Transcript 0:00 Before we get started this week, we have a very important announcement. This will be the last episode of the Explaining Brazil podcast in its current weekly format. 0:12 At the end of last year, we at the Brazilian Report embraced an exciting new chapter, transforming into a premium newsletter service focused on what you, our readers, value most, daily in-depth analysis on Brazil and Latin America delivered straight to your inbox. 0:33 That transition has been a resounding success. Our subscribers are now getting more insights, more context, and more value than ever before. 0:44 Along the way, our Explaining Brazil podcast has remained a key part of our mission, a free open door into our community and our journalism, and it's played that role beautifully, helping thousands discover and connect with the Brazilian Report. 1:01 Now as we grow and evolve, we're taking a step back to reimagine what audio can be for us and for you. 1:10 So we'll be hitting pause on our weekly episodes for now, not as an end, but as a chance to rethink and build something even stronger. 1:19 But before we go, if you want to keep receiving our analysis and insight on Brazil and Latin America, we're offering our podcast listeners a free two-week premium membership to the Brazilian Report so you can see for yourself what you're missing out on. 1:35 Go to newsletters.brazilian.report/upgrade. We really hope to see you there, and we'd like to give our sincere thanks for being with us over the past six years and almost 400 episodes. 1:51 Now, with today's show. A major social security scandal causes a government headache. Brazil's beef sector needs major changes to hit emissions goals. 2:05 And Lula's off to Rome for the Pope's funeral, but who's going with him? I'm Gustavo Ribeiro. And I'm Euan Marshall. And this is Explaining Brazil, brought to you by the Brazilian Report. 2:18 Brazil's Federal Police and Federal Comptroller's Office have blown the lid off a massive fraud scheme, one that skimmed billions of reais directly from retirees' pockets and leaves the Lula administration scrambling on three fronts, political, criminal, and fiscal. 2:36 Dubbed Operation No Discount, investigators carried out more than 200 search warrants across 14 states this week, zeroing in on top officials at the National Social Security Institute, the INSS, and their partner associations. 2:55 Here's how the scheme worked. Pensioners would have unauthorized union and association fees quietly deducted from their monthly checks, often via forged signatures. 3:08 For instance, one of the associations involved had just three members in December 2021 and suddenly ballooned to 600,000 two years later. 3:20 From 2019 to 2024, these illicit deductions totaled 6.3 billion reais, or $1.1 billion, with more than one-third of that amount being taken just last year. So how was this allowed to happen? 3:38 Under the far-right government of former President Jair Bolsonaro, rules were loosened for technical cooperation agreements between the INSS and pensioner associations, making it far too easy for groups to gain authorization to deduct fees. 3:55 Despite internal reforms and audits launched in 2023 after Lula took power, the problem only got worse. 4:04 Faced with the scandal, the Lula government swiftly suspended all association deduction agreements and pledged to overhaul oversight. 4:13 But critics argue that the mechanisms for pensioners to cancel unauthorized deductions remain far too complex, especially for elderly or less tech-savvy beneficiaries. 4:26 11 associations are now under court investigation, nine are barred from further deductions, and two are tied to Lula's own Workers' Party and its allies. Politically, opposition lawmakers are having a field day. 4:42 The far-right Liberal Party is demanding a parliamentary inquiry, branding this an example of systemic Workers' Party corruption. Fiscal pain's coming too. 4:53 The government has promised to reimburse those retirees, which could tack an extra 8 billion reais onto an already stretched federal budget. 5:03 In the immediate fallout, INSS head Alessandro Stefanutto was fired, and five other senior officials were suspended by court order. Read the full story in the April 24th issue of our Brazil Daily newsletter. 5:21 Brazil is gearing up to host COP30 in Belém this November, hoping to burnish its climate leadership. Yet a new study warns that one of the country's most important economic sectors could derail those ambitions. 5:34 Researchers at the Federal University of São Paulo calculated that if current trends continue, emissions from Brazil's gigantic beef sector will exceed the level compatible with Paris Agreement pledges by more than double. 5:48 Brazil is home to more cattle than people, and it is the world's second-largest beef producer and top exporter. 5:55 Cattle farming accounted for roughly 7% of the country's GDP in 2024, but all that comes at a very high environmental cost. 6:04 Methane from cows and deforestation from pasture clearing create a great deal of Brazil's greenhouse gas emissions. 6:11 In fact, land use changes account for roughly half of CO2 emissions every year, while about three quarters of all emissions can be linked to food systems in some manner. 6:21 Between now and 2030, Brazil's beef sector is projected to emit between 0.42 and 0.63 gigatons of CO2 equivalent, and to meet the country's nationally determined contribution of cutting emissions by 43% by 2030, beef emissions must drop by more than half. 6:41 Biologist Mariana Vieira, one of the study's co-authors, told us that solutions are available and that the sector knows what needs to be done to mitigate these emissions. 6:50 She mentions strategies such as the genetic improvement of herds, optimized feed formulations, recovery and rotational management of pastures, and integrating crops, livestock and forestry on the same land. 7:03 The researchers also calculated the social cost of carbon for beef emissions, measuring future economic, social and environmental damages that could result from the sector's status quo. 7:14 Were Brazil to in fact reduce its emissions by 43% by 2030, the country could save tens of billions of dollars in avoided losses from extreme weather events, biodiversity decline and agricultural disruption. 7:28 Read the full story in the April 24th edition for Brazil Climate Newsletter. 7:36 President Lula caught a plane on Thursday night to be in Rome this Saturday for the funeral of Pope Francis, an act of personal respect for the late pontiff and the culmination of seven days of national mourning here in Brazil. 7:49 But the real story lies not in Lula's travel plans, but in who will, or who won't, be a part of his delegation and what that says about Brazilian politics today. 8:01 Back in 2005, when Lula attended Pope John Paul II's funeral in his first term, he brought along some of his political rivals, most notably his predecessor Fernando Henrique Cardoso. 8:15 That was a deliberate move to show that Brazil's democracy was, quote, civilized and mature. 8:22 In fact, Lula invited all former democratically elected presidents except for Fernando Coller, who was then mired in corruption scandals. Fast forward two decades, and that spirit of cross-party unity has evaporated. 8:39 The mere idea of Lula inviting far-right nemesis Jair Bolsonaro to join him in Rome is unthinkable, not least because the former president is awaiting trial for allegedly plotting a coup that included plans to assassinate Lula and other top officials. 8:59 Other presidents will also not be receiving invites. 9:03 Michel Temer, who stepped in as president after the impeachment of Lula's successor and ally Dilma Rousseff, is likely persona non grata in the government's camp, being seen as a coup monger. 9:16 Fernando Henrique Cardoso is in frail health and has retired from public life. Meanwhile, Lula did invite the heads of the Senate, Lower House and the Supreme Court to join him. 9:29 Between the lines, Brazil in 2025 is not the Brazil of 2005, and Lula, seasoned by two previous presidencies, is not the same politician. 9:40 The nation is more divided, more hostile and far less willing to look beyond party lines, even for a papal funeral. Read the full story in the April 22nd issue of our Brazil Daily Newsletter. 9:56 Premium subscribers to the Brazilian Report receive our Brazil Daily newsletters in their inbox every weekday morning, as well as our expert newsletters focusing on business, climate, agriculture and Latin America. 10:08 So please check out Brazilian.report for more information. And sign up for free today and you'll get access to our Brazil Sports and Brazil Society newsletters sent out every Saturday and Sunday. 10:22 In this week's Brazil Sports newsletter, we look at the historic victory of Brazil's Hugo Caldeireno in the Table Tennis World Cup as the sport seeks to capitalise on its post-Olympics popularity. 10:34 And on Sunday in our Brazil Society newsletter, we delve into a bill to renew the country's civil code, which is the heart of Brazilian private law. 10:42 There are hundreds of rules at stake, affecting not only the public interest but also the private interest of those involved in the proposals. Sign up now and read both for free. 10:53 If you like Explaining Brazil, please subscribe to our newsletter services. That is the best way to support our work. 11:02 Go to newsletters.brazilian.report slash upgrade and you can get two weeks for free with the best newsletter of the Americas according to the World Association of News Publishers. 11:17 This podcast was brought to you by the Brazilian Report and this episode of Explaining Brazil was presented by Ewan Marshall and myself, Gustavo Ribeiro. 11:26 Ewan Marshall also scripted this show and Andre Cavassa was in charge of sound engineering. Thanks for listening. Thanks for following us over this past six years and we'll see you on our website, brazilian.report. 11:42 Thank you very much.