Transcript 0:00 November the 20th is Black Consciousness Day in Brazil, a public holiday in many cities and states around the country. 0:07 Although portrayed to the outside world as some sort of racial paradise, Brazil is nothing of the sort. 0:13 It was the last country of the West to abolish slavery, and when it did so in 1888, the establishment gave the freed slaves no means for survival or economic integration, creating a huge destitute underclass, the lasting effects of which we can still see today. 0:28 One arena where racism is still apparent today is football, Brazil's national sport and so often a reflection of society as a whole. 0:36 Despite the majority of players being non-white, they are often treated in stereotypes while the white players of European origin are strong-willed leaders, black players are seen as tricky, inventive, but ultimately unintelligent and untrustworthy. 0:52 That is not to mention the many cases of on-field racial abuse which we have witnessed over the years. 0:57 My name's Euan Marshall, staff writer at the Brazilian Report, standing in for Editor-in-Chief Gustavo Ribeiro, and this is Explaining Brazil. 1:04 [upbeat music] To discuss racism in Brazilian football, joining me today is Marcel Diego Tonini, PhD in Social History at the University of São Paulo and editor of Ludo Pediu, an online portal of academic works about Brazilian football. 1:29 Hi, Marcel. Thanks for speaking to us today. It, it's a pleasure to me. So to start things off, let's go back in time to the foundations of Brazilian football. 1:42 So it started as a sport for white men played by white men, but when we look at the history of Brazil's most prominent and famous footballers, the vast majority of them are black. 1:56 How did this sport begin to accept black players, and how has racism in football evolved over these years? Right. 2:06 Um, uh, football came by the influence of the physical education, the hygiene of the bodies, uh, seen as a European modernity, a leisure, and above all, a bracket of social distinction. 2:22 The material itself was important and the terms said in English in Brazil in the first decades of the 20th century. Mm-hmm. In defiance of the elite, its popularization was inevitable. 2:38 Uh, the control of the official practice, uh, of the clubs and the leagues remaining in the hands of the elites. 2:47 Uh, the discrimination took place by means of regulations prohibiting the entry of athletes who were manual workers, illiterate, poor, and colored people. 3:01 It was also forbidden the presence of blacks in the bleachers of private stadiums. Mm. Uh, the elite charged high membership fees. 3:15 They, uh, demanded that the athletes be members of this, the clubs or that the affiliated clubs had stadiums. For instance, we, we have the Vasco da Gama in 1927. 3:31 In the state capitals of Brazil, clubs of popular o-origin, for the most part, played, uh, championships of lower divisions or had to found their own leagues. We have two examples. 3:47 The National Football League Porto Alegrense in 1910 and the Suburban, uh, Football League in Rio de Janeiro in 1907. 3:59 The racialist theories of the end of the 19th century also influenced the football. The black presence was undesirable. 4:11 Racism was interjected by the black athletes themselves who tried to disguise their own negritude, skin color, and hair especially, throughout rice powder, talcum powder, passing a type of gel, uh, smoothing hair and wearing a cap. 4:32 The preeminent performance of the blacks was, uh, overturning the restrictions in a few, in a few decades. 4:41 Some authors have used the term conservative democratization to explain how some clubs have opened their, uh, doors and, and to restrict certain venues to members who have monopolized, uh, political and financial, uh, management and open the other spaces to athletes and fans that, uh, that were members from the lower classes as the, the black people. 5:14 Gremio, uh, is one of those clubs that practices, uh, such acts in Brazil. And so today, how has this racism in football, how has it evolved over the years? Does it, does it still exist? 5:30 Is, is football in Brazil still racist, and how does it manifest itself? Yes, the, the football in Brazil is still racist until now. 5:40 Uh, if we can see more, uh, black athletes, but we can't see, uh, blacks occupying, uh, other spaces like managers, like coaches, other spaces that needs from them opportunity and, uh, knowledge. 6:00 So Marcel, would you say that the structure of Brazilian football is inherently racist, and if so, why is it? Uh, it's certainly racist. 6:13 The, uh, recruiting base for coaches in world football, but above all in Brazil, it is the universe of former players. The proportion of Blacks in one and another universe is not repeated in Brazil. 6:29 While on one side we have many Blacks athletes, on the other hand, we counted on the fingers of one hand that the Black coaches in the two main divisions of Brazilian football. 6:43 The truth is that the Blacks are discredited to invest in their caree- in their career since young people. They do not see themselves in this, in these positions. 6:56 To be a good coach, you need, uh, the ability to coordinate a work team, they stand up to the players, make themselves respected in front of the leaders, disdain any fan fights, relate well to the press, and be a good strategist as well. 7:14 The indispensable disposition, however, is to rule other men in a context where male values are dramatized. 7:24 The fact that Blacks out of the coaching role is that, uh, is considered proper to those nature oriented to sending others. For the status quo in Brazil, in the Brazilian society, uh, it is, uh, up to them to obey. 7:42 There is therefore a direct, uh, relationship with the s- history of Brazil, our slave, slave past. It's not allowed that Blacks send whites in any professional and even in football. 7:57 The, the few that become coach begin in grassroots from the base categories until the, they are able to be a c- a coach in a crisis of the Brazilian clubs. I interviewed four of them. 8:14 Three of them told me that either they were fired or they were not hired because they are, they were Black. 8:23 So, uh, two, two Black coaches were Andrade and Jaime de Almeida, both of the most popular club in Brazil, Flamengo. They were, uh, respectively 8:37 champions of Brazilian championship, and even then they were dismissed of, in the first moment of instability. So it, their, their lack of preparation and competence or lack of opportunities to them. 8:55 No, it's no doubt that it's the lack of opportunity because they were not hired by any other great team, uh, in Brazil. 9:05 Yeah, it's, it's interesting that you mention Andrade there because I, I remember that the 2009 championship when he took over the team and they went on to win the league, and now we're less than, we're less than 10 years later, and if I'm, if I'm right in saying, I think Andrade is either he has now stopped football managing altogether, or he is managing like a part-time team in the northeast of Brazil or something like that. 9:33 It's amazing the contrast between the way that Andrade's career has gone and so many other Brazilian football managers who just keep getting chance after chance after chance at the really big clubs. Yeah. 9:46 And Andrade, yeah, one of the only prominent Black coaches at the time has really, he's never gotten a big job since. 9:54 Yes, that, that is, uh, Andrade has no opportunities to, uh, keep their career, keep his career, and other white, uh, coaches continues their career even with no famous or, um, no, no titles. 10:12 Yeah, there, there is, there is somewhat of a revolving door of, uh, white Brazilian coaches who all seem to manage all the same clubs and they all just get passed around. It's quite, it's quite fascinating. 10:26 But yeah- It was... 10:27 and another thing I would like to ask you was about the international perception of racism in football, because we see, here in Brazil, we see a lot of reports of racist incidents happening in major European leagues. 10:46 Uh, a lot of Black players being, um, being abused in Italy and Spain and all of these places, and there is the kind of, there's the perception that maybe that doesn't happen in Brazil. 10:58 Like, what, what would you say to that? Well, I, I say that this is a false image that Brazil has helped to, to sell around the world for decades. 11:10 This is the result of the ideology of racial democracy proposed by the intellectual Gilberto Freyre in the, uh, 1930s. 11:20 In the '50s, UNESCO came to realize a vast research project whose purpose was to show the world how Brazil was a model of race relations, where Blacks and whites coexist harmoniously, unlike the experience of the United States of America and South Africa. 11:41 In a short time, it was verified how this racial democracy was a myth, and now the racism in Brazil, uh, occurred in different ways. 11:53 Uh, being Black is a vic- victim as much as in, in the countries already I mentioned. In football it is no different. 12:02 Although we have many internationally preeminent Black athletes, even Brazilians, uh, they continue to be victims of racism, whether, uh, as athletes or in attempt to en- enter other areas of Action within football, such as coaches, referees, and sporting directors or journalists, as I, I said. 12:29 Yeah, and so talking about that which you just mentioned about the fact that there aren't many Black coaches where there are many Black players, if we just look over to the, the north of the Panama Canal for a second, in the United States, in American football, they suffered from a very similar problem where Black coaches were being poorly represented in the National Football League, and there they created the so-called Rooney Rule, which was they forced clubs to interview ethnic minority candidates for all of their coaching vacancies. 13:06 So do you think that that would be something which maybe could work in Brazil? 13:11 Yes, but the federations and the state federations and the CBF, they just make, uh, protocol campaigns that want to, uh, give an answer to society. 13:25 So they, they use banners with, uh, "Say no to racism," or, uh, "Racism, no." Uh, they don't want to tackle racism here. Yeah, I mean, that certainly... 13:41 we've certainly seen that quite a lot throughout the years, although there was one situation back in 2014 when Santos goalkeeper, uh, Aranha was racially abu- racially abused by fans of Grêmio, which we mentioned earlier, uh, during a cup match, and Grêmio were eventually actually thrown out of the tournament because of this. 14:05 And when Aranha returned to Porto Alegre, the first game that he played in Grêmio after the situat- after the incident, one of the Grêmio club officials called it a, quote, "fair retaliation" that he was booed by the Grêmio fans. 14:20 So, you know, what, what does that tell us about... We talked about the confederation, the CBF, but what does that tell us about how the clubs are trying to deal with the issue of racism? 14:29 Is there any desire anywhere for anyone to do anything about this? In this case, it reveals that racism is not fought by anyone, neither by CBF nor by, uh, Brazilian clubs or federations, state federations. 14:46 In fact, it shows how society sees the B- Black people and the persons who seeks, who seek his rights as, uh, dangerous people, as, uh, uh, rebellious peop- Blacks. 14:59 And the country never assumes, uh, racist, although this is a current, uh, current practice here. And the federations, as I said, they don't want to tackle racism, you know? Yeah. 15:13 And so ano- another thing which I've witnessed quite a lot when we're talking about racism in Brazilian football is that when players or people close to Brazilian football, when they are asked about racist behavior that they have seen or that they have suffered on the pitch, they often reply that to them it's just, uh, like a part of the game. 15:37 It's something normal. It's a strategy from the players and the fans to try and, try and wind up their opponents. Do you think there is anything to that? 15:46 I mean, should we treat racism on the pitch in a competitive sense, should we, should, should we treat it differently, or is it racism all the same? 15:55 The, the soccer culture in Brazil especially, uh, is that we, in this space-time of the stadium and the 90 minutes, it seems to have its own laws different from Brazilian society, in which, uh, discriminatory acts are allowed or at least, uh, tol- tolerated. 16:18 That is, uh, that what is expressed in sentences such as, "Everything that happens inside the pitch must remain on the pitch," or, uh, "Football has its own rules," or, uh, "Within the four lines, uh, this is allowed." 16:37 Uh, this is a, a soccer culture, you know, and, and it, it is very difficult to, to tackle this. We have to educate again the society to be 16:51 not patient with, uh, racism, not only in the football but in the society. Okay, great. So we'll leave it there for today. Marcel, thank you very much for joining us, and we hope to speak to you again soon. Okay. 17:07 It's, it's a pleasure to me. If you liked this podcast, please take a look at our website. It's brazilian.report. 17:14 Every day we have new content about Brazilian politics, finance, and society, and we've also got exclusive newsletter services if you want to be briefed about what's going on in Brazil before starting your day. 17:25 Subscribe now for a free trial and enjoy all of our content for 14 days, and it's really free. You don't have to submit any credit card information whatsoever. You can also follow us on Facebook and Twitter. 17:36 Our handle is @Brazilianreport. That's all for now. I'll see you next week. [outro jingle]