Transcript 0:00 A blitzkrieg of self-protection. 0:03 It began after the Supreme Court convicted former President Jair Bolsonaro for attempting a coup d'état, and justices authorized dozens of anti-corruption investigations into how lawmakers have allocated federal funds, as well as suspending those money transfers themselves. 0:22 In response, in the space of a single week, the Brazilian House approved a constitutional amendment proposal known as the Impunity Bill, a sort of get out of jail free card that would make it nearly impossible for legislators to be investigated or prosecuted for any crimes. 0:42 It also passed a motion to fast-track a bill granting amnesty to those convicted of crimes against democracy, Bolsonaro included. 0:51 And finally, the House saw the Liberal Party appoint Bolsonaro's son, Congressman Eduardo Bolsonaro, as minority whip, a cynical move to protect him from losing his seat for absenteeism, given that he has spent months in the US lobbying for sanctions on Brazil in an effort to save his father from prison. 1:14 Despite once claiming to be against the system, pro-Bolsonaro lawmakers voted en masse in favor of the Impunity Bill. They told voters that they had traded their support for backing for the amnesty bill. 1:28 On the left, frustration also ran high. 1:31 A dozen Workers' Party lawmakers also supported the Impunity Bill, and defended themselves by saying that they wanted to reach a compromise with the right and get the government's agenda over the hump. 1:45 The backlash against Congress was swift. Senators rushed to declare they would not approve the Impunity Bill, and the amnesty bill began to lose momentum as well. 1:55 Still, the whirlwind of legislation rekindled a flame that had long seemed extinguished, and tens of thousands of people took to the streets of Brazil's major cities over the weekend in protest. 2:10 For the first time in years, the left displayed a mobilizing power rivaling that of Bolsonarism, and the effect was almost immediate, with multiple lawmakers backing down on their support for the Impunity Bill, and others even saying that the amnesty push may be as good as dead. 2:29 And Eduardo Bolsonaro's appointment as minority whip, by the way, has also been blocked. In the middle of one of Congress's most anti-republican moments in recent times, democracy showed it's still alive. 2:44 My name is Gustavo Ribeiro, editor-in-chief of The Brazilian Report. This is Explaining Brazil. 3:07 To discuss the nuts and bolts of these latest developments, we welcome Mario Sergio Lima, a senior Brazil analyst at Madley Global Advisors and a longtime friend of this show. Mario, thanks for being with us. 3:21 Thank you, Gustavo. It's a pleasure to be here again. 3:23 Mario, in recent days, we've seen the House moving to legislate very much in its own interests, seemingly unconcerned with how voters might react, despite the heavy scrutiny on social media. 3:37 Now, unlike the Senate, House members are not elected by majority vote, but rather through a complex proportional system that is heavily influenced by party strength and the charisma of a few so-called vote magnet candidates. 3:53 As a result, their connection with voters may be less direct than in the case of senators. Was this disregard for public opinion always a feature of the Lower House, or are we seeing something worse now? 4:08 Because some argue that changes in campaign financing have made lawmakers more dependent on their party leaders rather than on their constituents. Hi, Gustavo. 4:20 Yeah, I mean, uh, it's, it's like a contradiction of terms because the Lower House was supposed to be the house of the parliament that was, uh, more connected to the needs of the common man in the streets, while the Senate would, would have like a, a, would be looking at the w- statewide what was important. 4:42 Uh, and, and so we had like a, kind of, kind of like a middle, middle ground between the governors of the states and the, the presidency. 4:52 Uh, but the fact that, uh, not only-- You, you have, uh, two reasons why you have this, uh, divorce between lawmakers, especially the Lower House lawmakers, and the public needs. 5:06 First, like you mentioned, is the financing, uh, system. 5:10 So since now you only have public financing for the campaigns, and you have, uh, the, the occasional, uh, private donate, donation, not from corporates, but from individuals. 5:24 So, uh, of course, I mean, this made the guy, this, this made the lawmakers more prone to, to the, the, the power of the leaders because the leaders eventually, uh, not, not the, just the, not just the party leaders in Congress, but the party, the, the, the party leaders, uh, the whole, the whole board of the party because basically those guys can set, uh, they can set the allocation of money for each campaign. 5:52 So that makes them more susceptible to those, uh, individuals rather than their constituencies. 6:00 Uh- Also, uh, they can since private donations are allowed but just for individuals rather than corporates, you can also be, uh, way more connected to local powers, local financial powers which tend to have, uh, interests that, uh, very rarely are similar to what the constituencies have. 6:23 Also, there's another, there's another reason which is important to highlight is ever since Bolsonaro basically gave up the, uh, presidential power, I would say like a presidential power of the purse to the Congress. 6:36 Uh, basically lawmakers do not feel, uh, anymore-- They, they don't need to, to do anything that would, uh, constitute some sort of political bargain with the presidency. 6:51 And at the same time they can, uh, they, they can have a free access to money to be directed to their constituencies. 6:57 But not, uh, I would say not for the, the, the, the most important works, but basically what would, would garner more votes. 7:07 Uh, so basically like I mean, they can, uh, absorb some sort of, uh, bad will from voters in these kinds of bills because they compensate with those, those earmarks that they ma-they, they managed to bring to their constituencies. 7:24 So it, it, it is a complete divorce, uh, from po-from power, uh, from people to power, which is a very negative, uh, aspect of Brazil's democracy at the moment. And is there a path for that to change? 7:40 Uh, although it wasn't, uh, the ideal world in which the, the, the, the executive branch had the power, that had the full power and would negotiate the access to those earmarks on their basis of the sup-the support they get on, on, on houses. 7:59 Uh, we, we kind of replaced that system, which was very flawed to a worse system. 8:06 Uh, so I, I think at some point the system will start to improve once, uh, the, the executive branch regain this kind of power of the purse. 8:18 And there are bills at lower house, sorry, at Supreme Court that are aiming to do so. Not bills, but, uh, uh, there are, there are, uh, cases, legal cases in the, in Supreme Court. 8:33 And also, uh, you have, uh, the, the you, you also have, uh, the probably... 8:42 But, but there were the-- You, you could also, I think at, at some point you should try to, to, uh, have a, a broader discussion, especially on transparency of the use of those funds and the kind of, uh, power that the parties have in this kind of public finance. 9:02 I think like those will be key steps towards it. But, uh, at some point you also need to, to have, uh, a sense of responsibility and a sense of accountability. 9:15 I feel like the Congress has lost a lot of accountability to their, to their, their constituencies in the, in the last years, and this need to come back. 9:26 So those guys really need to feel, uh, po-popular pressure on what they are voting. 9:33 Uh, it's not going to be the best system im-impermeable to problems, but at least you would, tho-those guys will need to, uh, show what they're doing and actually, uh, show what they're voting. 9:50 The bill that they, they, they tried to pass had, I mean, some parts which, uh, not only were they, they completely a-against everything that is de-democratic in nature, which is they wanted to do secrecy votes. 10:06 They actually managed to do a, a maneuver to in-to put secrecy votes on the possibility of, of opening up a, a, a, a case against their themselves, a legal case against themselves, which, I mean, it's, uh, it's corruption at its core. 10:25 And just to bring some details. So this proposal was meant to say that, uh, lawmakers could only be investigated if their peers approved it. 10:35 Now, this is the system that reigned, uh, between nineteen eighty-eight and two thousand and one because right after the dictatorship, the political class believed that it was important to give some shields to, uh, lawmakers, given, 10:51 uh, the dictatorial experience. Uh, but that quickly veered into abuse in democratic times because even lawmakers accused of murder, uh, were being shielded from investigations. 11:05 And I mean, these moves that, uh, that you mentioned, uh, they were only possible because of an alliance between two major forces in Congress right now, Bolsonarism and the big center. 11:19 And the big center, for those who don't know, is a loose coalition of self-interest, right of center parties that have dominated Congress for years now. 11:29 Political commentator Celso Rocha de Barros described this alliance as a sort of marriage of convenience between thieves and coup mongers. And, uh, we saw that [chuckles] dynamic during Bolsonaro's presidency. 11:44 But the context is quite different now. Bolsonaro is ineligible and has been convicted, while the speaker, Hugo Motta, a member of the big center, has not shown much reliability or firmness. 11:59 So in this new scenario, what-- in what terms is this alliance moving forward? And I mean, what does each side want and w- which, what does each side realistically can achieve? 12:16 Uh, I mean, it's, uh, it is a, a marriage of interest. Uh, it's clear. Uh, I, I, I like the [laughs] Celso, Celso Rocha's definition. 12:25 Uh, maybe, maybe I, I will be a little less, less, uh, aggressive on the, on the thieves because there are some which might not be thieves, but they, they do act in their own interest, but, uh, not criminals per se. 12:41 But the thing is, uh, when we changed it, the law in 2001, one case was very impor- w- was one of the culprits of that change, which was basically a lawmaker that was found in a video, uh, mauling a, a, a person with a, with a 13:00 chainsaw, [laughs] mau- mauling somebody with a chainsaw. 13:02 I mean, it was, it was this kind of people that were being protected at that point, so- And he did not lose his seat because he was dismembering people with a chainsaw. [laughs] That is important to say. Exactly. 13:15 Exactly, exactly. So, uh, the thing is, 13:20 it, i- i- it was like they, they lost, like, privilege, a constitutional privilege, but, uh, it was a constitutional privilege that wasn't being, was being used, uh, uh, improperly, but wasn't... 13:35 That, that didn't make sense in the moment where you had more than... You were moving towards a more stable democracy. 13:42 [gentle music] To hear the full episode, subscribe to Explaining Brazil on Apple Podcasts, Buzzsprout, or Spotify. Or better yet, support us directly by subscribing to The Brazilian Report, newsroom behind this show. 13:58 You will find the audio free on our website, along with daily newsletters delivering original reporting and sharp analysis on Brazil and Latin America. Head over to brazilian.report. 14:14 [gentle music]