Transcript 0:01 And nós não passamos a mão na cabeça de ninguém. Eu sou favorável à tortura, tu sabe disso. Eu sei o que é passar fome. Imagine that Lula, hã, could send me to puta que pariu. 0:12 On October 7, around 147 million Brazilians are expected to head to the polling stations, show their ID, and then get into a booth to choose our leaders for the next four years. 0:25 We will elect a new president, 27 new governors, 513 congressmen, and over 1,000 state lawmakers. But how exactly will that process happen? 0:37 That's a recurring question from subscribers of The Brazilian Report, and that's the theme of this week's Explaining Brazil podcast. 0:47 [upbeat music] Once again, I'm joined by Diogo Rodrigues, staff writer at The Brazilian Report. Hello, Diogo. Thanks for being here today. Hello, nice being here again. 1:01 First of all, Diogo, we can't say that Brazilians will actually cast their ballot. Actually, that's not technically what we do? 1:09 Yeah, I mean, Brazil has had a s- electronic voting system since the 2000s, uh, since exactly the year 2000. That's when the, all the elections started to be electronic. 1:21 Uh, they had some tests in 1998, but everything just went electronic in the 2000s, and that's how we vote. 1:27 I know that in some places like the US they have mixed, uh, system with some, uh, places being electronic, others, whatever, uh, uh, paper ballot. But here everything is just the same. 1:37 The same, uh, voting machine, that's what we call it, and everything works about the same. And Brazilians, they don't pick a candidate by their names, they pick a number. So each party has their number. 1:50 And for instance, for president and governor, it's a two-digit number. So for instance, uh, the Workers' Party's number is 13, so people who have voted for Lula in the past, they type 13 and then confirm. 2:07 For the Social Democrats it's 45, so it's something that every election is the same number for the same parties. For senators, three d- digits. For congressmen, four digits. 2:19 And for state congress, five digits, which creates some confusions, right? Because not all voters know the, the, the voting order. 2:29 It's a bit confusing because you have to start with a really long number, and, uh, then you have to go to the short ones. 2:36 And, uh, some people still have trouble with that, but the truth is, is that the electronic voting system, it had, uh, an interesting effect in blank and null votes. 2:46 The number dropped after the first election that we had, uh, the electronic vote all around, because now it was, it was just easier to, to, to know what to do. 2:56 And people would have a hard time writing, and that's something that's very important in, in a country that, uh, at least until recently, not everyone was, uh... knew how to read or write. 3:07 And the numbers were, you know, just easier for people to, m- to, you know, to vote and they, they made the process easier. Exactly. 3:15 And also because for instance, uh, when we had paper ballots, you had to write down the name of your congressman, and, uh, that's actually the reason why, uh, Lula has inserted the nickname Lula into his legal name, because he ran for Congress back in the '80s, and if people were voting for Lula, it would be a spoiled ballot because, uh, his name is Luiz Inácio da Silva, so he legally changed his name. 3:42 Uh, now we don't have that problem. When you type down the number, you get the photo of the candidate, his name, his party, so it's much simpler. 3:51 Like you said, the rate of spoiled ballots dropped by half from, uh, the 2002 election to, uh, from the 1998 election to, until 2006, for instance. 4:05 We're, we're talking about all the good, uh, the upsides of electronic ballot, but they are far from a consensus, right? 4:12 Because parts of the Brazilian political establishment are bashing electronic voting, saying that the system is easily rigged. Uh, what can you say about that? 4:22 Well, um, that's a recent thing I guess, that, that, that, that it... 4:26 I mean, um, every system has its flaws, but recently in the last, uh, I guess four years, five years, more people have become vocal about, you know, the problems that the electronic system might have, and they're challenging the electronic system and asking for more, more transparency and, uh, and, and, and pointing out problems. 4:45 There's a professor here at the University of Campinas. 4:49 He's not against the, the, the electronic system, but he's always pointing out problems, and he was part inclu- uh, he was part of a, uh, a hacking, uh, marathon that the, the Superior Electoral Court promoted last year, and his team was able to find some, you know, some breaches in the system. 5:06 I mean, it certainly doesn't, is not perfect, and there are people who, who want to, besides the electronic vote, they want to have a printed vote, like, as, as, as, like, a stub, uh, from, when you get from the movies- [laughs]... 5:20 in order to avoid frauds, in order to avoid manipulations. And, uh, that's- They should have, like, separate recounts and then, uh- Exactly. 5:28 In the case you need it, y- yeah, I mean, there's, there's suspicion of a fraud or anything like that, you could recount the votes. But that's also a problem. I mean, we can talk about that if you want, but- Yeah... 5:38 that, that's one of the things, uh, that's one of the discussions that we've been having about the electronic vote, is that is it safe or isn't it not safe? Exactly. And the thing is, uh, because the most vocal, um- 5:51 Anti-electronic voting system right now is Jair Bolsonaro, the far-right presidential candidate. And he said time and time again that no matter what the results are, it's going to ha- to be surrounded by suspicion. 6:05 But there has not been an actual case where evidence was found that there was fraud. Exactly. Uh, I know the right wing tried to, to, to say that in 2014 when Dilma Rousseff got elected by a very narrow margin. Mm-hmm. 6:21 But nothing went further because there was, uh, absolutely no evidence. And it's not like you couldn't defraud, uh, a paper ballot system, right? Exactly. 6:30 That's one of the arguments of people who, who question this, uh, this view that the electronic system is easily rigged. I mean, one... 6:40 The, the thing about the, the electoral court of Brazil is that it has, it has been very transparent, and whatever problems were found, they try to address it. 6:48 And, you know, every electronic system, any electronic system is subject to be, you know, the, to be invaded or whatever, whatever. N- nothing is 100% safe. 6:59 So, uh, we can say that those criticisms sound a little bit like, uh, conspiracy theories more than, you know, actual problems, but, you know, they're something that we have to watch for. Yeah, exactly. 7:12 And I think because a, a recent survey was published showing how much Brazilians are not trusting their institutions, and the electoral system got just 33%. 7:26 And my opinion, it's not that people think that the system is rigged, it's that in Brazil we usually say that you may vote for one person for Congress and elect another one, and that's pretty confusing, especially for foreigners who are observing the election. 7:42 Can you explain what people mean when they say that? The thing is our proportional system is, uh, it has a, a way of working that can leave out very well voted candidates because you have to... 7:55 There's a threshold of votes that each party has to get in order to have representative. 8:01 And even if someone individually gets, I don't know, many, many votes, hundreds and thousands of votes, but his party doesn't make it to that threshold, he not, he's not gonna get elected. So that's, that might be... 8:13 That's very confusing for the regular citizens because they don't un- understand how the system works. 8:19 But that's one of the things that we have here in the proportional system that confuses people, and that's what you're talking about. Yeah. 8:25 For instance, just as a comparison, so in the US and in the UK, the system is first past the post. So, uh, states are divided into districts. It's a, a win sta- winner takes it all. 8:39 Uh, so if you get 10% of the votes and the second place gets nine, you get elected. In France is a mixed system. You... 8:49 Voters, um, sta- regions are divided into districts, but that's a majoritary election in two, uh, rounds. So it's more like the way we elect presidents here in Brazil. In Brazil is a, it's a different system. 9:06 It's a proportional system. So in each state, if your party gets 10% of the votes, it gets 10% of the seats. So, uh, for instance, let's say in São Paulo we have one million voters, and then you have 100 seats. 9:24 To elect, uh, one congressman, you would have to have at least 1,000 seats. Am I, am I correct with the numbers? [laughs] Okay. So let, let's think in numbers, like in, in round numbers. 9:38 Suppose that you have, um, one million, uh, valid votes in one at, in one given state, whatever state it is, and you have 10 vacant seats to be filled for, you know, that, for the, the House of Representatives. 9:53 And the threshold that w- that I was talking about will be of one hou- 100,000 votes. That means the outcome of the number of valid votes divided by the number of seats to be filled. 10:06 It means that a party or a coalition will have the right to occupy that seat, one seat at Congress at every 100,000 votes that it gets. 10:16 So if our party at The Brazilian Report gets 200,000 votes, the two best voted within our parties will get those seats? Exactly. 10:27 We have two spots, and since the system, it's called an open list, I mean, the list, the, the, the people who get in are the people who, within that party or coalition, the people who get more votes. 10:39 So, you know, we'll have the two best, uh, uh, representatives, uh, best voted representatives, they will be elected to Congress. 10:47 There is a caveat though, because, well, maybe this will be the last time that we have this system as it is, but, uh, parties are able now to have legislative coalitions, which means a group of parties acts as a super party. 11:03 So you can vote for a candidate from party A and then help elect a candidate for party B, which is almost, what, one third of the House every four years gets elected this way, right? Something like this, yes. 11:20 And it's very upsetting because you, you, you... 11:23 People are not very conscious of what they're doing when they're vote, casting a vote for one party or one specific candidate because it's not always very clear what these coalitions are and who's in it. 11:35 Yeah, and that gives us a very fragmented Congress. We have now 31 parties represented in Congress, and the Workers' Party who- which has the biggest amount of seats, has 60, which is less than 12% of the House. 11:51 So impossible to govern without a coalition. I think Brazil is the Western country with the highest amount of parties represented in Parliament. Yes. 12:04 And, and another problem is that there's a, a very strong migration within those parties whenever the election is over. 12:11 So, you know, uh, representatives from a party that got the majority or whatever, got a spot in, in Congress will go to another party because, you know, it's more interesting for him or because the party offers more, you know, more advantages, and then it, it wants to get a stronger coalition within Congress. 12:29 So that gets deformed as the, as the, the years go on, as the years, uh, th- as the years pass by. And like you said, after the election, it's a game that parties try to lure, uh, congressmen into migrating to them. 12:42 Because the thing is, once the election comes, then free t- television and radio airtime and public funding for campaigns will be split among parties according to their representation in the House, right? 12:58 So for instance, Geraldo Alckmin, the center-right candidate, he has what one of his allies called the biggest coalition in the Western Hemisphere. 13:11 Um, he has 44% of TV and radio airtime, 44% of the public electoral front created by Congress to fund campaigns. Yes. And, uh, that's... The... 13:27 Another problem is that it's very easy to create a party in Brazil. There's a strong incentive to create a party because you wanna be part of that game. 13:34 Because if you manage to get into a coalition with, like, the, the PSDB or the, the PP or the, the, the centrão parties, the big center parties, you can get in that, you know, the division of, of money, and even though you're a small party and you get a lot of money because you were elected with a strong coalition. 13:52 Until now, you didn't have to do much to have access to that money and that free TV and radio airtime because even if you had never, uh, elected one single representative in the party's whole existence, you would be entitled to have the minimum share of TV, uh, and radio airtime and of the electoral fund. 14:14 Starting 2020, parties that don't have this year at least 1.5% of the votes in at least nine states and, uh, 1% of the votes in every single state will not meet the minimum requirement to get access to public funds and to free TV and radio airtime, which 14:38 will probably reduce the number of parties we have right now. That's one of the attempts, uh, to make the system less fragmented, but we don't know if that's going to work. 14:48 And some criticisms that people made about this and specialists made is that, uh, smaller parties will not have the chance to thrive because they'll have to... I mean, that, that's a very bre- big threshold. 15:01 It seems like it's small, but it's a quite, quite a big threshold. 15:04 I mean, at the same time that it will prevent, you know, insignificant parties from having access to the, the electoral funds, but it will also prevent new parties that are truly representative from having that same access. 15:17 So that's one of the criticisms that can be made. Exactly. 15:20 Because, uh, a lot of political scientists have always asked for this electoral threshold because it's not a healthy political system w- when you have over 30 parties in Congress. But it's funny because 15:35 Congress passed this new legislation when the country asks for renewal. 15:42 And what they do is to lock down the system and to say, "Okay, the big parties, the old-timers will have all the money, all the free TV and airtime, uh, and radio airtime, and then the new ones get the crumbles." 15:56 Uh, in a country where TV remains a very important media, that's very crippling for, let's say, Guilherme Boulos, with whom we talked to, uh, prior today, with Marina Silva, the environmentalist candidate. 16:12 She will have, what, 12 seconds every day to say her message. I mean, do... What do you have time to say in 12 seconds? Go to my website? Not much. 16:22 [laughs] Uh, Jair Bolsonaro, the far-right candidate, will not have much time. So you will have the Workers' Party, whoever the candidate is, and you will have Geraldo Alckmin being able to almost monopolize TV... 16:38 uh, political ads on TV and radio. Yeah. In practice, this, what this is doing and is going to do is to perpetuate the system that is already in place. It doesn't bring... 16:49 It doesn't allow any change to, to come from parties. So that's a big problem because, I mean, you... we were talking about how the Braz- how Brazilians are not, do not trust in the, in, in elections and in parties. 17:04 So I think that's going to be, to do more damage than good to the political parties and to the political system. 17:10 And Diogo, we are talking about, uh, TV, political ads on TV and radio, and Brazil has a, a very specific campaign timeframe, right? It's not like in the US when they start with the primaries, and then they... 17:24 It seems like they're always on campaign bec- especially because they have the midterms, uh, two years after the, the, the presidential election. So Americans seems always to be on campaign. 17:36 In Brazil, that's not the case at all, right? Exactly. I mean, you can campaign, uh, in a general way for 52 days, from August 16 to October the 6th this year. 17:48 And, uh, the TV and radio campaigns, which use the public airwaves and the, you know, all the channels, the public channels, not the, the cable channels, can go for 35 days from August 30- 31st to October 4th. 18:03 So there's a very narrow window and a very, uh, specific window. Yeah. E- even debates are heavily regulated. 18:09 If, if you have a Uh, t- a public television network or a radio station, which like you said, it's public concessions, uh, you have to invite every single candidate, uh, whose party has at least five, uh, representatives. 18:27 S- doesn't matter how competitive this candidate is. And now with social media, a lot of websites and a lot of media outlets are trying to do, uh, 18:38 on YouTube, uh, this kind of debate with four, five candidates to try to make the debate more qualified. 18:46 Because last week we saw the first presidential debate and, uh, it didn't seem like any of the candidates had much airtime to spread their message and to really make a statement about any of the issues. Yeah, exactly. 18:59 And these laws were created, well, w- it was an attempt to, uh, to diminish the influence of economical power, economic power on the campaign. 19:09 But what it's doing now, it's limiting what can be said and how, how long you can debate and, uh, and it's not up to date with what we have here because social media, you can do whatever you want on, also on YouTube, I mean, in terms of debating and in terms of, of who you can bring to, to debate. 19:28 It's a very outdated system. 19:29 I, I think it needs some improvement because, I mean, what it does, it just, it just makes it boring and, and, and, and it, and the public doesn't get anything from it because it's so, uh, structured, so limited. Yeah. 19:43 Um, once again, I don't think we're gonna have much renewal. I think re-election rates in Congress are gonna be as high as ever, in the, especially in the moment where Brazilians want renewal at all costs. 19:55 So I don't think that, uh, this election will be any good to make the political environment in Brazil much more peaceful than it is right now. Yes. 20:04 I mean, people have been talking about change since 2013, but little has been done in order for that to actually happen. The s- the political system is, is, is frozen. The electoral system is frozen, so there's not... 20:18 You cannot expect any change from what is the way it always was. Well, on this note, not a very positive one, but, uh, we're out of time. So thanks, Diogo. 20:29 Next week we'll be here to talk a bit more about the election, the challenges of the new president, and, uh, what are the main issues of this campaign. If you enjoyed this podcast, please take a look at our website. 20:42 It's brazilian.report. Every day we have new content on Brazilian politics, economics, and society. 20:48 We also have exclusive newsletter services if you want to be briefed on what's going on in Brazil before starting your day. Subscribe now to our free trial and enjoy all of our content for 14 days. It's really for free. 21:00 You don't have to put any credit card information. You can also follow us on Facebook and Twitter. Our handle is @brazilianreport. That's all for now. See you next week. [outro jingle]