Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hello, my name is Gustavo Ribeiro. I'm the editor-in-chief of The Brazilian Report. 0:14 Today, September the 7th, marks Brazil's independence bicentennial, but the date has been hijacked by President Jair Bolsonaro, who held celebrations of independence that were really political rallies in Brasilia, São Paulo, and Rio de Janeiro. 0:31 And these were events with sizable attendance, and they have been seen as a sort of last-ditch attempt by the president to pull off an upset in the presidential elections, which happen on the 2nd of October. 0:44 Let's remember that all polls show Bolsonaro way behind former President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, who tries to win back the presidency after serving for two terms between 2003 and 2010. 0:59 In Brazil, we have a two-round election system. There are many candidates, and if no one gets over 50% of the votes, then the two best-positioned candidates could go to a, go to a runoff. 1:12 And polls suggest that Lula could maybe pull off a first-round landslide victory if the elections were today, which of course [laughs] they are not. 1:22 And Bolsonaro is putting his faith that today's shows of, show of strength will help him stage that upset that he needs. And to discuss what happened today, I welcome political scientist Beatriz Hey. 1:35 Beatriz holds a PhD in political science. 1:39 She's an SNF Agora Visiting Fellow at Johns Hopkins University, a senior researcher at the Center for Studies on the Brazilian Congress at the State University of Rio de Janeiro, and a fellow at the Pop Vox Foundation. 1:54 Beatriz, thanks for joining us again. You were with us exactly a year ago. Yes, I was. [laughs] And here we are, discussing- [laughs]... almost the same things. Um- Yeah, but with a little twist, right? 2:08 Because many were bracing for a coup or for, uh, calls, uh, for supporters to deny, uh, the, the credibility of the electoral system, but instead we got political rallies paid for by the public dime. 2:25 And still, Bolsonaro did manage to draw throngs of supporters. What do you make of today's events? I think it was a, just a big, uh, campaign event, um, in several cities. 2:39 Uh, people were, a lot of people were scared that he would attempt a coup based on what happened last year. If you remember, we were discussing Bolsonaro's, uh, words against, uh, Justice Alexandre de Moraes. 2:50 Um, he specifically targeted him. In, in the aftermath of [laughs] September 7th, we had former President Michel Temer trying to calm down the mood in Brasilia and, and, and kind of make the branches talk to each other. 3:05 That's not what happened today. Um, based on last year, he was moderate. That's not to say he was moderate, but based on last year, he was moderate. 3:15 Um, so it just turned, turned to be a, just a big, uh, political campaign event, uh, with... He was able to mobilize a lot of people. Uh, I was surprised. But, uh, he only spoke to his bases of support. 3:29 He didn't say anything surprising or anything different than what he has been saying [laughs] during his campaign. Uh, and he, again, he's look- It, it, that, that... It blows my mind. 3:41 He wants to, uh, get support from women. He wants to target the female voter, and then he goes and says things that [laughs] do the opposite of that. That have the opposite effect. So he did that again. 3:54 He did that in the debate, and he did that today again. 3:57 Um, you know- And just for a piece of context for people who did not follow the events, uh, as closely as we have, Bolsonaro told supporters, uh, as one of his arguments why people should vote for him, to compare First Lady Michelle Bolsonaro to the first ladies of previous presidents. 4:14 He told men that they should, uh, find themselves a princess to marry with and be happy with. And then he also said that he, he said he's "" 4:26 which literally translates as the president saying that he doesn't have erectile dysfunction, which is not necessarily what you would expect to hear in an Independence Day [laughs] celebration, especially for the bicentennial of the Brazilian independence. 4:39 Well, we never heard anything about Dom Pedro's heart. I was expecting something about it. It was just such an event before, and nothing happened. 4:48 Instead, he was making machista comments about Lula's wife and, and his sexual performance. 4:56 Uh- Yeah, like you said, the, the government brought in the heart of, uh, Dom Pedro I, who is, uh, he was a Portuguese prince who declared Brazil's independence, was Brazil's first emperor. 5:10 Then he abdicated the throne to become a king of Portugal. That's why his heart was in Portugal. But he was still talking about body parts. [laughs] His body parts- [laughs]... not Dom Pedro's. 5:22 [laughs] Yeah, uh, I, uh, there was nothing in today's events about independence, the bicent- Nothing about that, right? 5:30 It was about his campaign and, um, his body and his preferences for women, and, um, that was all paid with the public dime, with, with the taxpayer money. Um, 5:43 it, it, my question is, will the Electoral Court do something? Uh, this was- Yes... out there- And, and this is interesting. 5:50 And this is interesting because, uh, federal prosecutors yesterday, they sent letters to the Ministry of Defense and to the president's communications office to say, "This must by no means be a political rally. 6:05 This is a state event, and should stay as such. Uh, we are opening a civil inquiry on this." So much for that. 6:12 [laughs]The one thing that surprised me though was that he did not try to discredit the electoral, um, machines, the electronic machines. I- at least not in the, the, the speech in Brasilia. 6:24 I don't know if he tried that in Rio. Um, maybe that is not giving traction for him in the campaign. Maybe that's not mobilizing his bases of support anymore. Um, I don't know. 6:35 I think that evaluation is wrong at the moment I say it. Um, or m- maybe he just needed something more extreme or, or more bizarre, uh, [laughs] to mobilize his base. 'Cause I think that's... 6:47 At the end of the day, that's what he did. He, he had his supporters out there. He spoke to them. I think it's unlikely that he gained any votes from today, 'cause he didn't move to the center. 6:58 He stayed [laughs] right where he is, uh, and where he has been. So, so you don't think he... Because the, the, the crowds were massive in, especially in São Paulo and Rio. 7:10 In Brasília, not so much, especially compared to last year, and we're gonna talk about that in more detail because we will have Sid Silva, who is one of our reporters who attended, who was at the event to cover it. 7:23 Uh, but even with those throngs of supporters, of voters, you don't think he has, um... He exits September the 7th at the same political stature he had, uh, electorally-wise? 7:39 I mean, he has 30, 32% of the votes in the polls. Um, I think those were the people who were out there. Um, we have been waiting to see if Alcides Brasil was going to make a difference. It didn't matter that much. 7:55 Um, he's trying to... 7:57 Again, he's trying to change his electoral situation with the female population, but he's not able to because he cannot contain his misogynistic behavior, uh, and he did that again today, uh, so I don't think he's gonna gain any points with women. 8:11 Um, I, I don't know. I, I, I might be wrong, and again, you and I were having this conversation this morning that we're just living in a bizarre world, uh, and, uh, a Vecna [laughs] world. 8:22 Uh, that the parameters are all upside down. Uh, and I'm, I'm just scared of, like, saying 100% that's what's gonna happen, uh, especially after the election in 2018. 8:34 But I do think that he spoke only what the people who vote for him want to hear. Um, he didn't say anything different than what he [laughs] has been saying. 8:43 And based on that, what he has been saying has, uh, gotten him 32, 32, 33% of the, of the vote intention, right? So I don't think he's... It shouldn't matter based on the parameters that we have. 8:58 And when we compare to last year's events, because, uh... So I'm- they- I'm in Brasília right now. Uh, uh, I s- I live in São Paulo, but I'm in Brasília. I came to Brasília last year. 9:09 And, um, comparing the atmosphere of the city now and a year ago, it was very different. Uh, there was a sort of tension, uh, last year that I did not necessarily felt this year. 9:21 Um, and, uh, the reactions also seem to have changed a lot. A lot of people were, um, uh, uh, worried that Bolsonaro was, to, to use that, uh, um, uh, analogy everyone likes to use, 9:38 uh, people thought that Bolsonaro was on the [laughs] banks of the Rubicon, and that he could maybe try to cross it. And at no point I felt that the political system was, um, reacting to the same sort of urgency. 9:53 Uh, is it because what happened this year is less, uh, dramatic or because we're just getting too jaded by the fact that Bolsonaro is always trying to push, uh, Brazilian democracy to its limits almost on a daily basis? 10:08 I also think it's because he knows that he has no support for a coup attempt, and he knows that because the big economic elite spoke in favor of democracy recently. 10:20 Uh, I think, uh, based on everything that we know from political science, that should make difference in his calculation. Um, you need the people with money and people with guns. 10:29 Um, people with money have said that, "We, uh, we don't want that. Uh, th- we're, we're not gonna commit to anything." The people with the guns, we still don't know, right? 10:38 And that's a conversation that we keep have- having year after year. Um, but given that the people with the money won't support him, uh, I think he, he felt less compelled to do something crazy. 10:52 And there is also the fact that, uh, the Supreme Court has been, um, circumventing his, uh, supporters', uh, ability to do something crazy, as your own reporting shows, correct? 11:07 Yes, yes, and, uh, we're gonna talk ab- about that in more detail because we're gonna have Sid here with us, and, uh, he was there- Okay... he can, uh- Yeah, so I'm not, I'm not- But, uh, no-... 11:16 I'm not gonna use No- Sorry. [laughs] No problem. But, uh, to, to talk about what you just said, you, you need people with money and people with guns, and people with guns remains a sort of question mark right now. Um, 11:30 and that's also because, uh, they intend to leave their position as a, uh, uh, to leave people on edge, uh, about where they would go if Bolsonaro decides a pow- uh, for a power grab. 11:44 Now, I've talked to, uh, political observers and, uh, there are two lines here to, to interpret this. 11:51 Uh, some think that, uh, they would be, uh, willing to follow Bolsonaro in this kind of putschist adventure if it comes to it, and others say that, uh, it's just a ruse in order to, uh, put the political establishment, uh, on the edge of their seats and to, uh, guarantee themselves a position where nobody will, uh, dare to cut down their benefits, their privileges. 12:19 Because Brasil- the Brazilian military enjoys many perks that, uh, no other kinds of workers do. They have hefty salaries. Their pension system is unparalleled. Their, their healthcare system is also unparalleled. 12:32 Um, wh- where do you put yourself? You- do you think they would be willing to cross the Rubicon or do you think they just want everybody guessing-... 12:42 what they would do because that serves their interests more, even more than any sort of coup. 12:49 So when we think about 64, um, it- so there has to be some level of coordination for these things to align and for a coup to actually happen, right? 12:59 I want to call the attention to one fact today that I think was very important. The Speaker of the House and of the Senate did not participate, uh, in any of the demonstrations, right? They were not there. 13:10 Arthur Lira was not there. Um, he was there the last time Bolsonaro was out there during his- launching his presidential bid, um, right? He was there. He wore a T-shirt saying Bolsonaro. 13:24 Um, so I think that sen- that sends a signal to other political actors, which [laughs] in Brazil includes the military, um, that there is no support for any sort of, uh, anti-democratic attempt from Congress and from the Supreme Court. 13:41 That is pretty clear. So I think all of that is gonna be taken into account in everybody's calculations as things unfold. 13:48 Uh, to me, it was, uh, it was very important, uh, to- just to pay attention to the fact that Lira did not show up, 'cause this is somebody who was- has been aligned with Bolsonaro, [laughs] who has been benefiting from Bolsonaro being, being president. 14:01 And I think he's smart enough to know that the ship has sailed. Like, Bolsonaro has been polling consistently at the 30s, uh, at, at this level, and it doesn't look like it's gonna change. Right. 14:15 Uh, yeah, sometimes you- you send a lot of signals by the things you do, by the things you say, also [laughs] by the things you don't do, uh, so Lira not showing up. And, uh, there are a lot of reports that say, um, 14:28 that, uh, candidates in Lira's home state of Alagoas, uh, Lira himself are hiding their association with Bolsonaro at the national s- level because Lula, uh, polls better in Alagoas and in the rest of the Brazil's northeastern region. 14:44 Uh, so associating oneself with Bolsonaro may not be in their best interests, [laughs] right? I, I mean, r- remember, we're talking about a group of... 14:52 Like, Lira is part of a group of political parties that have no allegiance. They go with who's winning. Um, Bolsonaro doesn't... It doesn't look like he's winning, right? 15:02 A few years ago, they were with the Workers' Party, the same party- Yeah, yeah, exactly... that they claim to be feuding with. [laughs] My point exactly. 15:08 [laughs] And just, uh, to, um, address our, uh, uh, people who are watching us, our viewers, uh, we at The Brazilian Report are a subscription-based, uh, media outlet. 15:22 So if you like our content, if you like our, our videos, our podcasts, and our stories, please subscribe to The Brazilian Report. Um, the, this is the journalistic engine of everything we do. 15:35 We have exclusive newsletters and exclusive reporting every day, and, uh, we have, uh, uh, plans that range from just $3.90, uh, and, uh, you can tweak your subscription plan the way you need. 15:52 Now, um, Beatriz, you were talking about the fact that, uh, there was some coordination about the kind of messaging that we are going to display in, uh, today's rallies, especially in Brasilia. 16:07 And to discuss further that, I would like to call Cedê Silva. He's our Brasilia correspondent, and he and Amanda Auge were there this morning. Um, Cedê, uh, thanks for joining us. So tell us a little bit what you saw. 16:22 I remember we were talking earlier that, uh, you, uh, spotted three very key differences between today's events and last year's events. Can you tell us a little bit about these differences that you spotted? 16:38 Yeah, sure, Gustavo. Uh, thank you for having me. Uh, good evening to you and to Beatriz Hay, and happy bicentennial, everybody. 16:45 [laughs] Uh, me and Amanda Auge worked on a story that our subscribers can read that is now published on The Brazilian Report. 16:54 Uh, it talks about, uh, the differences between, uh, this year's Independence Day pro-Bolsonaro rallies and last year. And also, uh, Amanda Auge has some background on why some of these differences, uh, happened. 17:10 What I saw, uh, today in Brasilia, and I also went to the same place, uh, last year on the, on the other September 7 demonstrations, and I could see some three key differences as you said. 17:23 Uh, the first one is that there was a much smaller crowd. 17:29 There was still- there were still, uh, throngs of supporters, several thousand pro-Bolsonaro, uh, uh, supporters, but, uh, the, the attendance was, uh, much lower than last year. 17:41 And one of the signs that we, we know about this is comparing photos, uh, from this year and last year. 17:48 For instance, the presidential palace has an official Flickr account with official photographs for the president's agenda. 17:56 Uh, if you look at the album for last year, there are a lot of photos of the crowd and of the president addressing the crowd. But this year, they only published one photo of the crowd. 18:08 So this is, uh, an indicator that the crowd was not as large as, uh, President Bolsonaro wanted and definitely not as large as last year. 18:17 The second difference is there are many less signs this time around- Uh, with pro-coup messages, such as calling for the deposition of the Supreme Court justices or calling on Bolsonaro to use the armed forces, uh, to have an intervention in government. 18:36 These messages, still exist. They are still there, but they are on a smaller quantity than last year. Among other brought to this story the explanation why. The, this, this, this is no accident. 18:48 There was coordination back on social media, back on WhatsApp and Telegram for these pro-Bolsonaro groups, for a more, uh, unified message, and for a message that is not as, uh, strikingly pro-coup as it was last year. 19:05 They have not- They changed with dog whistles, right? [laughs] Pre- precisely. [laughs] They have not, they have not became angels, uh, no, for, for last year to, to today. It was not a, a change of heart. 19:17 It's not a change of character. It's just ch- a change in how to convey these messages. 19:22 So there are still messages with, uh, so-called dog whistles, which is a political jargon for, of messages that most people will understand, uh, uh, one thing, but the few people in the in-group, inside the group, are going to understand what's the real content of that message. 19:41 And so their message that, "Uh, we want to respect democracy as long as the vote is audible and there is a public counting of votes," which means they do not trust Brazil's voting system. 19:54 They will not accept, uh, Lula winning the election. But that message is, uh, coded, uh, for, for pro-Bolsonaro, uh, supporters. 20:06 And, and the third main difference is since this is an el- electoral year, uh, there were a lot of messages and a lot of electoral workers campaigning for candidates. 20:17 So for instance, I was handed a pro-Bolsonaro leaflet. Uh, it contains a QR code, and it features the first lady on the other side. 20:26 We- Professor Hay was talking about how Bolsonaro supposedly tries to pander to female voters, but he can't because of his nature. Uh, so there you got one, one of these, uh, leaflets. 20:39 Cedê, did you- And there are for senators and congressmen too... did, Cedê, did you scan the QR code? What did it say? I did not- [laughs] I did not yet scan the QR code, but- I was going to ask my question. 20:50 Could we do it- I did not-... right now to see where it takes us? I'm good. [laughs] Well, it's, it's probably a pro-Bolsonaro campaign because, uh, this, this is, uh, following the rules. Uh, it contains who paid for. 21:03 Yeah. So this is a Liberal Party official, uh, official leaflet. So let's scan the QR code right now, and our Brazilian report readers are going to see live- [laughs]... where this takes us. Uh, it's- I want- Yeah... 21:18 I just want to point out that this is a legacy from the pandemic. We didn't have QR codes before the pandemic, did we? This is the first time I'm- And, yeah, not, not as often. And what, uh- Yeah... 21:27 I, I really dislike having them on, um, on menus and menus. Oh, and, and it, it's actually who paid for this is a candidate for assembly. So it takes you this, it takes you to this webpage. 21:42 Uh, he's, he's running for the Brasília State Assembly. Even though Eduardo Torres is not on this banner- [laughs]... 21:49 uh, if you go to the QR code, you're going to be taken to, uh, an, an assembly, an assembly candidate, a candidate for a state assembly. 21:57 So, a- and Cedê, what you're, what you're describing is kind of striking because we are seeing an event paid for by the government, uh, that is being used for candidates to pamphlet- Absolutely... 22:09 uh, and the president to, um, deliver a, 100% electoral, uh, speech with absolutely no reference whatsoever to the bicentennial. 22:20 Uh- Yeah, I th- If the electoral courts want, they have pretty much everything they need to strike down the Bolsonaro candidacy because that is, uh, it seems, at least, uh, at first glance, a sort of textbook example of what we call in Brazilian electoral law abuse of economic power, doesn't it? 22:41 Yes. Uh, they will not do that, but they should do that. [laughs] And in fact, they have just accepted officially Bolsonaro's candidacy. Uh, but they're, that's, uh, they've, they've got all the elements. 22:52 Uh, I think that's the most important message that, that, uh, for t- for t- tonight, at least in my understanding, is that Bolsonaro, uh, who has already stole a lot of things, literally. 23:02 Uh, the first family has actually stole a dog last year. They literally stole a dog that belonged to someone else. It was not a stray dog. 23:11 They stole a dog and, and left the dog in the official residence until the owner found out about it and took the dog back. 23:17 Uh, recently, last month, in, in Brazil, so many outrageous things- Is that an impeachable offense? [laughs] Yeah, I, yeah, of- it's a common crime. It's a common crime. [laughs] You, you can impeach for a common crime. 23:27 You stole a dog. And they re- they returned the dog. And last month, uh, President Bolsonaro, uh, in, in bright sunlight, close to the, his official residence, he tried to steal somebody's cell phone. 23:40 He actually tried to steal a phone in front of everybody. And he, and so President Bolsonaro steals a lot of things. And he stole something from us as Brazilian, uh, as Brazilians. He stole our bicentennial. 23:53 Uh, this is a time when Brazil should be celebrating and coming to a better understanding of our history, of our culture, of the reasons why we're such a big country compared to our South American neighbors, of the reason that why we speak a language that our neighbors do not, of, uh, the reasons that, uh, Brazil came to be, uh, the, uh, a nation with, uh, with, with the scourge of slavery, uh, and with the scourge of, of social inequality and of s- so, so many other things and so many other decisions, uh, by Dom Pedro, by the leaders at the time. 24:29 Uh, José Bonifácio, which was an important Brazilian leader, uh, he had, uh, a project to outlaw slavery at the time of independence. 24:39 The decision was made not to outlaw slavery at the time, but we, we could, we could be something else, and we're not having that conversation. We're not having- No way... 24:48 having that conversation about the bicentennial that was stolen from us. 24:51 Um, and, and we are discussing, uh, our bicentennial declaration of independence is at the founding of our nation as just another electoral rally, uh, by a guy who, who, who claims that, uh, he can always get an erection. 25:06 [laughs] Yeah. And, uh, which, uh... By the way, we at The Brazilian Report have had that conversation. We have launched this week a special four-part series. 25:17 You can, uh, listen on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. Now, Sidlay, you just described what you saw in Brasilia. I want to invite into our conversation Constance Malre. 25:28 Uh, she's in Rio, so she is the person who saw Bolsonaro up close the latest. Constance, thanks very much for joining us from Rio. Uh, you, you were just at Copacabana moments ago. 25:42 So can you tell us a little bit, uh, what you saw? What was the mood, the atmosphere there, and what did you take, uh, from the event? Thanks, Gustavo. It's good to be here. 25:54 I'm actually still in Copacabana because I decided it was too risky to try and get home in time, so I hope the noise behind me isn't, isn't too bothersome. 26:02 Um, so yes, I was- It's still the rally, what we're listening to... It's still the rally. [laughs] There's people coming back from the rally. I'm in a hotel. Um, 26:10 but, uh, yes, I was on, uh, the Avenida Atlantica in Copacabana all day. Uh, people started arriving really early here. Um, as you said, Bolsonaro was in Brasilia this morning. 26:21 He didn't arrive in Rio till later this afternoon, but, uh, the crowds were already out en masse from pretty early. Uh, they came here to, uh, to watch the military show that was planned. 26:34 Uh, there was, there was an air show, a naval grade. 26:38 Uh, the whole, the whole of Copacabana Beach was lined with, um, with these sound trucks, uh, you know, playing, playing Bolsonaro jingles who had, uh, evangelical pastors leading prayers from the sound trucks. 26:51 And, uh, early this morning, it was really quite, uh, quite a festive atmosphere. Um, speak- you know, speaking to people here, everyone's convinced that Bolsonaro has already won. 27:00 Uh, Sidlay, you said the, the crowd in Brasilia was smaller than last year. I think that was also true in São Paulo, but in Rio, however, uh, it was quite the opposite. 27:09 Uh, you could barely move on, on Copacabana Beach from so... There were so many people later this afternoon. Um, 27:16 and I think here, definitely Bolsonaro succeeded in, uh, in the show of strength that that was the whole point of him, of him co-opting these, uh, these independence day celebrations to show that, that he can rally people on the streets and that, uh, what he calls, uh... 27:32 [cheering] Sorry about that. Uh, but to show that he has got the support of people on the streets, even if the surveys currently show that he will lose to, lose to Lula. 27:44 Now, Constance, um, when I was listening to the speech that Bolsonaro delivered in Copacabana, uh, I couldn't help but notice that he, he, he was just repeating bits that he had already delivered in other speeches recently, verbatim sometimes. 28:03 Uh, he didn't bring anything new to the table. It was just the same, uh, the same old Bolsonaro talking points, or did I miss something? No, I think that's, that's quite right. 28:18 Uh, you know, Bolsonaro stuck to, uh, the script of criticizing Lula, criticizing the left, uh, defending, you know, his conservative values. Uh, obviously criticizing- Constance, if I may just interrupt you. 28:34 If you can hold your microphone just a little bit closer to your mouth, I think it- Is that, is that good? Um- Yes. Thank you very much. Sorry. Sorry. Crowds are coming and going. Um, uh, 28:45 but yeah, so the s- his speech today really didn't say anything new. Uh, the same sort of electoral discourse. Um, and also it was, it wasn't quite as aggressive as some people expected. 28:57 You know, he didn't, he didn't make a full frontal attack on Brazil's democratic institutions. 29:03 Uh, as you said, just sort of repeating, repeating his criticism of Lula, uh, defending, defending a conservative Brazil, uh, and really just a- an electoral, an electoral speech more than anything else. 29:17 Now, Beatriz, uh, this electoral speech that Bolsonaro just gave in Brasilia and especially in Rio, um, I think he also illustrates this new part of the Bolsonaro m- campaign messaging, which is to hammer down, uh, whenever he can that Lula is a convicted felon, even though the Supreme Court has quashed Lula's convictions last year, and that he said that, "I may be crass, I may, uh, talk, uh, in vulgar language, but I ain't no thief." 29:52 Um, what do you make of these words? Yeah, we know. 29:55 [laughs] Uh, because we, we have, uh, seen a lot of scandals as of late, and just last week, if I am not wrong, uh, we saw a report by news website, UOL, saying that half of the assets owned by the Bolsonaro family have been bought in cash, which is a classic, um, way of dealing, uh, property by people engaged in money laundering schemes because it, uh, actually... 30:22 I'm not saying the president has engaged in such schemes. I'm just saying that, uh, investigators, uh, frown upon this kind of dealings because it's a way to make money untraceable. Mm-hmm. 30:33 So, um, sorry for the long question, but what do you make of this next stage of the Bolsonaro messaging to hammer down, "Lula is a crook. I am not. I'm a Christian." What do you make of it? 30:44 Uh, there's, there's so many things in that question. Um, I think my first reaction is that I don't study public opinion. 30:51 Um, I study political elites, but to those people who study public opinion, um, I want to understand how the Bolsonaro voters rationalize n- not pinning down corruption on him, 'cause that blows my mind, right? 31:05 We've had many, many, many, many corruption scandals tied to this government. Uh, we had gold being exchanged at the Ministry of Education. Like, w- it's just so bizarre. 31:17 Again, we're in this bizarre world in which there, there, there is evidence that Bolsonaro and his sons engaged, and his administration engaged in corruption, and he can go on a campaign trail and say that Lula is the one who's corrupt, not him. 31:34 And that's okay for 30, 33% of the presented population. Um, we need to study that [laughs] uh, to understand what the mechanism is, uh, psychological, uh, mechanism there. But I think, uh, he- it's, it's... 31:50 I'm gonna switch the question and, and, and my answer is just, like, I think the Lula campaign ne- needs to do a better job in, in highlighting the corruption scandals that Bolsonaro and his administration and his family. 32:02 So it's Bolsonaro, his administration, and his family are engaged in or can be potentially engaged in, right? Um, 32:10 again, we- I have been writing about this, uh, I have been talking a lot about this, but the secret budget in itself, to me, is more damaging than anything that was done since democratization, uh, in- because of the consequences that it brings, not only to the legislative arena, but for the political system as a whole, right? 32:29 Um, it's- he, he can do that. He can go and say whatever he wants, but there has to be a comeback, uh, to, to what he's saying. Um, and the part about religion, because he says he's a Christian, uh, I think, um... 32:44 I also just want to make a parentheses. Uh, who was in Bra- who was in Rio, Constance, did you see the, the Silas, the pastor Silas Malafaia? Uh, he was in that, how do you say that [laughs]... [laughs]... 32:59 A sound- A sound truck... a sound truck. A evangelical sound truck. Brazil 2000, uh, 2022, that's what we have, Bolsonaro campaigning on a neo-Pentecostal sound truck. 33:13 I think that, when I read that this morning, I was just like, "Yeah, this is exactly right. That's where we are right now." 33:18 Um, but yeah, he, he, he wants to sell this image that he's a Christian and that he has Christian values, right? 33:26 Even though those Christian values, uh, when we look for evidence to support that, in reality, we don't find it, right? Because he, as Sade was saying [laughs], he steals. Uh, and today he stole our Independence Day, um, 33:39 which is, uh, un- unfortunate because it was supposed to be a celebration of, uh, Brazil and, and, uh, our nation state and all of that, and we didn't hear a word about that. 33:50 Now, uh, Beatriz, I'm just going to call for a quick break of, uh, just one minute, and when we come back, we'll come back also, we're gonna add one member to our conversation, uh, Ewan Marshall, our editor at The Brazilian Report, and he, uh, is in São Paulo. 34:08 He lives quite close to Avenida Paulista, where, uh, pro-Bolsonaro supporters held their own parade. So we'll be back in just a few seconds to disc- to talk a little bit more with Ewan. 34:21 I'd like to take this opportunity to talk about our new exclusive report on the 2022 Brazilian elections, a watershed moment for Brazilian democracy. 34:31 In less than a month, Brazilians will head to the polls in what is gearing up to be the most decisive election in the country's recent history. Everything you need to know to be well-positioned in this crucial moment. 34:43 Our 31-page report is filled with in-depth analysis that will bring you up to date on crucial topics such as the main issues facing the economy, Bolsonaro's re-election strategy, threats to Brazilian democracy, the importance of congressional elections, and a detailed overview of governor races in key Brazilian states. 35:03 So don't hang around any longer. Become an insider with the Brazilian report. Go to brazilian.report/subscribe and use the coupon code SEPTEMBER22 for a 20% discount on our exclusive report. 35:22 Hello [laughs]. So I've been, um, I've arrived here, editor of the Brazilian Report, Ewan Marshall. Uh, Gustavo Ribeiro, our editor-in-chief, is taking a quick break from the hosting duties. 35:34 So I'd like to welcome back, who have we still got here? Sade, Beatriz, Constance, lovely to speak to all of you. Hope you're all well. 35:47 Um, as Gustavo said before he took his quick break, um, I obviously am in São Paulo today, where we had another of the pro-Bolsonaro rallies. 35:58 As I think was mentioned a bit earlier, um, in this particular broadcast, the numbers in São Paulo were large, but not quite what we've seen, uh, especially last year, and also in a lot of other, uh, pro-Bolsonaro rallies or rallies for other candidates at, um, at particular points in recent history. 36:17 But still, uh, I think maybe there's a, there's a kind of caveat we should add here is that it rained quite a lot, um, this morning in São Paulo, which is, I don't know, if, if you've never been to São Paulo or Brazil in general, I think just when it starts raining, it really does just put a proper dampener on your day. 36:34 You don't really want to leave the house. 36:36 Um, but yeah, some massive, massive crowds that formed after that, to their credit, uh, coming out with their, with their rain ponchos and filling up, uh, Paulista Avenue, which is the kind of main thoroughfare in São Paulo. 36:51 There was a suggestion originally that Jair Bolsonaro himself would address the crowd, uh, via a video link, but apparently one of the organizers was saying that they had a severe problem with the internet connection, maybe connected to the rain. 37:07 Um, but yeah, it was an interesting, uh, rally. It seemed it was more in Rio de Janeiro and potentially in Brasilia as well, but more of a kind of show of strength, um, sort of thing. 37:21 So I would just like to bring in Seydi here on a point which I would like to make about the, uh, today's rallies. Because this idea of a show of strength, it's not what we expected. 37:35 It's not what a lot of pundits expected from today. Uh, a lot of pundits expected maybe a more kind of, kind of strong, aggressive language from the president, and that's not what we got. 37:44 But is this str- show of strength in itself going to be a major advantage for Bolsonaro coming into this, uh, the, the, the home stretch of the election period? 37:56 Well, you know, I, I do not think that, uh, Bolsonaro's campaign, uh, really- is really concerned about using this platform to change votes or to appeal to people that currently do not intend to vote for Bolsonaro. 38:12 So the show of strength, uh, is, is really catering to people that already vote for him. He, he is, he's repeating the same old messages as, as Constas said. 38:22 Um, so hi- his intention here is, I understand, the same intention he had on recently going to interviews and participating in popular podcasts. So Bolsonaro goes to popular podcasts, and he gets really high ratings. 38:39 And then him and his supporters go to social media and they say, "Look, Bolsonaro is leading the ratings in this podcast. So how come the polls show that he's losing? He's so popular. 38:51 He gets so many ratings, so many people listen to Bolsonaro, so the polls must be wrong." And so the show of strength here is the same thing. He wants to draw large crowds and say, "Oh, look how big a crowd I got. 39:04 I got all these people going to my rally, therefore the polls are wrong because I'm number one." It's very, very similar, uh, to Donald Trump. It's the, it's the very Donald Trump playbook. 39:15 Uh, he- you attract large crowds, therefore the polls are wrong. And this was his intention, uh, with, with these political rallies by hijacking once again our bicentennial. 39:26 I also want to add some specific message that Bolsonaro said in his, uh, speech in Rio. Uh, one of the things that we should follow in Bolsonaro is that, uh, Bolsonaro always says the same things. 39:40 He has been saying the same things for the last 30 years. He does not- he, he has never changed his messages, and this allows us to understand Bolsonaro even when he speaks in half sentences. 39:54 In Rio today, Bolsonaro said a half sentence. He said, "I'm sure that you guys know what we should do for Brazil to follow in this path," which- by, by which he means the path to freedom. So I'm sure that you guys know. 40:10 This is a reference to a previous, uh, live. Bolsonaro does a live, uh, Facebook, uh, broadcast every Thursday. And one of r- one of these recent, uh, broadcasts on Thursday, Bolsonaro had a similar message. 40:25 He said, "I don't need to tell you what I'm thinking about, but you guys know what's at stake. 40:32 You know how you should prepare yourself, not for new capital," by which he means the invasion of the Capitol in the United States on January 6th. 40:40 "Nobody wants to invade anything, but we know what we must do before the elections." So here in Rio, he said a half sentence. He only said, "You guys know what you should do." 40:51 So what you guys know you should do is you- you're not going to recognize the result of the elections. You should go to the polling sections or to polling places and disturb people. 41:03 Uh, you should disturb the counting of votes. You should threaten poll workers. And this was once again the same message. But only now Bolsonaro spoke a half sentence. 41:16 And Beatriz, something I would just like to kind of bring up here, because you were with us speaking last year, uh, September 7th on these, uh, similar but different, uh, demonstrations. 41:29 And I think there was a kind of sensation that we had that day that perhaps Bolsonaro had played a lot of the press as fools. Is that the same today? Has he done this again? 41:40 I could not understand the last part of what you said because it cut. Could you say that again? Oh, sorry. Yeah. 41:45 Yeah, so the, the last year when we were having this conversation, there was this kind of idea like, you know, he's- we were expecting or fearing something different to happen, um, during last year's September 7th demonstrations, and we got something completely different. 41:59 He fooled us in that, in that particular, um, regard. This year, has he done it again? Has he fooled us once more? I mean, uh, not really. 42:10 If we look at what has happened since then, um, I was just telling Gustavo that I think some of the context changed, uh, significant- significantly. 42:21 For instance, uh, the people with money, uh, the economic elites have signaled that they support democracy. Um, so I think that is a big change for him in terms of what he can do. 42:34 Uh, I think that will also change the calculation. I hope it will change the calculation. 42:39 [laughs] I don't study the military, so, um, I, I don't know how they behave, but, uh, I hope that that would change the calculation for the military, for the armed forces as well. Um, 42:50 so I think- He kind of behaved the same way that he has been behaving in the last months, right? 42:59 Uh, I think what happened last year was he felt really empowered, like he felt like he could do a lot 'cause it wasn't clear who was supporting democracy or not at that point. 43:08 And so he went out there and he said, he named specifically, uh, a specific justice, and to the point that we had to have, uh, former President Michel Temer come in and kind of calm everybody down and make some sort of deal that we still don't know exactly what happened. 43:26 Um, but, uh, I think that was a different moment, right? Uh, when you ask me h- has he done something different, based on what he has been doing this year, not really. He didn't say anything different. 43:38 Did he say anything different from what he has been saying? I don't think so. Yeah, not really. It's the same messaging, uh, which to me, honestly, it's kind of stupid campaigning, [laughs] 43:48 if you think about it, because he wants to... I was saying this like 10 minutes ago, he wants to get more votes from women, and then he goes there and puts on a machista show. It's not rational. 44:02 Yeah, I mean, f- from, maybe from where I'm standing, I would perhaps guess that he's trying to buy into that idea of showing his ability to mobilize people, which- I mean, it-... 44:15 in public opinion worldwide, but, and also in Brazil- It works... there's a kind of- It works for- There's a tendency to... Yeah. It works for- There's a tendency to vote winner... part of the... Right. 44:24 Or the- And it works for his core supporters, right? 44:26 But if he wants to reach out outside of that, it doesn't really w- especially if he wants to reach out to women, he shouldn't be saying that we should vote based on who you're married to. [laughs] Indeed. Yeah. 44:38 Um, but it's just like perhaps the one aspect is that what you've seen a lot in, in, in Brazilian elections and public opinion over the year is that there is a tendency closer to the time to want to rally behind the winner, to want to behi- rally behind someone who you think has a really good chance. 44:54 And even though if he's on the one hand portraying the polls as, you know, as, um, as inaccurate and untrustworthy, he's showing potentially material evidence to people that, "Oh, look, I'm popular. 45:09 Look how many people I can bring out. You know, I'm giving myself a show of strength." I don't know. I mean, potentially some people might find that quite attractive. Well, like I'll, I'll... 45:21 So here I'm just w- I'm brainstorming, right? But, like, we were expecting the economic help that he gave to Brazilians to make a huge difference in the polls, and it didn't. That's money that we're talking about. 45:33 Um, I don't know if support will really s- switch numbers that much. Exactly. And just, just on that note then, let's talk about the polls, because we have had 45:47 f- for quite a long time now, the, the polling outlook has really not changed very much at all, um, between 45:55 Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in the lead and Jair Bolsonaro in second, and then, you know, we've got some of these third-way candidates, which combined are barely reaching 10% of the, um, of support. 46:07 The only real kind of influence we had was back when Sergio Moro dropped out of the, um, dropped out of the race in April. 46:16 And as you can see on this graph here, from March to April, Jair Bolsonaro gets a little bit of an increase there with, uh, voters coming from Sergio Moro. 46:25 But beyond that, we're seeing basically the same picture for, you know, well over a year now. 46:32 Is there any sort of belief that this can possibly change now with, as we've said, Bolsonaro saying more or less the same sort of things? 46:41 I don't see it changing unless something really catastrophic happens, like, uh, he's attempted, somebody attempts to kill him, like it did in 2018. That was a game-changer. 46:53 Um, I don't, I don't, I don't, I don't see the p- the, the data are there, right? We- He's been saying the same thing, he's been polling consistently the same. Uh, he's not moving to the center. That we- [laughs] 47:06 Today he showed that he's not moving to the center. He's not even moving to women. Um, [laughs] he's going the other way. 47:12 And I'm sorry I'm, I'm hammering on this point about women because it's just, to me it's just shocking how it's stupid but also outrageous at the, at the same time, right? 47:22 'Cause, like, if he wants to gather to get vote from these part of the population, he should be doing exactly the opposite [laughs] of what he's doing. 47:30 Um, but it seems like he's, uh, yeah, if he continues with the same, I don't see the numbers changing that much. And I think, um- Well, if, if, if I might barge in- Of course... 47:42 I see this as a natural consequence of polarization. 47:46 Uh, for months I've been calling, uh, that this, that this election would be the most boring presidential race Brazil has ever had, uh, with Lula first and Bolsonaro second, and this is just a natural consequence of having a polarized country. 47:59 In a polarized country, you've got two major candidates. People will not ch- change their minds. It doesn't matter what either candidate d- does. 48:08 If either of them burns the national flag live or et cetera, their supporters will not change their mind, and this is, this is a natural consequence of having a, a polarized race. 48:18 So, uh, the, the exciting thing, what I have always said is the exciting thing and exciting news is not on the presidential race and not on the election, but it's on what's going to happen after the election- I-... 48:31 when inevitably Bolsonaro will not recognize the result. I fully agree with that. 48:37 Uh, and if the US teaches us something, it's that that's exactly what we should be paying attention to, uh, how exactly we're gonna get out of this transition situation, right? It's not clear to any of us. Exactly. 48:51 Um, and obviously that's something that we're- What we've said a lot of the Brazilian report is that we are going to be looking not just at the election, but in the post-election period, which, you know, it's arguably, as Sidé says, it's 49:05 more interesting, tense perhaps than the actual c- campaign itself. Uh, Constanze, I'd just like to bring you back in here. 49:13 Um, I don't know, I don't know how you're getting on in Copacabana, if the crowds have died down a little bit, but, um, it sounded quite- They're getting bigger [laughs]. People are coming off the streets [laughs]. 49:25 Well, we talked just, uh, just recently there, it was Beatriz that brought up that, um, the Bolsonaro campaign has sought to put a lot of money into these kind of little short-term financial measures, economic measures to... 49:38 Just that kind of really grabbing for vote sort of thing. And we just, we haven't really seen any proper change in his po- in his, um, popularity. 49:48 Even though that, you know, over the years we have, you know, presidential approval is, is, is often linked to economic prosperity, but Bolsonaro just can't seem to, to get a break, really. Why is that? 50:04 Why he can't get a break despite having, despite having created or, like, yeah, put the whole government machine behind, behind distributing new benefits. I think, 50:17 yeah, we've really seen his support sort of cap at around 33%, haven't we? Uh, and it's his core supporters, the ones who, you know, who, who believe the, the discourse they're being fed. 50:31 Uh, you know, Beatriz was saying, you know, "You can't believe that these people who are on the streets, you know, can't see, uh, the corruption that surrounds Bolsonaro and his family." 50:39 The people I was speaking to today just don't, just, you know, if you ask them, "Oh, well, what, what, what do you have to say about, you know, the reports of Bolsonaro's family is corrupt?" 50:48 They're just like, "No, no, it's not true. He's an, he's an honest man." 50:51 Um, so I think Bolsonaro's managed to hold on to those people who, you know, who, who will not budge, but that, uh, that, you know, the combination of the economic crisis, uh, I think the, you know, the, the pandemic now seems very far away, but definitely took a hit on his support over the last year as they pushed away that middle part of the electorate, which, you know, a couple of years ago was still on his side. 51:26 Sorry, my microphone was muted there. Yeah, we just saw, saw a quick example there of the correlation that we have, um, between presidential popularity and the economy. 51:36 And you see that there, you know, there were some important moments for Bolsonaro, principally with the, kind of the emergency salary that came in, um, during the coronavirus. 51:45 It immediately saw, um, a significant drop in his rejection rates. But then, since then, all of these things that have come in, you know, the Auxílio Brasil benefit is now at 600 reais a month. 51:59 But it's just not really, not really having the effect that he had hoped. 52:03 Um, and I think now what we're looking at is we're not really looking at Bolsonaro trying to bring in a comeback, we're looking at whether this race is gonna be solved in the first round or if we're gonna have a runoff. 52:17 So from... So Beatriz, actually, you wanted to kind of jump in there. I don't know if it's connected, but we'll... 52:24 If you can also come round to that afterwards, as in where do you see this in terms of are we having a second round or is there a chance that this is gonna be ended soon? 52:35 I just wanted to comment on something that Constanze said that, uh, about my point of, uh, how Bolsonaro supporters don't see his corruption or possibility of corruption. 52:44 I think one possibility is that they don't trust the news outlets that are reporting this. 52:51 So of course they're not gonna recognize any corruption scandal, 'cause the only [scoffs] journalists that they listen to is the João Mengel ones, right? Uh, and they're not reporting any corruption scandals. 53:01 I've heard... I had the unfortunate experience of hearing, uh [laughs], João Mengel talking about the secret budget, and it's really not a thing in that universe, right? 53:10 Um, so I think that would partly, uh, explain, uh, how exactly he can get away without being accused of corruption. Um, I think I, I would bet on a second, on a runoff. 53:27 Um, I think, um, the numbers are pretty stable, but, uh, there could still be movement with the other candidates. Um, Simone, for instance, Simone Tebet polled, uh, he, she went up a little bit, uh, after the debate. 53:44 Uh, I don't... That's not to say that the debate matters. Uh, I don't wanna put that idea out there. I don't think it does. Um, but, uh, I would bet on a, on a, on a runoff. 53:55 I think it's a very polarized election, and we still, uh, don't know, uh, how accurate the polls are gonna be in ter- just in terms of the margins, and this is an election that's gonna be decided at the margins, right? 54:06 Um, so yeah, I don't know if Sidé and Constanze have a different opinion. Yeah. 54:11 And just quickly before we, we bring the two in, um, just to explain that Brazil's elections, they do work in a situation where in your first round, if one candidate gets more, um, more than half of the valid votes, which essentially means that all the other candidates combined against the leading candidate, if one leading candidate wins, then we don't need a runoff. 54:34 They win directly in a first-round landslide. If not, we have another month of campaigning, and the top two candidates go against each other. Whoever takes it, takes it. Um, and also... 54:46 Yeah, so Constanze, if we could just bring you in there about, you know, where, where are you seeing this, um, in terms of are we going to second round? Are we not? 54:56 I, I agree with Beatriz, uh, and I think that we're gonna go to a second round. You know, Lula's, Lula's lead falls... You know, the possibility of him winning in the first round falls within the margin of error. 55:07 Um, you, you mentioned, Beatriz, about that some of the centrist candidates are sort of grappling, probably grappling a few votes. 55:13 Uh, and I think if the campaign sort of continues in this form, uh, we're, we're definitely heading for a second round. 55:26 And Sidnei, uh, just to ask you on this, because one of the kind of factors that we have in this kind of the, the, the home stretch, as it were, of the campaign, is that Lula, who is, you know, well ahead in the, in, in the polls, is trying to appeal to the voters of Ciro Gomes, who is in third place at the moment. 55:46 He's trying to suggest that, you know, if you guys decide to strategically vote for me in the first round as opposed to Ciro Gomes, then we can just wrap this whole thing up. Uh, we can beat Bolsonaro in the first round. 55:58 There'll be no need for that further month of candidacy. And as we see here in this graph, Lula has consistently, throughout August, he was showing that he was polling better than all the others combined. 56:11 But then for the first time, we're just starting to see that dial slip into the other direction, um, with Lula there with 44% in comparison with 45% compared to the rest. 56:23 Sidnei, what do you think the chances are then of this, these Ciro Gomes voters engaging in this strategic voting? 56:31 Oh, from what I have seen, uh, Ciro Gomes supporters have been, uh, very steadfast in their support usually. Uh, they, most of them are not willing really to change their mind. 56:42 And in fact, making Ciro Gomes drop out has been a long desire in the PT campaign. It, it also happened in 2018, and it's happening this year again since, uh, the beginning of the year. 56:54 You, you see, uh, Petistas pro-Lula messengers, uh, saying that, "Oh, you know, C- Ciro should quit so Lula could win in the first round," and et cetera, et cetera. 57:05 Uh, there's also, um, some bad blood between them, and this has also inspired actually, uh, what we, what people now call fake news, but it's just a lie, that Ciro Gomes on the, the last election, according to this lie, uh, he traveled to Paris and he did not vote for Lula's candidate, Haddad, in the second round in 2018. 57:29 Actually, Ciro Gomes did travel to Paris, but he traveled back to Brazil and he voted, uh, in the, in the second round. Uh, the vote is secret, but, uh, Ciro says, uh, we understand Ciro voted for, for Haddad. 57:44 And so, so there is this bad blood and it has been a long dream from pro-Lula supporters for Ciro to drop out or for Ciro's voters to change for Lula. Uh, but they have been really steadfast with Ciro. 57:59 But this year, uh, to the Petistas' advantage, uh, Ciro is polling this year, uh, much lower than he did on last election. 58:08 On the last election, uh, Ciro won 12% of the vote, and he won on his, uh, home state of Ceará, uh, which is not likely to happen this year. So I believe that from what I understand from other polls, uh, show us, the m- 58:25 at least most of the Ciro supporters that could go to Lula already did. And just... Sorry, yeah. 58:37 And just bringing up the, the mention of Ciro Gomes there and the, the Paris story in 2018, like, I think the, like, 58:47 the, the target of that particular story is more like, oh, yeah, he didn't campaign, he didn't decide to campaign for Haddad, which is something that, you know, that could be playing in the back of the minds of the Lula, uh, camp at the moment. 59:02 I think that if this does go to a second round, Ciro Gomes is someone who, you know, he sticks to his electoral principles. You know, you can say a lot what you... 59:10 You, you say a lot about Ciro Gomes, but he definitely sticks to his principles. And there is a chance that maybe he wouldn't engage, um, in endorsing Lula against Bolsonaro, uh, similar to, to, to what happened in 2018. 59:24 And I imagine that could be a concern with that extra month of campaigning as well. You know, that is, that is a long time. That's a lot of time on television, a lot of, you know, um, a lot... 59:34 And, and some debates as well, which I know that Beatriz thinks are not important, and I think you're right in that. [laughs] Um, so I think we- I, I guess might add, um, this also speaks, there's an undertone in that. 59:46 There's an undertone of, of fear, uh, on, on part of the Lula campaign in that they're afraid that in the second round, the rejection to Lula could be, uh, stronger than the, the rejection to Bolsonaro. 59:58 So, so they speak of that fear when they speak of, "Oh, Ciro should resign so Lula can win." 1:00:04 So to add to Sidnei's point, the research in political science, uh, about how the, the percentage of voters behave is really they're divided between being a PT voter and anti-PT voter. That worries me. 1:00:18 Um, yeah, the runoff worries me in that, in that sense. And when I say it worries me, I want to say, like, if we're... From my perspective, uh, as an analyst, uh, I'm coming from a place of supporting democracy. 1:00:31 We're dealing with a candidate that is against democracy and has shown that, uh, he is against democracy. Uh, I do want to say I don't think debates matter, but I think it's healthy that they... 1:00:41 people participate in them because they should put their proposal, uh, the proposals out there. They should participate in interviews. Um, yeah, I love debates. I, I, I said that on Twitter. 1:00:52 I- when the first one happened, I miss them. I think we should have more of them. I don't think they matter, but they're, for political junkies like me, they're fun to watch too. [laughs] Exactly. 1:01:02 Right, uh, I think we'll be wrapping it up today. 1:01:04 Um, but first of all, I'd just like to give a quick reminder that, uh, The Brazilian Report, we have a page on Buy Me a Coffee, which is for, you know, people who, if you are a subscriber and you want to maybe support us a little bit more, or maybe if you don't fancy signing up to the website, but you want to give us a little bit of help there, you can donate, uh, coffees to us to fill up our coffee mugs while we're covering Brazil. 1:01:28 And also, we have a special membership program there where you can sign up by buying us monthly coffees, and we'll give you a lot of, you know, extra benefits like exclusive newsletters, behind-the-scenes content, all that sort of stuff. 1:01:42 It's very fun. So definitely check that out at buymeacoffee.com/brazilianreport. So what remains to say is thank you to you all. 1:01:51 Sidnei, Beatriz, Constance, it's been great to speak to all of you on, um, this slightly confusing day, I suppose, you know, the bicentennial of, of, of Brazil's independence. 1:02:03 Um, and yeah, for everyone who is celebrating their independence at home, you know, a very happy Independence Day to all of you, and we at The Brazilian Report will be back very soon. Thanks very much. 1:02:17 [outro music]