 16:11 He posted an endorsement from Pablo Marçal, who is, uh, someone who wreck havoc in the 2024 São Paulo mayoral elections, uh, a sort of new wave Bolsonarista that in many aspects it, it was even more radical than, uh, Bolsonaro, uh, in his proposals. 16:36 Uh, so I mean, that, that doesn't, that doesn't seem like someone who will, uh, endorse Lula or simply be silent. 16:49 I, I would, if I had to bet my money, I would say that, uh, uh, he would not explicitly endorse F- Flávio, but his rhetoric could push his voters towards Flávio. 17:03 But, uh, but again, again, it's, it's the disill- disillusion, low propensity to vote people. Do they then follow this leader that they've, uh, attached to? Or do they- Mm... ignore it, or they just stay at home? 17:14 And I think it doesn't necessarily mean that it transf- transfers into 11%, if that's the statistic at the end of the, of the, at, at the end of the, the polling, and that's the voter. 17:23 Doesn't mean that those 11% migrate. I, I actually agree with you that Lula has a very difficult chance. I think it's virtually impossible for women- win in the, in the first round. 17:32 But, but, and he has a very difficult time because he doesn't have much to pick up. The, the, the tiny little parties on the left don't, I think, amount all of them together to 1 or 2%. 17:42 Now, that could be a determining factor if all those people actually do mobilize for Lula's coalition. 17:48 Because if the, if the margin of difference between, uh, the two main candidates is similar to what it was in '22, then it could easily be a situation where 1 or 2% from anywhere could make a diff- difference in the election, but we'll have to see. 18:02 I mean, it's a lot of speculation on our part. Now we'll have to see what happens. 18:05 I think that the, the, the Lula campaign is struggling very hard, uh, to deal with the, uh, the assault by Trump and the attempts of Trump to inter- interfere in the elections and to tip them Uh, to favor Flávio Bolsonaro. 18:18 Uh, and, uh, I think the meeting that Lula and, uh, Trump had that, uh, last week, uh, is an indication of an attempt by the Ministry of Foreign Relations and the Lula government to try to find a way to have a conversation with, with Trump. 18:33 It's pretty difficult with the crazy man in the White House, but I think they're trying to do that. 18:37 Whether it will result in any, uh, lightning of the attempted, uh, imposition of new tariffs on Brazil is another question. Right. 18:45 So you, you already introduced the, the, the next segment that, uh, um, that we were going to address in this episode, which was, uh, Lula and Trump had, uh, 10 days ago, um, a call of one hour and 20 minutes, uh, that the Brazilian readout described as very cordial and very productive. 19:09 One thing that is interesting is that you don't have anything from the American side, so it's hard to say, um, what exactly went on because the Brazilian side says, "No, it was great. 19:21 Uh, uh, when the two presidents talk, th- things seems to f- seem to flow." Uh, but, um, I mean, in Brazil nobody really expects this, uh, tariff negotiations to go anywhere. 19:37 And it's also, um, I think 19:40 Bra- Bra- the, the Lula administration buying itself some time because it, it, it is trying to, uh, thread a delicate needle between, uh, showing resolve but not antagonizing Lula to the point that, uh, it will vex many of the voters that he wants to win over. 20:00 Because, uh, uh, polls show that Brazilians favor negotiations with Trump rather than retaliation. And also, if you just 20:09 retaliate, it can have, uh, uh, massive inflationary effects, and no president is going to do that weeks away from, uh, what is going to be a very nasty election. Um, so I mean, I, I think we just 20:25 try- Brazil is just trying to kick the can a little bit further down the road. 20:29 I, I think you're absolutely right about that, and I think they're trying to string on Lula to the s- to extent possible until after the elections, and then they'll deal with it and the effect it will have. 20:39 Um, you know, it's interesting. A- allegedly from the readout that the Brazilians provided, uh, Trump wanted to know about the elections and Lula said everything is fine. 20:47 The election process is gonna be perfect and we have no problems with electoral, uh, integrity. Uh, it's gonna be fine. But he didn't go into details about the candidates and, and how they were doing. 20:58 And some people have read that to mean, well, Trump is not really that aware of what's going on or the, the, the alleged campaign of the United States to interfere in the elections isn't really happening. 21:08 Well, I, I don't agree with that. I think that there are... 21:10 I think L- Trump is just not really well informed about a lot of things, and he really gets it wrong and he's kind of vague on a lot of details of, of geopolitics. 21:19 On the other hand, I think it's clear that, um, he, he is still trying to do everything possible on one hand to, uh, fix his elections, Trump's elections, and also to favor his allies in Latin America and I think this recent, um... 21:33 And I, I wanted to ask you a question because I haven't been able to find the information. You pr- perhaps know this. 21:37 The recent, um, proposal by Trump to, um, to, to waive tariffs on ground beef and other kinds of beef products to the United States for the next 90 days and offering them at a 25% lower price, are, is Brazilian beef involved in this possibility j- that you're aware of or is it just Argentinian beef? 21:56 I have to check. I, I don't have this information right now, but, uh, it would shock me if that was the case because Peter Navarro, uh, was, uh, 22:07 saying that, uh, Brazilian beef companies are operating a cartel in the US and pushing prices up. So he was very, uh, very aggressive when talking about Brazilian companies. 22:20 But, uh, I mean, Trump wants to lower food inflation in the US no matter what. So, uh, I, I think at this point we have learned not to ask for coherence from, uh, the Trump White House. 22:33 No- nor, nor can we expect him to have any effect on prices in the next two months. And it also is creating a very interesting d- dynamic in the United States 22:41 of people in key states, what are called swing states, the states that it will make the dis- the dis- the difference in the elections in, in the North Central part of the United States, which are very important, de- de- depend a lot on agri- agribusiness. 22:55 And they're very upset with this because this is gonna undercut prices in the United States, and it seems a very blatant, uh, attempt to in- influence the elections. 23:04 Although it probably won't affect it any prices at all in the next t- two months or the... It's because it's, it's, you know, we're close to the Ame- US elections. US elections are in six weeks as well. 23:15 So these kinds of things, the same manipulations of oil prices is, is not gonna make the situation better in the United States. 23:22 Now, that how that relates to Brazil I think is that to the extent that Trump is really very desperate about, um, his, his position in the United States, it's likely that he will be paying much less attention to Brazil in the mix even though I think his operators around him are very conscious of the strategic importance of Brazil and will be involved in, in maintaining the pressure on the country, uh, uh, in the up period, uh, till the elections and, and to the extent possible and the way possible supporting Flávio's candidacy. 23:53 Although they claim that they're neutral in the elections and they have no candidate, which is just not true. 23:58 I, I just can't imagine that Trump is not at some point gonna blurt out a very clear and decisive endorsement of Flávio, because that's what he does. 24:05 And I think that, again, as you point out, uh, will push back, uh, again, people who are nationalistic or against foreign interferences in the elections will be very upset by that, and I think that will help solidify Lula's, uh, support among the center left and to a certain extent, uh, if that happens. 24:25 Yeah, maybe even to some people in the center right because, uh, Trump has become a sort of toxic brand. Uh, 24:34 I mean, what the u- the, the, the trade war that the White House has waged against Brazil, and we have touched on this, on this podcast before, has, uh, pretty much, uh, been a drag to US image in Brazil, to Trump's image in Brazil. 24:50 Uh, more Brazilians now say that Brazil should be closer to China than they say that Brazil should be closer to the US. So I don't think that, uh, Trump's endorsement, uh, would, uh, help Flávio. I would say that, um, 25:06 uh, 25:08 the, the, the Lula camp, uh, it, it, it tries to, uh, not to draw, uh, practical measures from the US but als- always keep a sort of ambiguous, sometimes antagonizing, sometimes, uh, reproaching relationship with the US because, uh, 25:30 that Trump interference is also a casus belli. 25:33 I mean, if you take the programs that the candidates filed, uh, before electoral courts, uh, the, the leitmotif for Lula four years ago was reconstructing the country after, uh, four years of Bolsonaro, and now that central place is, uh, was given to sovereignty. 25:54 So having this foreign antagonist also plays into what Lula wants, right? Exactly, and the problem with this is that Trump doesn't know how to control himself, and so I, I just... 26:07 I mean, Trump currently has decided he's gonna... He has a large electoral fund of $400 million that he controls, and he hasn't been spending it on many races. 26:16 And now the question is, is he gonna spend it in the last six weeks of the campaign, and how is he gonna do that? 26:21 And his announcement is that he's gonna promote himself through a series of TV ads saying how wonderful his presidency has been, which the Democrats are saying, "Thank you. This is wonderful." 26:31 This is gonna put him in the center of the electoral race. It's gonna make this race a, a, a, a, a referendum on the Trump presidency, and it's gonna hurt Republicans. 26:42 And so this, this need that Trump has to be always the center of attention and the most important person and a player, I think, 26:49 uh, is such a strong force within him that he will not be able to resist at some point doing something to indicate his support for Flávio, thinking this is gonna help Flávio, and as you point out, this could actually backfire. 27:01 Uh, and I think the, the Democrats see this, this tendency in the United States backfiring on the Republicans and on Trump, and I think the same thing could happen, uh, in Brazil. Um, 27:12 the, the, the nationalism, the feeling of, you know, sovereignty is a real sentiment in Brazil, and it's a, it's a broad-based sentiment. It's, you know... 27:19 The, the right appropriated the, the flag and, and made it theirs, and the, and the, the fla- the colors of the selection of the, the, the soccer cup's, uh, team. 27:29 And, and I think that, um, th- that opens the door for a strong sentiment of nationalism against, uh, interference. 27:36 Not again, again, not among the hardcore, unconditional, uh, supporters of the Bolsonaro camp, but among other people who don't like Lula but have doubts about that. 27:48 That, that sector in the middle which is gonna be crucial to- Mm-hmm... to who- what will be the final results. It's that, what we call in English the swing vote, but, you know, we'll see. 27:57 See if this is actually a, a, a factor that will, will make a final difference in the, in the s- what I think will be the second round of the elections. 28:05 And with that in mind, I think that, uh, Flávio Bolsonaro did what, in my opinion, was a smart pivot. He no longer is talk about geopolitical issues. He's not talking anymore about voting machines. 28:18 Uh, he's trying to, uh, talk only about bread-and-butter, um, issues. 28:25 And, uh, he's doing something that can really work on many voters, uh, in asking voters, like, "Do you think your life is better now than it was four years ago? 28:36 Can you buy more groceries now than you could four years ago?" And I mean, uh, food inflation has been punishing in Brazil. 28:44 Now, uh, food inflation during the Bolsonaro years was twice, uh, what it has been in the Lula years, but, uh, that's not how voters think, right? Voters just, 28:57 uh, they're not, like, doing spreadsheets to compare, uh, when prices rose the fastest. 29:03 They're only seeing their, uh, grocery carts getting lighter and lighter and more and more expensive, and that could be really detrimental to the government, especially now that we're seeing massive, uh, 29:17 brands collapsing, NS filing for bankruptcy protection, and that even if these are not systemic companies and, uh, uh, th- their weight on the economy is limited, it, it sort of helps create this feeling that the economy might not be heading, uh, towards the, the best path. 29:38 No, you're right, and I think that the feeling of, "Are things better than they were four years ago?" The famous line that Ronald Reagan inve- invented, uh, is applicable in Brazil. 29:46 And I think that there's, there's a, that's a real feeling that will affect some voters. 29:50 I think Lula at this last moment is trying to get the things passed through Congress and has been conciliatory towards Congress in order to see if he can get the six for one that is basically defending the idea of a 40-hour work week, uh, to be passed, and it could be passed. 30:04 Uh, uh, and I think, uh, the Bolsonaro forces are gonna vote against it, which I think was gonna harm them to a certain extent. 30:11 Uh, there are other measures that I think Lula's hoping to squeak through Congress before, uh, the elections that might favor him to a certain extent, uh, in this regard. 30:20 Um, but again, it's gonna be a very tight race, no question about that. 30:25 And, uh, you mentioned, uh, the six-day work week, and before we go, I, I, I think we should talk about this because this is a crucial week for the government. 30:34 Like you said, uh, the government has, uh, a lot of popular legislation in line to be approved i- in the Senate, um, after months Uh, 30:46 that, uh, Senate President Davi Alcolumbre sat on these, uh, pieces of legislation. And, uh, it is interesting because the government was very disgruntled that, uh, things were not moving. 30:59 But the fact that they are moving now five weeks before the election could create a sort of feel-good factor way more potent than if they had been approved, uh, months ago. 31:10 Because nothing lasts, uh, either bad or wrong in the polling. Uh, you have a scandal, the candidate drops. A few weeks later, he goes back to the normal again. 31:22 Something good happens, they have a bump up, but then it normalizes again. So the fact that this comes close to the election is positive for Lula. 31:31 And Lula is also interested in negotiating with Alcolumbre to be able to, or Alcolumbre with Lula to, to, to ensure that he remains the president of the Senate. 31:38 So I think there's a, there's a geopolitical consideration there that says that this is the right thing to do right now. So we'll see if it happens. I, I'm a little skeptical. 31:47 I think that the right-wing forces are gonna try to block, uh, the, the, the vote. But that also helps the government. Yeah. Ab- absolutely. 31:53 Because they will have right-wing politicians saying, "Well, this bill that is supported by 70% of voters, we are against it." [laughs] Exactly. 32:03 And I, you know, I mean, the arguments that it's gonna cause more unemployment, I don't think... The people who are working very hard and long hours, I love this idea. And I, so I... You know, and, and we think about it. 32:14 This is a fight that's been going on for 150 years to have the 40-hour work week, and Brazil hasn't managed to get it yet, although this is a demand that, you know, it's been around since the late 19th century. 32:24 Um, so I think you're right. I think these are possible, uh, advantages for the, to the left-center coalition that Lu- Lula's constructed. 32:34 I think he does have a way to reach out to kind of an historical, uh, constituency that do remember the good times of Lula and, and perhaps will give him one last, uh, go at it, uh, this last four years. 32:46 I think his campaign has not been strong enough convincing why all the reasons why, uh, uh, the, the Workers' Party-led coalition needs to be in power again. 32:54 But again, the, the campaign is gonna pick up and the, the, the tensions and the, the hardcore debates are gonna kind of emerge, um, as the, as the candidates debate each other on, on national TV and as, as the... 33:09 I haven't been watching the ads because I'm in New York right now, but are they tedious or how... Are they, are they interesting? Are they kind of lively or are they more of the same? 33:19 You, you have a little bit of everything. I have, uh, seen mostly the ones that, uh, one is trashing the other. Uh, especially Lula with like, "Oh, this is Flávio's CV. He was accused of this. He was accused of that." 33:33 Um, but, uh, I, I, I haven't seen much of the positive campaigning. 33:39 But, uh, just, uh, uh, because you said that, uh, Lula showed that he wants to negotiate with Congress, and I think that, uh, the fact that within a few days of, uh, him talking to the congressional leaders, he unclogged much of the government's, um, 33:59 uh, legislative agenda, uh, it speaks both to Lula's capacity as a negotiator, but it's also to, uh, how incompetent his government has been for three and a half years. 34:12 And because Lula has delegated a lot of the negotiating to underlings. And in Brazil's presidential system, the way that it is crafted, uh, the president has to be part of the negotiations. 34:26 You don't have, you can't do much if just your, uh, secretary of institutional relations is the one doing the talking. And 34:37 even worse than that, Lula's roster of political negotiators was a terrible one, uh, filled with incompetent people that, uh, w- at one point his liaison with Congress was not in speaking terms with the House speaker. 34:50 So, like, how can you do your job in the, in the, under those conditions? Uh, his Senate whip, uh, 34:58 did an appalling job in the, in many hearings committees and allowed the Lulinha case to be raised by the opposition and to become the sort of m- shadow ca- uh, that is being casted over the Lula campaign. 35:14 Um, the, the, the scandal involving the president's son that we have talked in previous episodes. 35:20 So I think that it showed, okay, uh, if Lula wants to govern the next four years if, if he wins, he will have to be more present in, uh, negotiations between the different branches of government, something he hasn't done over the past three and a half years. 35:38 Yeah, I think you're absolutely right. And the, the big question really is, is whether this final, i- if Lula wins, if this final, uh, mandate of the four years is something that- Mm-hmm... 35:46 not only manages to implement some programs that'll be popular to maintain the legacy of the, of the Workers' Party-led governments, but also if there can emerge in this four years a viable candidate to replace Lula. 35:58 And, and that's the other question too because Lula will not be running again. Uh, and this will be the, the... In, in four years it will be a very different political scenario obviously. 36:08 And, and one of the big challenges I think he'll have is not only finding a way to work with Congress and be much more hands-on, but also to how he can guide the, his coalition towards a possible strong candidate, uh, in, in tw- and, and 20, in 2030. 36:24 And I don't think that candidate is, uh, is João Doria. 36:27 I mean, he might end up being the candidate, but I'm not sure he's the one that's going to inj- en- en- en- uh, energize voters and, and, and carry the, the left-center coalition forward after the, uh, the next, uh- Especially because, uh, João Doria is not in the Workers' Party and, and I don't see the Workers' Party backing any candidate that is not one of their own. 36:49 Right. Unless there's a real internal crisis in, in a way that there's just no way out. But I agree with you. I think that's the tendency is to have a notion, "We are the mass-based party of the left. 36:58 We are hegemonic and we should stay at the leadership." And that, that, you know, makes sense from their point of view. 37:05 It also makes, doesn't make sense from the point of view of trying to build a broad-based coalition that can win and not just, uh, mark a position. Um, well, but that's for, that's far down the road. 37:15 I mean, the big question is what's gonna happen in the next, uh, the next five weeks. And I think it's all out there still to be determined. I think there's, it's a very fluid situation. 37:24 I think the tendency is for Lula to win, but it's gonna be very tight. But on the other hand, I think anything could happen as we know in Brazilian politics and Brazilian history. 37:33 The, the most strange twists of, of, of history can occur on a dime and, uh, we'll see if that happens again, uh, in the next five weeks as we approach the, the D-Days of the October elections. Yeah. 37:49 With that, I think, uh, we should, uh, we could call it a wrap. And, uh, thank you very much, James. Always a pleasure talking to you, and see you next week. See you next week. Great talking.