Transcript 0:00 [gentle music] Hello there. I'm Gustavo Ribeiro, the editor-in-chief of The Brazilian Report. Once again, our podcast is being recorded from my office space at home. So we apologize for the less than ideal audio quality. 0:15 But the entire building where our studios are located, next to Avenida Paulista, is in full lockdown. That also explains why we delayed the publishing of this episode. 0:28 Two weeks ago, we spoke with economist Monica de Bolle about what the government should do in order to avoid a recession in Brazil. 0:37 But so much has changed in these two weeks, and I know that because the day we published that episode, March 11th, was my birthday, which also happened to be the second last day I left my building. 0:52 In these past two weeks, cases of COVID-19 have exploded in Brazil. States have put themselves in quarantine. And recession, which seemed like a possibility, now is a fait accompli. 1:08 The question is, how bad will things get? [dramatic music] That's what we try to answer this week. My name is Gustavo Ribeiro, and you're listening to Explaining Brazil. 1:34 Before we get into this week's show, I want to do a little recap on the evolution of the COVID-19 outbreak in Brazil. In two weeks, we went from having 52 to having nearly 3,000 confirmed cases and almost 100 deaths. 1:53 But some studies indicate that the official number may account for only 11% of the real number of cases. 2:01 In some favelas dominated by drug trafficking gangs, criminals have installed a curfew and ordered social distancing. States have shut down all non-essential commerce. 2:15 But President Jair Bolsonaro wants the economy to get back to normal. Nossa vida tem que continuar. Os empregos devem ser mantidos. O sustento das famílias deve ser preservado. 2:30 He says that allowing for a recession is going to create grave social problems far worse than the outbreak itself. Felipe Campante is a professor at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies. 2:47 Professor, thanks for joining us on Skype. I want to ask you, what do you make of President Jair Bolsonaro's approach to the coronavirus? 2:56 I mean, he does have a point when he links recessions to the increase of mortality in Brazil. 3:02 But is his approach a reasonable one, considering that most experts say social isolation is the only way to contain massive infections? It's hard for me to say kind of from an epidemiological perspective, of course. 3:18 Uh, but, I mean, it definitely looks like, uh, you know, things are going to get pretty bad. 3:25 Uh, and I think the economic repercussions of that are, are quite striking because, uh, this is not, uh, your, your standard, uh, you know, economic shock or economic crisis where you might wanna think about how we would want to avoid recession. 3:46 I think now, uh, uh, to put it bluntly, uh, like, we need a recession in order to fight the virus, right? So, like, we, we need economic activity to go down because we need people 4:02 to engage in social distancing, right? 4:05 So I guess the, the, the right question to ask is what can we do to make sure that people can go through this moment without losing their livelihoods and, and without, uh, uh, uh, suffering too much, uh, uh, uh, damage from an economic perspective. 4:26 But I think it's, it's a very unusual situation because, uh, we don't want economic... And, and it, it's not even that, uh, that we don't want, but we cannot have a normal economic, uh, uh, uh, uh, 4:40 scenario taking place, right? So it's not a situation where we, where we can choose between having social distancing and having normal economic activity because, you know, the shock is not the social distancing. 4:56 The shock is the virus, right? 4:57 As long as the virus is out there, people are going to refrain from, from, you know, going to the restaurants and going to, uh, uh, you know, through their normal, through their normal lives because they're gonna be afraid of the virus. 5:11 And, uh, as a result, what we really need is to do as much as we can to make sure that the, the, the, the virus is under control and that we can help people through this process. 5:28 Many countries are passing stimulus programs to help people weather the crisis. In Brazil, government measures have come bit by bit and dwarf next to what other countries do. 5:41 The government proposed to give 200 reais to informal workers per month for three months, then increased it for 600 reais. 5:52 That's roughly $120 per month, and the Economy Ministry says that's because Brazil does not have the same economic firepower of other countries and that the country can't afford to swing and miss Is that a fair assessment? 6:09 We're going through a very, very hard situation, you know, akin to a war. You know, obviously, like, with all the, the, the, you know, the appropriate, uh, uh, uh, caveats on the, on the comparison. 6:21 But what we need is to borrow resources from the future, right? So our future selves, you know, us, uh, you know, years from today, uh, are not going, are, are not gonna be going through a pandemic. 6:39 So we need to borrow from our future selves to help smooth, uh, uh, and soften the blow that we are, that we are suffering right now, right? 6:48 So we need to be spending, uh, uh, uh, heavily right now to make sure that, uh, uh, uh, you know, we have appropriate resources to deal with the public health situation and to provide for the people whose livelihoods are threatened. 7:04 Again, not because people are making up, uh, uh, uh, constraints on, on, on, uh, uh, uh, you know, social interactions, but because there's a virus out there. 7:14 You know, if you're in a situation, let's say, like Canada, so Canada just announced this policy where they're basically going to be providing income, you know, $2,000 a month for anyone who has lost a job or needs to, you know, take care of a relative or, you know, is sick. 7:28 So, so that's the right policy, right? But doing that in Canada obviously is, uh, uh, a bit easier than doing that in Brazil. There's been very little, uh, leadership, uh, coming from the federal government. 7:43 Uh, you know, on much to the contrary, it seems that, you know, like, the president in particular has been sort of undermining, uh, uh, uh, uh, a lot of the, the efforts that are, that are necessary. 7:54 And I think that translates into a policy response that ha- that has been, I think, uncoordinated and, and very timid, and I think poorly, poorly designed, uh, uh, uh, in particular. 8:06 So the measures that have been, uh, announced, uh, uh, uh, have also, 8:11 you know, uh, not been, uh, uh, uh, you know, even setting aside the size, uh, but just, like, the, the proper targeting and, in particular, kind of really 8:22 trying to reach the people who are most vulnerable and who need most help, which is, you know, the, the, the, uh, the people, uh, in the informal sector and the, uh, uh, the poorest. 8:33 Uh, I think it's been very poorly calibrated, uh, in that sense as well. So, uh, you know, on the one hand, I mean, it, it is true that, uh, uh, uh, you know, Brazil has, 8:44 you know, less, uh, resources available than, than, than the US or Canada or the UK or, or, or what have you. 8:54 But I, I think, you know, we really need to make a, a, a push commensurate with the size of the problem and, uh, with the size of our economy, right? So, you know, I think we really need to, to, you know, to spend 9:09 a lot of resources in trying to fight this because, like I said, it's a matter of, like, borrowing resources from the future to fight an emergency. It's, it's, it's like a war, right? 9:20 You, you can't just say, like, "Well, uh, we can't spend a lot, uh, uh, on this," or, or, you know, this is, uh, we need to, to keep, uh, you know, business as usual, or, or, you know... 9:36 It's just an emergency situation, and you need to act accordingly. I think it's, it's, it's, it's very important. And you really don't see that, especially coming from the federal government. 9:45 I think the, uh, uh, Congress has been, I think, more, more attuned. The, uh, governors and, and, and, uh, local governments I think have been more, uh, uh, responsive. 9:56 But unfortunately, that's something that, that needs, uh, you know, by the very nature of the situation, it needs coordination from the top. And, and unfortunately, this has been sorely lacking, I think, uh, uh, 10:08 you know, to a large extent because, uh, we have, uh, leaders, and the President in particular, who, who really, uh, you know, doesn't seem to be attuned to the, to the, to the nature of the situation. 10:22 And I think that's, that's, that's a tragedy. 10:25 The president defends no restrictions on movement and commerce, but then 25 of 27 governors have said they would just ignore him and go ahead quarantining their states and leaving stores closed. 10:40 How does this political deadlock impact the effectiveness of our response to COVID-19? Because in our political system, there's only so much a president can do without the support of local administrations and vice versa. 10:56 Yeah, no, I think it really, uh, you know, this, uh, uh, uh, um, frankly, uh, uh, uh, insane, uh, uh, approach, uh, from the president hugely undermines, uh, the response because listen, you know, the virus doesn't 11:12 care about state borders, right? Uh, uh, uh, this is something that needs, uh, uh, uh, a centralized approach, right? 11:20 The, the, the firepower of the federal government in terms of mobilizing resources is much greater than, than, uh, the, the states in isolation. 11:28 So that, that's simply, uh, uh, uh, you know, something that really requires this type of coordination, uh, for it to be effective. And, and the absence of that coordination is, is hugely damaging, right? 11:40 Now, you know, the fact that, uh, uh, uh, uh, the president is isolated in, uh, uh, in terms of, of his response, 11:49 it's basically coming from the reality that, again, the problem is not the measures that are being taken to try and contain the virus. The problem is the virus, right? 11:58 As long as the virus is out there, the economy will not be operating as normal because people will not be, uh, going about their business as normal, right? 12:08 And- If the virus, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, if the situation worsens, which is bound to happen, right? You know, the evidence is overwhelming in that regard. 12:17 You know, if people, uh, uh, uh, uh, even going back to the 1918, uh, uh, uh, flu, uh, pandemic, right? 12:25 There's this evidence that, you know, as social distancing measures were, uh, withdrawn because people felt like the situation was improving, then the, the, the, the, the, the virus came back. 12:35 So if the situation gets worse, then the economic situation is gonna get worse because people are going to be more scared, people are gonna be more concerned, and are gonna be, you know, even less likely to, you know, go about their businesses. 12:48 Like, just think about it frankly. Like, you know, if... Would you wanna go to a restaurant right now knowing that there's this vir- th- this virus out there, right? 12:58 And even if you are, you should be aware that, like, lots of other people wouldn't because they would be scared of the virus, and so on and so forth. 13:05 So it's, it's just the reality of, uh, uh, uh, the pandemic that, that is the real problem, right? So we can't pretend that we can go about, uh, uh, uh, you know, business as usual because it's just not possible. 13:20 The president accuses governors of acting with ulterior motives, eyeing the next presidential elections. 13:28 And to his point, some governors, and I'd singled out São Paulo's João Doria or Rio's Wilson Witzel here, they do seem to have, uh, some ulterior motives in their actions, especially Doria seemed to taunt Bolsonaro at every turn. 13:45 For instance, the São Paulo governor has disclosed his negative COVID-19 test results and then urged Bolsonaro to do the same. Politicians are gonna do politics, right? So that's, that's to be expected. 14:00 And, and, you know, there's, there's, there's just no other way. Uh, uh, uh, you know, that's, that's what they're gonna do. So I think, uh, uh, um, you know, speculating about ulterior motives or, or, or, 14:15 uh, uh, uh, thinking about the motivations, uh, uh, uh, is not the right way to think about this, right? I think we need to think about, like, what people are doing, right? 14:23 And is what they, uh, are doing something that helps solve the problem or is it not, right? I think that's the right question to ask. And, uh, uh, uh, 14:36 you know, I think the governors are being much more constructive in terms of what they are doing to control the pandemics than, uh, uh, uh, the president is. 14:47 And I think, you know, all of them have political, uh, aspirations, and all of them have political motives. That's, that's not the difference. 14:55 The difference is whether they are helping or they're not, and I think that's, that's how we wanna think about that. 15:04 And, and I think, uh, uh, uh, you know, any major event is going to be a political, uh, uh, uh, a political event, right? And is gonna have political implications. 15:18 And, you know, part of it, you know, some research that I'm doing right now is, is exactly kind of looking at the impact of the Ebola, uh, uh, crisis, a much, much smaller crisis, uh, in the context of the US, but the impact that it had in US politics and how it was sort of exploited by politicians. 15:37 So that's nothing new. That's nothing that, that, uh, uh, um, you know, is unexpected or surprising. I think the real crux of the matter is 15:49 what is the policy response, and, and that's how, that's how we should judge, uh, uh, what the politicians are doing. 15:57 My next question was precisely about that study on the influence of the Ebola scare in the US 2014 midterm elections. What did your research tell you about that? Yeah. 16:09 So that's a, that's a very interesting episode, uh, because, uh, uh, you know, the Ebola, uh, crisis hit the US, uh, as it were, uh, back in 2014, really in the month before, uh, the midterm elections of that year. 16:25 So it was really, uh, very much, uh, uh, uh, you know, right as campaign season was at its, was at its peak. 16:34 And, and it, you know, it's, it's, uh, it's a very different context, uh, from what we have now in the sense that, uh, the public health impact was much, much, much smaller, right? 16:49 But it was a very important, uh, uh, source of anxiety and, and fear at the time. And what we find is that, uh, uh, uh, first of all, uh, it, it did have, uh, an impact. 17:02 In particular, it really led to a, a worse, uh, performance, uh, um, from the Democrats in the election. 17:09 So we find that places that displayed greater, uh, concerns with Ebola, uh, uh, uh, the Democrats did worse and, and, and there was a, there was a, there was a causal impact of the concerns on the Democratic electoral performance. 17:25 Now, and the other thing is that the, the situation was strategically exploited by politicians, and in particular, Republican candidates, uh, uh, uh, really jumped, uh, uh, on it and, and started talking a lot about Ebola. 17:41 And, and not just talking about it, but talking about it in conjunction with specific topics, uh, of strategic interest to them, right? 17:49 So they were talking about Ebola, uh, in conjunction with immigration and, you know, borders and, and with Obama kind of trying to associate, uh, uh, uh, the crisis with, uh, uh, with, with these topics. 18:03 And, and the interesting thing is that some of that Worked for them, uh, from that political perspective, and some of, some of that didn't, right? 18:10 So we find that there was no impact on, uh, uh, Obama's approval ratings, right? 18:17 So the, the, the attempt to kind of try to undermine, uh, uh, uh, um, Obama's, uh, uh, uh, approval, um, or, or his standing with the public by tying him to Ebola doesn't seem to have worked. 18:30 But it, it does seem to have worked, uh, when it comes to immigration. So we do find evidence that people, uh, uh, uh, you know, voters responded by, uh, becoming more, uh, uh, uh, um, anti- anti-immigration. 18:45 And is it possible to anticipate in any way how this COVID-19 pandemic is going to affect elections in Brazil? Because, I mean, we are set to have municipal elections in October. I think it too early to tell. 18:59 Uh, uh, like I said, you know, in the case of Ebola, it was something that was happening literally like, you know, during the, the, the month before the election. 19:07 So it was like, uh, you know, kind of a, a, a more immediate impact and, and who knows what's gonna happen between now and, and, um, October. 19:16 But I think there's a, there's a, an even more basic concern, which is like, are we gonna be in a position to actually, you know, have a normal election? 19:24 Uh, uh, or are we gonna be in a situation where we're still gonna, uh, you know, have to have social distancing measures in place? And I think that's, that's a, that's a very serious dilemma. 19:35 I think this is a, this is a real dilemma. 19:38 And in the case of Brazil, I think, uh, it's, it's, it's made worse, uh, uh, by the fact that we don't have, uh, uh, uh, you know, vote by mail as we have in the US, for instance, right? 19:50 So I th- you know, the US, we're gonna have a presidential election this year, and that's a, that's a big, that's a big question. 19:57 But here, at least, the, the solution is already kind of in place, which is, well, we should just kind of extend this, uh, uh, uh, um, you know, alternative of, of, uh, vote by mail that already exists. 20:10 And, you know, let's, you know, the, the obvious solution is to, to, to try to make it, uh, uh, uh, uh, you know, to ramp it up and, and, and, you know, even make it like the default option. 20:20 Whether it's gonna be implemented is a, is a separate question, especially given, you know, in the US, we don't have a national election. We have, you know, a number of state-run elections, right? 20:29 But in the case of Brazil, where we, where all the voting is basically, uh, you have to, you have to show up and, and, and vote, this is clearly a problem from a, from a public health perspective. 20:40 And it's, it's not clear at all that, uh, uh, uh, come October, we're gonna be in a, in a, in a position to hold this type of massive conglomeration of people, uh, uh, um, safely. 20:54 The president seems to be more and more isolated. 20:57 Our Brazilian correspondent, Brendeno Grillo, reported on Tuesday that political leaders have begun negotiating how to proceed with an impeachment process against Bolsonaro, and this was corroborated by four independent sources. 21:12 How do you see this crisis unfolding? 21:15 On the one hand, I think, uh, uh, uh, there's a, there's a lot of volatility, uh, uh, uh, because just this is such a, such a huge, uh, uh, event, uh, that, and evolves like so rapidly that it, that is, that is hard to, to predict. 21:30 But I think in general, it, it, it really has reduced, uh, Bolsonaro's, uh, uh, room for maneuver because, you know, through his own, uh, uh, uh, inapt response, I think it's become, like, quite clear that he 21:46 not only is not someone who you, you would wanna have in charge, uh, in a situation like that, but he's actively, like, a problem, right? And, and, and, and in that sense, I think he is, uh, uh, uh, um, 22:02 creating his own isolation. 22:04 And in some sense, I, I think that, uh, uh, there is, there is little appetite for, for an impeachment process because I think people understand that there's, like, the trauma involved and, and the risks that, you know, how he might react and so on. 22:17 But it's almost like he's forcing, uh, people's hands, uh, as he makes himself, uh, such a huge hindrance, right, such a huge problem, uh, uh, for dealing with, uh, with the crisis. 22:28 And I think as the perception that that is the case increases, uh, I think Bolsonaro will end up being sidelined in one way or another, uh, either, you know, sort of formally through, like, an impeachment process or, you know, through some sort of, uh, you know, 22:48 as we've noticed recently. 22:49 Like, so governors have been meeting and, and, and discussing, uh, uh, uh, measures with Congress without Bolsonaro's even being present, so the people just kind of bypassing it and, you know, pretending that he doesn't exist. 23:02 But if he, uh, uh, uh, you know, keeps reminding us that he exists and that, you know, by, by, 23:11 you know, compromising and, and, and damaging the efforts towards fighting this emergency, I think he's, he, he makes the situation, uh, uh, more unsustainable, uh, uh, um, more and more unsustainable. 23:25 So I think, you know, if, if before this episode, I think, you know, the, the, you know, there was a, there was a non-negligible possibility that Bolsonaro could, could, you know, try something, uh, uh, you know, 23:43 some- something like a self-coup or something like that or kind of trying to, like, really kind of a, a, a, a frontal attack on, on democratic institutions. 23:51 I think now he may even try that, but I think the, the, his chances of succeeding are, are going down at a very fast pace because, you know, I, I think the people who he would need to support such an adventure, you know, in the military and, and, uh, the business community and so on and so forth, I, I think, you know, there's been an increasing perception that he is, he is a problem. 24:16 And, and in, in that sense, I think the scenario is very volatile because as, you know, he becomes more isolated, perhaps kind of there is a greater incentive for him to try something, uh, uh, uh, more radical. 24:31 I think his scope for actually succeeding with that, 24:34 you know, on balance, I think has been going down because, uh, you know, it's, I think it's, it's becoming clearer and clearer that, uh, uh, again, he's, he's, he's not part of the solution. 24:45 He's, he's actually like a big problem. If you like this podcast, please rate us with five stars. That will give us a push to reach more listeners. And take a look at our website. 25:01 Every day we have new exclusive content, including a live COVID-19 blog our team is diligently filling with the most relevant updates about the outbreak. 25:13 Also, subscribing to The Brazilian Report is the best way to help this show. Plans start at less than $4, which is less than a latte on Starbucks if you're in São Paulo. Just go to brazilian.report/subscribe. 25:31 And that's it for this week. Stay safe, wash your hands, and listen to your podcast backlog while in self-isolation. My name is Gustavo Ribeiro, and this was Explaining Brazil. 25:46 [outro music]