Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Brazilian sovereignty is under threat. 0:04 US President Donald Trump has been trying to pressure Brazil not to put former President Jair Bolsonaro on trial for allegedly leading a coup attempt after he lost the twenty twenty-two elections. 0:19 Trump has also complained about Brazil's tech regulations. 0:23 The pressure has already come in the form of sky-high trade tariffs, as well as in the form of an investigation into what Washington calls unfair trade practices and signs of distancing in the military field. 0:38 Brazil has so far resisted. Yet in the twenty-first century, a country's sovereignty or its capacity for self-determination goes far beyond borders. It lies in the cloud, and there too, the United States holds dominance. 0:56 Brazil's exposure to the US in this regard is in fact substantial. 1:01 Experts note, for instance, that roughly sixty percent of Brazil's digital data traffic is hosted in data centers in Virginia, including websites, apps, e-commerce, banking operations, and even public health services. 1:19 So can Brazil assure its digital sovereignty? My name is Gustavo Ribeiro, editor-in-chief of The Brazilian Report. This is Explaining Brazil. 1:30 [upbeat music] In the latest Digital Sovereignty Index, Brazil ranked forty-fifth out of fifty-seven countries with a score of just two point forty-four. 1:51 To give you a sense of scale, Finland, the leader, scored sixty-four point five; Germany, fifty-three point eight. 2:00 Brazil is not just behind, it's barely on the map, and this matters because digital sovereignty is about far more than just technology. It's about power. 2:12 It's a country's ability to control the infrastructure, the data, the standards that underlie its economy and its democracy. The World Economic Forum breaks it into three layers. 2:25 The physical layer, the servers and the cables; the code layer, the rules and the protocols; and the data layer, who owns and controls the information that flows through all of it. 2:39 In Brazil, this debate has become urgent. Universities, public agencies, and even ministries, the backbone of Brazil's scientific and political life, depend on cloud services from companies like Microsoft and Google. 2:55 Intelligence information has been shared over WhatsApp, and local infrastructure is so weak that even open source tools often have to be hosted abroad. Who builds the systems we rely on? Who controls the infrastructure? 3:10 And what does that mean for democracy, security, power? And can other countries offer solutions for Brazil? This week I'm joined by Luca Belli. 3:22 He's a professor of digital governance and regulation at the Getulio Vargas Foundation's Law School in Rio de Janeiro, where he directs the Center for Technology and Society and the CyberBRICS Project. 3:36 He also sits on Brazil's National Cybersecurity Committee and has worked with the Council of Europe on Internet governance. Welcome, and thanks for joining us this week. Thank you very much for inviting me. 3:52 So I want to start with the United States. Brazil today is facing mounting pressure from President Donald Trump, particularly in trade and defense. 4:03 Those tensions can easily be extended into the digital sphere, given how reliant Brazil is on US-based platforms and providers. How 4:14 vulnerable is Brazil, and what might these sort of tensions translate into the digital sphere? 4:22 Well, uh, Brazil, as most countries actually, is, uh, pretty vulnerable, and I think that's, uh, the reason why, uh, the current administration is keeping a pretty low profile, if you want, in discussion is precisely because they have a very good understanding, uh, perhaps not the best possible understanding, but a pretty good understanding of the level of vulnerability of the country. 4:50 Uh, and again, that is not a Brazilian peculiarity. Uh, pretty much all countries, uh, around the world, with the exception of the US and China, are, uh, dependent on foreign technologies, uh, in... 5:05 of foreign digital technologies. And, uh, even countries like Russia that, uh, have spent the past decade to try to create some... 5:16 their own version of digital sovereignty that is very close to what we could define digital autarky, at the end of the day, they are very much reliant on Chinese technology. 5:26 So, uh, that is really something that we have mapped quite extensively in our research on digital sovereignty in the BRICS, uh, grouping of the past five or six years. 5:36 And, uh, yeah, it is quite evident that, uh, these, uh, the findings of our research that are particularly focused on the BRICS grouping, uh, they apply, uh, in similar fashion to other countries. 5:52 Even very, uh, developed nations like European, uh, Union member states, they are very much dependent on US technology. 6:02 And actually, in this case, it might be even more frustrating to some extent because, uh, in Europe it's something... 6:10 or digital sovereignty is something that is discussed as a priority at least, uh, since two thousand and twenty. 6:16 And, and s- you see that, uh, uh, nowadays the entire continent is still very much dependent on digital technologies. 6:26 Uh, as, uh, to some extent Brazil is I, I think that to some extent Brazil is e- even le- a little bit less dependent, [chuckles] uh, paradoxically than, uh, uh, European countries. 6:39 In Europe, there is not such a, such a thing as, uh, as Pix Uh, our digital public infrastructure for online payment, uh, in countries like Brazil or India or, or Russia, this is common. 6:52 Uh, in Europe, uh, the most of countries are totally dependent on US, uh, technology for, uh, online payments, on Visa and MasterCard, uh, particularly. 7:04 So, um, at least Brazil has, to some extent, uh, managed to achieve some sort of success in reducing the dependency and creating, uh, a little bit of technological autonomy, uh, but it's still very vulnerable. 7:22 Now, when we talk about the Trump administration, we have seen that, um, President Trump has inserted the US government into many US companies in extraordinary ways for the United States, including, uh, pushing for a cut of Nvidia's, uh, revenue from China. 7:42 On Friday, last Friday, Intel agreed to allow the US government to take a 10% stake in its business. Um, we have seen Apple, uh, bending over backwards to please Trump. Uh, 7:57 when we see the U- US tech companies and their unwillingness to resist pressure from the Trump administration, given the tensions between the Trump White House and Brazil, 8:13 what does that pose as a risk for our country? Well, actually, you know, uh, I mean, the Trump administration is very transactional, right? 8:20 So they are, uh, trying to pursue their own, what they perceive to be their own interest. 8:26 I'm not sure that they are always successful in this, but they are, uh, they are, uh, very, uh, they have very good understanding of the fact that, uh, US businesses, uh, and especially, uh, uh, businesses linked to digital technologies, they have always cooperated with, uh, US administration. 8:51 And actually, for those who have studied a little bit of how digital technologies and, uh, uh, innovation, the policies of innovation of the US over the past 70 years is very much, uh, very much linked to the, uh, large industrial policy, which is, uh, hidden to some extent because most people think that in the US innovation happens because of, uh, private sector. 9:20 But in fact, the private sector is, uh, very well connected with the government that puts billions of 9:28 f- fundings in fundamental research, uh, like in agencies like the NASA or, or ARPA or DARPA, depending on how you call it. 9:38 They have been pouring billions in fundamental research since the, the, the '70s, sorry, the '50s when they were created. Uh, so for the past 70 years, they have been pouring billions in fundamental research. 9:50 And what we have in our smartphones, the GPS, the crystal liquid screen, the, uh, I- the, the, the, the, uh, uh, lithium ion batteries, uh, or the very same internet, they are the result of billions spent by the US administration to, uh, foster research that the private sector would not necessarily pay for, and then, uh, creating a very good connection with the private sector to, to, to make a profit out of this research and, uh, to, to use it also to lever- to, to create some sort of global dominance in, in, uh, 10:27 terms of, uh, technology, right? 10:30 Uh, this is, uh, something again, that, uh, people may think is a Chinese strategy to ha- to invest heavily in, in, uh, industrial policy and then to have public contracts to scale up, uh, national, uh, champions, but it's something that the US are, is, is doing since the, the '50s literally. 10:51 And the Chinese are simply reproducing something that worked very well in the US that creates an enormous, uh, a competitive advantage for the country, uh, that hosts these very large companies that then supply services and products that become quite essential for others. 11:11 So you create an enormous dependency if you want, and enormous po- uh, situation of advantage, uh, because, uh, it's, uh... 11:19 That is something actually a point that we explore in, in our book on digital sovereignty in the BRICS, uh, is not only on the one hand how Brazil w- or India were very successful with their digital public infrastructure for payments. 11:33 Brazil has copied its Pix from India, from the UPI, uh, but also something that, uh, the, the reasons for which some of the countries like Brazil are still vulnerable. 11:42 And, uh, actually, I think, I'm pretty sure that someone in Washington has read our book that was published six months ago because we, we speak about the GPS, uh, the fact that because i- a- amongst the sanction that [laughs] were put in on the table, the Trump administration wanted to, uh, to switch off [laughs] uh, uh, threatened to switch off GPS. 12:01 And actually, it's interesting because we, we include in the book the example of the GPS. 12:05 Uh, the, uh, Brazil is one of those countries that has not, uh, uh, created its own GPS or has, if you look at Russia or China or India, uh, or the European Union, they have created their own G- GPS system because they know that this is su- such a critical infrastructure that totally depending on another country for it, well, this is not something I would suggest to a friend as a wise investment. 12:28 [Instrumental music] To hear the full episode, subscribe to Explaining Brazil on Apple Podcasts. It costs less than $2 a month. 12:37 Or better yet, support us directly by subscribing to The Brazilian Report, the newsroom behind the show. 12:45 You will find the audio for free on our website, along with daily newsletters delivering original reporting and sharp analysis on Brazil and Latin America. Head over to brazilian.report. See you next time. 13:01 [Instrumental music]