Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hello, my name is Gustavo Ribeiro. 0:12 I'm the editor-in-chief of the Brazilian Report, and this is another episode of Explaining Brazil, a podcast that we are doing in this electoral cycle in partnership with the Brazil Office Alliance. 0:23 And as always, I'm glad to welcome James Green, a historian for Brown University and president of the board of directors of the Washington Brazil Office. James, glad to see you again. It's great to see you today also. 0:39 So James, I think we have, uh, tons of stuff to talk about, and let's just delve right into it. 0:45 And I think I, I want to, um, w- both our org- or both of our organizations, uh, are and will be on the news this, uh, this two weeks now. 1:00 Uh, the Brazilian report hosted an event, uh, in which Flávio Bolsonaro, uh, once again echoed conspiracy theories around the, the Brazilian voting system, and the Brazil Office Alliance is taking a delegation to the US, uh, to debunk these myths and, uh, to, uh, reaffirm Brazilian sovereignty in these elections. 1:22 Because as we have talked over the past few weeks, um, there's a major concern in Brazil, and not without reason, that the US, uh, may try to interfere either, uh, before the election or after the election by not recognizing the results depending on how they go. 1:43 Um, so should we start talking about Flávio Bolsonaro? We talk about this past week, and then we go for next week? [chuckles] Let's do that. Go for it. So, uh, 1:56 uh, let's, uh, do a little context here because I think the Brazilian press did not do a good job in covering the event, uh, attended by Senator Flávio Bolsonaro. 2:08 So there is, uh, this series of events called Debating Brazil, which the Brazilian report is doing in partnership with consultancy agency Novo Celulo Comunicação, uh, of a very good friend of mine, Fabio Brilhante, 2:23 a, a, an excellent journalist based in Brasília. And, uh, our, uh, proposal was every election cycle, Brazil always look inwards. 2:32 And, uh, foreign policy has always been a very marginal, uh, aspect of Brazilian elections. 2:39 And we wanted to use the fact that, uh, we have, uh, a lot of audience from embassies and consulates and foreign governments because we cover Brazil in English and, uh, bring presidential candidates to, uh, talk to, um, 2:56 foreign ambassadors and lay out their vision for Brazil and how they see Brazil on the global stage. 3:02 It was an event that was meant to be more foreign policy-focused, but we gave candidates freedom to bring whatever issues they thought were, uh, the key issues that represented their views of Brazil and their campaigns. 3:19 So we started this, uh, event cycles a month ago on June the 16th with Chief Electoral Justice Kássio Nunes Marques, and he came, and he used his entire time precisely to reaffirm how trustworthy and how, uh, immune to, uh, to, to coding interference from foreign, uh, actors of the Brazilian voting systems. 3:46 He explained to foreign ambassadors in, uh, in, in, in detail how the process of ensuring that every voting machine, uh, has zero votes, uh, comput-computed, uh, at the time that the election are going to start, and how it's, uh, possible for every Brazilian to, uh, check the official counts of the Superior Electoral Court with the count that each individual ballot box will provide at the end because they have a printout with all the counts. 4:22 So, uh, he, he used the entire morning and luncheon to, uh, explain how the Brazilian, uh, voting system is accurate. 4:30 Gu-Gustavo, if I may interrupt, you know, uh, I was here in two thousand twenty-two, uh, invited by, um, uh, people to observe the electoral process, and the, the Electoral Court from São Paulo, uh, was in charge of receiving a international delegation. 4:46 And I went through two or three days of explanations too. 4:49 I was so impressed with how efficient and organized they are, especially compared to the United States, which has a decentralized voting system in which, uh, all kinds of forms of voting occur. 5:01 Uh, in Brazil, it's just really efficient, organized safeguards and possibility for hacking. It's really an amazing system. Uh, the United States should adopt it actually, if you wanna know the truth. 5:12 And so this is again what, uh, is happening when people question the system. It's just fake news. It's to create a panic or a lack of confidence in the electoral system, especially when one expects to lose an election. 5:26 That's what, uh, Donald Trump is doing today. So how did it go with the-- with Flávio? Yeah, and just, uh, just to continue, uh, on, on the June the 23rd, we had Romeu Zema. On June the 25th, we had Renan Santos. 5:40 Uh, we also invited Ronaldo Caiado, who has claimed not to have, uh, a free date to, to do it. 5:48 Uh, we are talking to the Brazilian government to bring President Lula or, uh, someone from his campaign to talk on the same venue. And on, uh, July 21st, we hosted Flávio Bolsonaro. 6:02 And again, the proposition of these events is not to do a grilling of the candidates. 6:07 It's to put on the same venue Uh, representatives of partnering countries with people who, uh, aspire to be, uh, uh, to, to take on the mantle of the highest office on the land and to, to let these candidates, uh, lay down their vision. 6:24 And both-- Flávio Bolsonaro right out of the gate is he brought the allegations, uh, of voter fraud. 6:34 Um, he, uh, talked about the recent, uh, claims from the US government made by Donald Trump, saying that, uh, CIA documents, uh, allege that a, a Venezuelan company, uh, Smartmatic, would have, 6:53 um, uh, uh, engaged in voter fraud for more than a dec-decade in Venezuela. And according to him, the Brazilian voting machines would share the same origin as the Smartmatic ones. 7:06 Now, it's important to say that, uh, claims about Smartmatic and, uh, its role in, uh, US elections have been deemed factually false by a Delaware judge and have been disproven by fact-checking agencies in Brazil and also by the Superior Electoral Court, which says that Smartmatic has absolutely no interference in building the machines or coding the program that run in those machines. 7:35 So it's fake news. It's, uh, really was something that Flávio Bolsonaro has taken from his mentor, uh, Donald Trump. 7:42 Donald Trump during the, the 250 anniversary celebrations at Mount Rushmore, uh, eh, you know, talked about the threat of communism in the United States, the fact that the elections were illegal, made a big point in a, a address to the nation, uh, 10 days ago that there was electoral fraud that was rampant in the United States. 8:02 And I think he's preparing, and I think Flávio's doing the same thing. It's preparing to, to deal with the fact that they're gonna lose. 8:09 And if they in fact do lose, this is the excuse they can give to their base of support not to lose them, not to lose their confidence, to say, "Well, we won, but they stole the election." 8:18 And I mean, this is- So, and the one thing that I think it's, it, it's fascinating is that, uh, the entire Flávio Bolsonaro pitch is, "I am the continuation of my father." 8:29 And I think this event, he, he did something and consciously so because he was the one that evoked the parallel that four years ago, uh, almost to the date, his father convened 100 foreign ambassadors to the presidential palace to talk about the voting system, and that's one of the reasons he has become ineligible for public office until 2030. 8:53 So, uh, i-in every aspect, Flávio Bolsonaro seems to be trying to emulate his father [chuckles]. 9:00 No, in a very bizarre way, and I think it's ag- really, it's a showing of a sign of the weakness of the campaign, the division within the campaign, the desperation to call Milei, the president of Argentina, to the convention of the PL to-- in the nomination convention. 9:14 All of this, uh, mere signs that he's not doing well and that he's having difficulty getting the center right to endorse his campaign, and therefore he's exer- he's doing the same playbook that Donald Trump use- uses, is, is going to use to justify. 9:29 In the case of the United States, I think it's very much the situation in which Donald Trump w-wants to be able to justify calling in the National Guard, uh, to intervene in, in, in specific key elections in which the Democrats have a likely possibility of winning a disputed district for control of the Congress. 9:47 And so, uh, Flávio's doing the same thing. It's a, it's a very familiar playbook, um, which, uh, it really does show a sign of his weakness, I think, in this election. 9:56 No, and I think that, uh, I don't know if you agree with me, but I also think this kind of claim is his sort of antidote for other negative news cycles that have popped this week, uh, against him. 10:10 He has been, uh, linked to Banco Master in multiple ways. The latest ones were, um, invoices that his one-man law firm would have issued through a shell company i- within the Banco Master ecosystem. 10:27 For those who are not aware, Banco Master is, uh, was a bank that was liquidated by the c-central bank because the central bank found it was laden with fraud, and, uh, its owner, Daniel Vercaro, is linked to the bribing of, uh, federal officials on all branches of government. 10:47 Um, and so, uh, th- he has issued three invoices, two of which were immediately canceled, and, uh, what Flávio says is that they are grilling him for money he has not received. 11:01 Now, people who are familiar with, uh, and I'm not saying that's the case, I'm just saying that people who are familiar with money laundering tactics have pointed out that this is a common, uh, practice among people who want to move money, uh, and create an appearance that, uh, financial records are squeaky clean when they are not. 11:24 Again, I'm not saying that's the case of Flávio Bolsonaro, just that it is a playbook that can also be used for, for that. 11:32 And there is speculation among some that in fact the money that he, um, that was sent-- that he was requesting from, from Banco Master for his father's-- the film on his father biography, a very inflated budget for the, for the film it seems, was per-perhaps also ways to channel money to the United States, not for the film, but actually to support Eduardo Bolsonaro. 11:52 Again, these are allegations. They're not proven, but there, there, there are people who are speculating this might be the, the situation that, that's going on there as well. 12:02 Yes, and I mean, uh, I think that it makes sense for Flávio to levy accusations against, uh, the voting system because Bolsonaro debating, uh, the trustworthiness of voting machines is home turf for him. 12:19 Uh, and it, uh, it deviates the news cycle instead of talking about his financial connections to Banco Master and, uh, the other problems, uh, surrounding his candidacy. 12:31 Again, looking to his, uh, master chef, the person who he's following, Donald Trump. Donald Trump does this all the time. The minute there's a bad news cycle, he'll come up with some crazy thing. 12:40 He'll recycle the idea of occupying Greenland or making some wild comment or claim to, to really try to change the news cycle. And he's, he's been quite good at that for many, many years. 12:51 Even before he was a political candidate, he was brilliant at manipulating the media in New York to his benefit. And so I think that's what Flávio's doing. I think you're right about that. 13:00 And it, again, it shows they're on the defensive. They're concerned about the results, although I still believe it's gonna be a very close race. 13:09 Now, I want to talk to you as well about other aspects of the Flávio event that the press, uh, did not pay attention to, and I think that, uh, it is important. 13:19 I think that, uh, Flávio, when he was asked about his positions on Ukraine and whether he would visit Kiev, uh, as, as president, he, uh, I think he shown-- he showed, um, a lack of, 13:36 uh, a doctrine on foreign policy. 13:39 And, uh, he mentioned that his father visited Moscow just before the, the conflict started, and, uh, he mentioned Brazil's reliance on Russian fertilizers, but he didn't answer that question. 13:52 And he said, uh, conflicts that, uh, and, uh, I will-- I'm paraphrasing here. He said that, "Of course, everyone is against all kinds of wars, but if something is not directly related to Brazil, Brazil should not, uh, 14:09 weigh on any sort of global situation," which I think goes against Brazil's, um, as-aspirations to be a global power. 14:20 I mean, a country that wants to be a global leader, uh, must not refrain from weighing in on global issues. And it shows how weak he is as a candidate, his program, his policies, what he's trying to argue. 14:34 I mean, of course, Brazil should be able to and have the right to make opin-- uh, have opinions on any global issue, whether it's the conflict in the Middle East or between Russia and Ukraine or, or Trump's tariff policy. 14:47 I mean, these are, these are givens that any sovereign nation has a right to think about and be a player. And you're, you're right. Brazil wants to be an international global player. 14:56 But independently of that aspiration, I think the Brazilian government and candidates alike have totally autonomy and should have strong opinions on what's going on internationally if they're interested in really using, uh, foreign, uh, issues as a way of engaging with the world and, and including promoting peace or promoting comp-- uh, dialogue between nations. 15:18 And he, he doesn't seem to really have a grasp on these questions very, very well. I, I'm not sure that he really is prepared to think about international issues in a sophisticated way. 15:28 And I think from what you're describing, that's what he revealed in, in his conversations. 15:34 One thing really, uh, caught my attention was when he said, "Well, but if I want to delve further into it, I would have to assemble, uh, a diplomatic team and, uh, take a look at what could be done and hasn't been done." 15:48 And I mean, we are less than three months away, uh, from an election. One would assume that a candidate who is, according to some polls, in a statistical tie for the presidency to 16:01 be paying more attention to this kind of issue, especially today when geopolitics has become, uh, so central in every kind of discussion, uh, when we talk about, uh, food policies, mineral policies, uh, trade policies. 16:18 I mean, you can't escape geopolitics. No, and especially the current, uh, imposition of a twenty-five percent tariff by the United States. These are very important questions that need, need to be addressed. 16:30 I mean, I think-- I re-- I'm remembering, uh, when in the debate with Kamala Harris, uh, Donald Trump was asked what his healthcare plan was. This is after 10 years of being a candidate. 16:40 He said, "Well, we have a concept of a plan," which means they don't have a plan, and they don't even have a concept of a plan. It was a way of kicking it down the road and saying they have nothing. 16:48 And I think, again, you're, you're indicating from the content of this event that it looks like Flávio may have a concept of a plan, but I don't know if he has any plan for anything. And this is really serious. 17:00 If you're, uh, claiming to be the leading opposition to the government in power and, and saying that you're capable of running a country as complex and as important as Brazil, it's, it's, it's a very-- it's a sign of weakness in my mind. 17:15 No, and another thing that, uh, and if I may just, uh, before we move on, uh, that really caught my attention was when he was talking about the fact that he wants to, in his words, he wants to bring to Brazil institutional stability, uh, and, uh, respect for the rule of law. 17:33 And he, he banged on the drum that the next president will be able to name four Supreme Court justices because three seats will be vacant over the next four years, and there's already a vacancy that has not been filled, so in-- a major power in an 11, uh, 17:52 seat court. And then he made a non-sequitur that really flabbergasted everyone present, and he said, "You know, Taiwan, that's China's problem. That's not Brazil's problem." 18:06 And I mean, that was crossing the street to walk on a banana peel [laughs]. There was nobody asking him about it. 18:13 And I, I just want to remind you that Brazil adheres to the one China principle, and, uh, Brazil officially considers Taiwan an, uh- In a, a part of China, 18:28 it has reaffirmed so, uh, even recently in 2023. Uh, and that's really reminded me of the Jair Bolsonaro years because during COVID, the-- both Jair Bolsonaro and members of his administration, 18:45 uh, were making a lot of xenophobic statements and, uh, the flag of Taiwan briefly became a far-right symbol in Brazil just as much as the US flag and the Isra-Israeli flag, uh, because it was a way of, uh, taking a shot at, at China. 19:04 And I want to remind, uh, uh, listeners as well that, uh, uh, there, there is a recent, um, uh, paper from, uh, 19:16 the Getúlio Vargas Foundation that, uh, we at the Brazilian report wrote about it, showing how Brazilian farmers who are a key constituency of Bolsonarismo, they do business with China, but their loyalty goes towards the US not. 19:38 No, I think, uh, you, you nailed it. I think the guy is not ready to be president and I think this is a very serious question and we'll see what the voters think about that. 19:47 Um, but it doesn't bode well and if we recall the way in which Jair Bolsonaro was extremely isolated, very, uh, incapable of articulating, uh, international relations, um, it's not a good sign. 20:02 It's not a good sign for Brazil and Brazil as a very large economy, an important country in, in Latin America and South America and, uh, aspirant of being a, a world player, a global player needs strong leadership that understands the complexities of geopolitics and can interact with them in an intelligent way. 20:22 Uh, and I think that's-- I think the-- what you're describing is a sign that that's not really what's going on there, uh, with, uh, his campaign. 20:31 Now, what Flávio did not do in this meeting with foreign ambassadors was to pledge again his allegiance to Washington, which he has done, uh, a few times over the past few months. 20:43 And I recall a March speech during a CPAC event in Texas where he said that, uh, Brazil could be the solution for the US to reduce its dependence on Chinese, uh, rare earths and critical minerals, uh, which brings us to, uh, foreign interference, uh, because that was ex- an explicit way, uh, in which Flávio asked for Washington to help him win the presidency and get this quid pro quo. 21:15 Um, now the Brazil Office Alliance is taking up a delegation to Washington to try to prevent precisely that from happening. So can you please talk a little bit about the initiative? Sure. 21:26 And, uh, it's not the first time, right? Right. 21:29 In 2022, in July, uh, 20 representatives from social movements went to Washington DC extremely concerned about the, the threats to democracy in Brazil and the threats to the electoral process. 21:42 And they wanted to be very clear to members in Congress and to other international entities in Washington DC, the inter-- uh, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, the Organization of American States, that social movements, social-- civil society was really worried that the elections could, could end in, in a, in a, in a, in a bad situation in which, uh, the government of Bolsonaro challenged the results or tried to overturn the election results, which is actually what happened essentially in the invasion of the, uh, of the government buildings on January 8th in 2023 after Lulu had been inaugurated when Jair Bolsonaro and others organized, um, an attempted coup with supportive sectors of the army. 22:29 What happened though in '22 was that the Biden government very m-- it was very, very clear in making statements that it believed in the electoral process, defended Brazilian democracy and would immediately recognize the outcome of the election and in fact within less than an hour after the electoral courts denou- uh, uh, announced that Lula had won the elections, they recognized the government. 22:52 So this year we're in a different situation because in '22 the Biden government was clearly defending the democratic process of Brazil and wanting to let it be very clear that the United States was in favor of 23:04 s- supporting Brazil in this process. In 2026 we have Donald Trump in power and Donald Trump doesn't believe in the electoral process in the United States. He doesn't believe in the legitimacy of elections. 23:16 He wants to interfere. He's been trying to manipulate them in a lot of ways and now he's announced very clearly that his candidate is, is Flávio Bolsonaro, that he wants to support him. 23:26 Michael Rubio, the, um, uh, Secretary of, of, uh, of State has made the same clear, uh, announcement about their loyalties towards Flávio Bolsonaro. 23:37 And so this delegation's message to people in the United States into Congress was, "Please help us by defending the non-intervention of the United States in our elections. We believe in sovereignty, national sovereignty. 23:55 The United States should not interfere. Donald Trump should not try to take a position on this election and try to manipulate the outcome." And it was a very clear, strong message. 24:06 We had representatives from 16 social movements in Brazil ranging from the Black movement to the feminist movement to the indigenous movement, human rights organizations which were very important and are very well known in Brazil with one clear message: "Please no intervention of the United States in the Brazilian elections." 24:26 And this is very important because unfortunately in 1962, many years ago Uh, when João Goulart was the president of the country, the United States, through the CIA, financed, um, with five million dollars campaigns to undercut the candidacy of governors who were running for the governorships in '62, who supported João Goulart. 24:48 And so they supported his opponents. This money would be about thirty-five million dollars today, which is a lot of money to interfere in an election. 24:56 And so, in fact, what this social movement, these representative social movements were saying is that we believe that the United States should respect the autonomy of our country, our sovereignty, and should not interfere in the elections. 25:11 And they appealed to members of Congress to speak out if the Donald Trump administration attempts to do that. 25:18 And the representatives with whom they met, uh, and the advisors to other, uh, offices were very unified in their concern about the integrity of the elections and the possibility that Donald Trump would try to tip the balance in favor of one candidate over another. 25:36 And so I'm very confident that they will be speaking out about the neces-necessity of respecting Brazilian sovereignty and the electoral process of Brazil, and denouncing the Trump administration should they try to do more than they've already done in this regard. 25:53 No, it's interesting you say that because at the same time, uh, US-Brazil relations continue to get more and more adversarial. This week, we had, uh, the twenty-five percent tariffs kicking in on Wednesday. 26:07 We are taping this on, uh, Friday, July twenty-fourth. And today, we had twelve point two percent being enforced. Uh, Brazil was among, 26:18 uh, roughly sixty countries, uh, found the, who the US finds are not doing enough to prevent the, the trade of, uh, goods that use forced labor. 26:29 Now, it's interesting because, uh, they carve out many exemptions so that that moral high ground does not, uh... 26:37 I mean, the fine print does not sustain it, uh, especially because Brazil has been considered by, uh, the International Labor Organization as a beacon of how countries should be tackling this issue. 26:51 Uh, Brazil has, uh, from mobile sp- inspection groups that were created in 1995 under, uh, the presidency of Fernando Henrique Cardoso to send labor inspectors, federal police, and prosecutors into remote areas to free workers. 27:07 Uh, we have written, rewritten the penal code to put, uh, um, exhaustive hours, degrading conditions, and debt bonda-bondage alongside outright coercion to qualify as, uh, as, as slave labor. 27:23 And we have created, during the Lula administration, the dirty list of slave labor that, um, publicly shames companies found guilty of that, and that brings many restrictions on loans from public banks. 27:38 So Brazil is doing its homework. I mean, Brazil is far from perfect, uh, on that, and there has been some setbacks, notably during the Jair Bolsonaro administration. 27:49 The budget for, uh, anti-slave labor, uh, actions fell fifty-five percent in real terms. We had this year, uh, BYD that was listed, uh, on the dirty list and then three days later removed. But I mean, uh, uh, 28:08 some setbacks aside, Brazil is doing its job on that, so it doesn't stand strictly- It's a, it's a pretext. Trump had a problem. 28:15 The Supreme Court declared that his initial tariffs were illegal, so he went back with his lawyers and went, "Well, how can I get around this? What is a, a loophole?" 28:23 Uh, and I'm not even sure that this loophole is gonna work, and, um, we'll see if it actually goes and ends up going to the Supreme Court to see if it's legitimate. But he's grasping at straws. 28:32 And I should point out, I mean, if-- I mean, one of the things that really impressed me about Brazil is that since the establishment of the new constitution in eight- in, uh, 1988 and a series of governments with ups and downs in the economy, there's been a real attempt to address some of the major problems of the country. 28:49 Another is child trafficking and, and sex trafficking, which I'm very impressed with the amount of propaganda about that, the announcements in the, in, in, in the airports about the illegality of this kind of activity. 29:00 The same thing with the, the labor, forced labor or equivalent to slavery. It's, it's a problem, but it's a problem that's being tackled. And to be very honest, in the United States, 29:14 immigrant workers working in the countryside many times are in similar conditions of virtual obligation to be there because they don't have a green card. 29:24 They don't have legal rights to be there, and they know at any moment they could be deported. And so they're exploited, and many of the people who hire them know that and could take advantage of that situation. 29:36 And of course, Trump is doing nothing about that. Nothing at all about that. 29:40 On the contrary, the only thing he's doing is deporting hardworking, uh, people from all over the world who come to the United States to get a better life. 29:48 And so it's another form of hypocrisy that the Trump administration is imposing on Brazil. And as you pointed out, because of high inflation in the United States, 29:59 orange juice, meat, and coffee have been exempt from the list of, of, of tariffs because the United States wants to get as much of these products into the country to keep prices lower. 30:11 And so it's, it's- And I mean, it's, uh, the, the bulk of slave, uh, of forced labor in Brazil is in agriculture, so [laughs] it's, uh- Right. No, it's, uh- [laughs] And, and, and so it's a, it's a way of Trump... 30:26 The, the worst thing about-- There are two really horrible things about that. First, it's a horrible policy. It's a stupid policy. It doesn't work. 30:32 But he continues to lie to the American people Who still think, those who have not really paid attention to this, that a tariff imposed on the country is a punishment against the country because that country has to pay the tariff, but that's not the case. 30:48 The importer, the American importer of shoes, Brazilian shoes, has to pay now a twenty-five percent tariff over the shoe price, which means they're gonna r-rack it up the, uh, ratchet up the price of, of this product in the market. 31:03 It's gonna make it less competitive. 31:05 It's gonna be harder for Brazil to export to the United States because there were barriers, barriers created by Donald Trump in the tariffs he's imposing on these countries, um, uh, in, in order to, to hold back the importation. 31:20 And as we pointed out, Brazil has a trade, uh, a positive trade balance with the United States. It's not a negative one. 31:28 Brazil i-imports more US goods than it exports to the United States, and it's driving many, uh, producers to other countries to, to have outlets, and China is a clear example of that. Chief among them China, yeah. 31:42 If the, if the United States was really concerned about China as a serious competitor, then it should be doing everything possible to lower the possibilities of bringing goods to the United States because, you know, owner of, of soy, a trader in soy-soybeans is gonna look at the market and say, "I can't afford to sell my, sell my soybeans to the United States. 32:02 I'm gonna sell them to China. There's a demand there." And so it's, it's really shooting at people in the foot. Trump is obsessed by this policy. It is a very bad policy. 32:11 Ninety-five percent of all economists in the United States point that out, but he won't let go, and he's a stubborn person that insists that everything he does is perfect, it's right, and so he's gonna insist on this, and it's creating a animosity among all of US allies around the world. 32:27 It, it's as if Trump is in the presidency to destroy the, the United States, to bring it down, to make it weaker, and to align- No, one thing that I find- His policy. It's just criminal as far as I'm concerned. Yes. 32:40 No, and one thing that I, I, I find, uh, interesting about this is that the Trump administration's antagonism toward Brazil might be or is already undoing decades of US soft power here because many polls show Brazilians and Latin Americas, Latin Americans generally warming to China, uh, and even if some sectors like farmers, as I mentioned, remain wary of Beijing. 33:06 But just this week, uh, poster PoderData asked whether Brazil should align more closely, uh, with China or the US. So a year ago, uh, the US led by twenty-seven points. 33:20 Fifty-nine percent said Brazil should be closer to the US, thirty-two said that Brazil should be closer to China. Now China leads by seventeen points. 33:30 Fifty-two percent say Brazil should be closer to China and only thirty-five to the US, so it's, uh, uh, the currents have split. Trump... No, and Trump has no m-macro vision. He re- he's reactive, he's impulsive. 33:45 He, he, he, he b-builds policy based on what he thinks at that moment, not based on reality, not based on a series of experts who will listen to him and challenge him. He only has yes-men around him. 33:56 And now he has, uh, a relationship with sectors of Brazilian society which he intends to build that kind of relationship with. Um, you know, the government of Brazil very rightly said, "We have rare minerals. 34:08 We wanna, we wanna put them on the market. 34:10 This is a wonderful export opportunity for the United States or for, for Brazil, but we wanna make sure that we control how this happens, and we wanna be able to gain from not just sending abroad, uh, minerals that are valuable in terms of, of that production, but we want to also have the ability to be able to process many of these minerals ourselves so that we can benefit economically from this resource that we have, this amazing, uh, mineral resource." 34:36 And it's really important to do that because unfortunately, since colonial times, one of the major models is w-was export. First of, of sugarcane- Mm... 34:45 uh, and then of gold, and then of coffee is the three major export items. And now soybeans. And now soybeans is the f- the fourth major and, and to a certain extent meat products as well. And so 34:57 i-in order to, to kind of break that 34:59 dependency or that relationship of basing the entire economy on export of products is to s- find ways to add value in the country to what is exported to help the economy of Brazil and to benefit from that as opposed to just a-allowing countries to come in and take out of the country everything that they deem that they need for their, for their own economies. 35:22 And so, um, one needs to be able to be firm and stand up for sovereignty of the nation, uh, and, and establish limits, and I think that's not what's happening, uh, with one, one side in the elections. 35:36 Uh, and so the delegation, which was a nonpartisan delegation, it was not involved in discussing candidates and parties, was basically talking about the necessity for the United States government to stay out of the Brazilian elections, not to interfere, not to try to influence them, not to side with one candidate over another candidate. 35:55 And that was a very important message which I think that people who listened to them took very seriously. 36:02 Um, and, and hopefully this will generate more awareness in the US Congress about, uh, plans that Trump might try to im-im-im-impose before the elections or after the elections to kind of block it or to, to put a brake on it, as I believe we were able to do in '22 in putting a brake on the possibility of some kind of military overthrow of the Lula government because the f- the armed forces in the United Sta-- uh, in Brazil said, "If the United States is not behind us, we're not gonna join The coup attempt. 36:38 And so the armed forces in Brazil were split, and a sector refrained from, uh, joining the attempted coup to overthrow the legally elected government of, of Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. 36:51 Now, uh, I remember one phrase that I, uh, I said that, uh, in our first podcast together that, uh, 36:59 many in Brazil, uh, resented the fact that the US, since the end of the Cold War, never really paid attention to Brazil, uh, when drafting its foreign policy. 37:09 And now that the US is paying attention, uh, many people are, uh, might be, uh, saying, "Well, we should watch out for what we wish for." It reminds me of, uh, one phrase that, um, is credited to, uh, an ancient 37:27 Mexican president, Porfirio Díaz, "Pobre México tan lejos de Dios, y tan cerca de Estados Unidos." Poor Mexico, so far from God, so close to the US. 37:37 [chuckles] You know, the United States and Brazil have a lot of similarities and a lot of sharedness in terms of their common legacies of enslaving people in order to create tremendous wealth in the country, frontier societies. 37:51 There are many, many things in, in common between the two countries, and there is a possibility of a fair, egalitarian, horizontal relationship between the two, and not a vertical one, not one in which the United States imposes on Brazil. 38:05 And I think that that is the intent to try to build that kind of relationship, respecting Brazil's sovereignty and its autonomy, but trying to find ways to build connections between the two countries that are positive connections, that are respectful of each, each, each, each c-country's autonomy and its independence and its, its tradition. 38:24 And unfortunately, uh, Trump is not interested in that at this moment. He's interested in creating, uh, a, a, a Latin America which is dominated by the extreme right, and he's doing everything possible to do that. 38:36 He also wants to create a situation in which Cuba is vulnerable to, uh, uh, resi-regime change. 38:44 Um, he's little-- having a little difficulty doing this because of his involvement in the endless war in Iran, but that's one of the intentions of the State Department, Marcos Rubio, Marco Rubio, um, Vice President JD Vance, and the president. 38:58 And so it's a very serious moment, and I think it's very important when voices can speak out against US intervention, uh, in Brazilian affairs. There's a tradition. 39:10 There's a tradition of activists and scholars and Brazilianists and a few Brazilians living in the United States during the military regime of speaking out very widely against US intervention in Brazil to support the military regime. 39:24 I wrote a, a book about this, which in, in English is called We Cannot Remain Silent: Opposition to the Brazilian Dictatorship in the United States, also published in Brazil. 39:32 Uh, and so this new initiative that, uh, the Brazil Office Alliance, uh, working with the Washington Brazil office took, took, took, took on is a very important attempt for people-to-people democ-- uh, dip-diplomacy, for respect for sovereignty and autonomy, and the defense of democracy, which is really crucial in this moment, uh, worldwide. 39:57 Well, James, I think we can leave it there. Uh, as always, was an excellent, uh, uh, moment talking to you and, uh, um, uh, impatiently waiting for next week when, uh, 40:12 where we're, we're going to read it again, and possibly with more crazy stuff happening [chuckles] between now and then. Well, you know, the World Cup is over. The pre-election star- is starting. 40:20 I think the n- the only thing that's gonna be talking-- being talked about in Brazil for the next, uh, hundred days is gonna be the elections, the elections, the elections. 40:28 It's the obsession in the United States and in other parts of the world. It's gonna be a very important period in October, uh, and early November for Brazil, for the United States, and for the world. 40:37 Let's, let's continue our dialogue, and let's